Penn State needs to get past some of its fans’ idea of the football uniform as a monument to the past.
I get it. Many of the traditions that mark it, from the nameless jerseys to the black shoes, go back decades. Many of them have their roots in the way Joe Paterno emphasized team over individual, substance over flash. Since his passing in 2012, a lot of people have clung even more tightly to “black shoes, basic blues, no names, all game” as the most visible representation of his complicated legacy in Happy Valley. Ask successor Bill O’Brien, who faced an uproar when he put names on the jerseys for a couple of years to honor players who stuck with the program through NCAA sanctions.
This isn’t Paterno’s program anymore, though. It hasn’t been in more than five years. It lives on and should continue to evolve with the university and the people it represents now.
So it was a little discouraging to hear coach James Franklin seem to politely dismiss the possibility of the team wearing a pink and black kit — as the basketball team did a few years ago as a nod to Penn State’s original colors — at an event Monday in York, Pa. Via PennLive.com.
“It’s a little bit different for football because our uniforms cost hundreds of thousands of dollars. It’s not as easy to do as with other sports.
“I don’t know if we’ll ever go to maybe pink because of the cost...I don’t know if that necessarily makes sense for us. One of the things that’s best about Penn State is how iconic our uniform is. And all of these other schools have to do all these crazy things to make a statement. Our statement is our history, and our traditions, and our values and who we are. That’s taken us a long way.”
First of all, give me a break. If Penn State can afford to renovate Beaver Stadium, it can afford alternate uniforms.
Second, no one is making a serious argument that Penn State alter its identity or turn into Oregon East. It’s fine, good even, to preserve the current uniform as the primary look and celebrate what it represents.
Read More
The question Franklin responded to was whether Penn State might wear pink for homecoming in a one-off, perhaps in conjunction with Breast Cancer Awareness Month in October. Similar ideas have been floated for years, notably by students and members of the football team itself.
And guess what? Franklin, despite voicing some of the same concerns he did Monday, seemed receptive to the ideas in these 2014 comments to The Daily Collegian.
"I think the basketball team has done it and had some success so hopefully that opens up the possibility of those things."
It seems he’s been reeled in by the JoePa Lobby since then, and that’s unfortunate. The Steelers also have iconic uniforms, and they’ve had some success with “throwback” inspired designs in recent years, from their 75th anniversary kit to the infamous bumble-bee jerseys. Big Ten rivals Michigan and Ohio State, which have a wee bit of tradition themselves, have tried several different looks as well.
Sometimes it’s fun to do something different. Not for every game. Not even every year. But every once in a while to spice things up. Especially when the idea is rooted in history and put forth by tuition-paying students and members of the team itself, and especially when modern-day recruits rank Penn State’s uniforms among the worst in college football.
Most other major college and professional teams have established this. The only reason Penn State hasn’t is resistance by Paterno, then by his supplicants, some of whom mistakenly see the program more as a manifestation of the old coach than the larger Penn State community.
It’s time to change that.
Sure, some of these people are season ticket holders who write big donation checks every year. If they want to drop their tickets because Penn State dared to change the uniforms as Paterno left them for one day, however, that shortfall will be more than made up by folks who want to snap up some baller new jerseys to wear to their tailgates.
Penn State should experiment with alternate uniforms, and doing so is not a matter of subverting Penn State’s history. It's about giving a new generation of fans and players some small bit of ownership of their own.
Adam Bittner: abittner@post-gazette.com and Twitter, @fugimaster24.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.