UNIVERSITY PARK, Pa. — Opportunities to compete for a national championship don’t come around every season.

Penn State wasted a great one Saturday night, leaving emotional coach James Franklin to make a painful admission and then a promise after the 27-26 loss to No. 4 Ohio State.

“We’ve gone from an average program to a good program to a great program. But we’re not an elite program yet. We are going to break through and become an elite program. I will find a way. We will find a way. We are going to get this done. I give you my word. We are going to find a way to take the next step. We are done being great. It’s on me. You guys think I’ve been a psychopath in the past? You have no idea.”

With a chance to take control of the Big Ten Conference East Division and put itself in a prime position to qualify for the College Football Playoff, No. 9 Penn State came up small down the stretch, blowing a 26-14 lead in the final eight minutes. Not even a throbbing “White Out” crowd of 110,889 — the largest ever at Beaver Stadium — could lift Penn State to what would have been its 17th consecutive home win.

Advertise with us

A punishing loss?

To use Franklin’s words, you have no idea.

Three of Penn State’s four toughest remaining games are at home against Michigan State, Iowa and Wisconsin. It has to play at Michigan Nov. 3. A win over Ohio State would have left Penn State in position to go 12-0 in the regular season and play in the Big Ten championship.

Instead, when Beaver Stadium finally stopped shaking, it was Ohio State that emerged from this spectacular September night as an early playoff favorite with its stunning comeback.

“I’m pretty upset right now because I’m hurting for those guys in that locker room,” Franklin said. “I know how much they have invested and how hard they have worked. We didn’t finish the game the way we should have finished the game, no doubt about it.

Advertise with us

“No one is happy with this. Our fans aren’t happy. I’m not happy. I could say it’s a moral victory because we lost by one point to a higher ranked team. But I’m not going to do that. It’s not good enough.”

The Penn State defense, which played well for 3½ quarters, couldn’t stop Ohio State quarterback Dwayne Haskins Jr. on the Buckeyes’ final two drives. Haskins threw touchdown passes of 47 yards to wide receiver Binjimen Victor and 24 yards to receiver K.J. Hill Jr., that second score producing the winning touchdown with 2:03 left.

“You can’t give up those huge plays for touchdowns at the end of the game,” Franklin said. “The reality is we had opportunities. We didn’t make plays. We didn’t tackle in open space. We didn’t make plays when we needed to make plays.

“We should have finished that game.”

The Penn State loss also wasted a significant Heisman Trophy statement by quarterback Trace McSorley. His 461 total yards — 286 through the air and 175 on the ground on 25 carries — set a Penn State record. But with the game on the line at the end, with Penn State facing a fourth-and-5 on the Ohio State 43 with 1:22 left, the Penn State coaches didn’t give McSorley the chance to make a play despite calling two timeouts to discuss their strategy. McSorley’s handoff to Miles Sanders off right guard lost 2 yards. It was a bizarre play call.

Advertise with us

“We didn’t make the right call in that situation,” Franklin said. “Obviously, it didn’t work. That’s on me.”

It was fascinating how the game played out. Just about everyone expected a shootout, similar to Ohio State’s 39-38 win in Columbus last season. The teams came in with the two highest-scoring offenses in college football. The over/under betting line was a staggering 70½ points.

So what happened?

A defensive struggle for most of the game, of course.

This loss will sting Penn State for quite a while.

Advertise with us

The game shouldn’t have been close in the second half. Penn State should have won by blowout in the first half. It was much the better team in every way.

“We played a great first half,” Franklin said.

Going in, it didn’t seem as if the Penn State defense, much-maligned despite the Nittany Lions’ 4-0 start, would be able to contain an Ohio State offense that averaged 54.5 points and 559 yards in its first four games. Haskins Jr. was a Heisman favorite after completing 75.7 percent of his passes for 16 touchdowns with just one interception.

But the Penn State defense controlled Haskins and the game for almost two quarters. Maybe it was the energy provided by the White Out crowd. Or maybe Haskins wasn’t ready for that kind of incredible atmosphere in his first real road test. Whatever. Ohio State’s offense punted seven times in its first eight possessions. Haskins threw an interception to safety Garrett Taylor on the other. At that point, Ohio State had produced just 71 yards.

Unfortunately for Penn State, its offense wasted most of that great defense. It couldn’t take advantage of an Ohio State defense that was playing without injured star defensive end Nick Bosa, who could be the first selection in next spring’s NFL draft. Penn State settled for a 34-yard field goal by Jake Pinegar after a fabulous, one-handed catch by wide receiver Juwan Johnson for 31 yards to the Ohio State 17. Pinegar missed a 46-yard field goal after a 51-yard scramble by McSorley. Pinegar connected for another field goal from 39 yards to make it, 6-0, but Penn State could have had more after Taylor’s 45-yard interception return to the Ohio State 28.

Advertise with us

Penn State still was in good shape after a terrific play by wide receiver K.J. Hamler, turning a catch on a short crossing pattern into a 93-yard touchdown, the second-longest play from scrimmage in Penn State history. Hamler beat cornerback Shaun Wade across the middle, then simply ran away from him and the rest of the Ohio State defense to give Penn State a 13-0 lead. Is there a faster player in college football?

But a fumble at the Penn State 25 by Sanders turned the game Ohio State’s way. One play later, the Penn State defense finally broke, allowing running back J.K. Dobbins to turn a screen pass from Haskins into a 26-yard touchdown. That left Penn State with a very unsatisfying 13-7 lead at halftime.

A lead that didn’t hold up on night that will leave Franklin, the Penn State players and their fans wondering what could have been for a long time.

Ron Cook: rcook@post-gazette.com and Twitter@RonCookPG. Ron Cook can heard on the “Cook and Joe” show weekdays from 10 a.m. to 2 p.m. on 93.7 The Fan.

Do you appreciate good journalism? If you do, consider subscribing.

Support journalism. Subscribe today.