You may recognize the name.

Hayden Hurst is a 25-year-old rookie tight end for the Baltimore Ravens, and he’ll get his first crack at the Steelers, the team he grew up rooting for, on Sunday at M&T Bank Stadium. He’s also the same Hayden Hurst, a 6-foot-5 right-handed starting pitcher, whom the Pirates drafted six years ago, before a severe case of the yips ended his promising but brief baseball career.

Same guy, only now he has shoulder-length red hair, a beard and a smile.

“It’s night and day,” Hurst said Wednesday, three days after his first NFL touchdown catch against the Panthers. “I was in a pretty bad spot when I was with the Pirates. … A huge weight has been lifted off my shoulders. With football I can play free, cut it loose and just go be the athlete God made me.”

Advertise with us

As a kid, it was Hayden’s dream to play for the Pirates. His reality was three tortured years in pro ball spent fighting off loneliness and depression and trying to relearn how to command a baseball.

Jerry Hurst, Hayden’s father, was born in Murrysville and lived there until his own father’s job at an oil and natural gas company was transferred to Jacksonville, Fla. Jerry met his wife, Cathy, at The Bolles School, a prep school which their children, Kylie and Hayden, also attended.

Jerry passed down his Pittsburgh allegiances. “I hated the Ravens until about six months ago,” he said last week. Hayden joked his days as a Steelers fan “are probably gone.” This summer, Hayden texted his parents upset when the lights outside the Ravens’ stadium were turned red after the Washington Capitals won the Stanley Cup. If he’s invited to a Capitals game, Hayden told his mother, he’ll go. But he’ll wear a Penguins jersey.

“He’s still got some Pittsburgh blood running through him,” Cathy said.

Pittsburgh-bound

Advertise with us

Hayden was a big kid. In middle school, he grew five inches in a year, then five more the next. He felt growth pains in his feet. He needed Tommy John surgery at 13. He was 6-foot-3 and 205 pounds, pitching for Bolles’ varsity team in eighth grade.

Hayden played only one season of high school football, believing an injury could cost his family millions. On the pitcher’s mound, Hayden led Bolles to two state championships. His fastball touched 95 mph. Hayden accepted a full scholarship to play baseball at Florida State, though his draft grade — late first round to early second — suggested he’d never play there.

The Hursts held a draft party. Thirteen of the first 60 selections were high school right-handers. None were Hayden. He wasn’t drafted until Day 3, when the Pirates picked him in the 17th round.

Jerry later discovered Hayden’s agent, whose name he didn’t divulge, had falsely told teams Hayden wouldn’t sign for less than $1 million. So he tumbled down draft boards until the Pirates took a flier on him at pick No. 526.

Jerry fired the agent. Hayden and his father settled on $400,000 as their asking price — approximately third-round money. At around 11 p.m. the day before the signing deadline, Pirates then-scouting coordinator Jim Asher phoned Jerry and asked, “Is it still $400,000?”

Advertise with us

“Yes, sir,” Jerry replied.

“OK,” Asher said, and hung up.

Figuring that meant no deal, Jerry went upstairs to find Hayden, who was in bed. As they spoke, Jerry’s phone rang again. It was Asher. “Mr. Hurst,” he said. “All right, $400,000.”

Hayden burst out of bed. They celebrated and cried. The printer spit out three tickets to Pittsburgh.

Hayden Hurst started pitching for Bolles' varsity baseball team in eighth grade. He later won two high school state titles. (Courtesy Jerry Hurst)

A ‘mental wreck’

Advertise with us

Hayden’s minor league pitching ledger lists only one game. He entered for the Gulf Coast League Pirates on June 24, 2013, a year after the draft. Five batters. Five walks. Two wild pitches. Later that year, in an unofficial game on a back field at Pirate City in Bradenton, Fla., Hayden drilled a Baltimore Orioles batter in the head with a fastball, knocking him unconscious.

Whenever Hayden called his parents, he hid his anguish. “He felt like if he told us he’d be letting us down,” Jerry said. Over the next year, the Pirates tried to steer Hayden back on course. He met with psychiatrists, psychologists and even a hypnotist.

Hayden began working with Scott Elarton, a recently retired pitcher who’d joined the Pirates’ player development team. The outlook was bleak — with yips, Elarton said, “very few, if any guys return to what they once were” — but he wanted to help.

“I was just dumb enough to think I could help the kid get through it and get right,” Elarton said. “The natural ability that was there was major-league stuff. I thought, well heck, we’ll get him back to throwing strikes and move on down the road. I really had no idea what I was in for.”

They tried everything. Elarton gave Hayden targets to hit. The batter’s eye. The foul pole. The center of a hula hoop. Jerry would send Elarton research papers he’d found about curing yips. Elarton saw small progress, but it vanished as soon as Hayden stepped on the mound.

Advertise with us

Hayden was anxious and depressed. He spent almost all day in his dorm room.

“There definitely came a point where I was not worried at all about his baseball future,” Elarton said, “I was just worried about the guy as a person. He got super, super down.”

“He was a wreck,” Jerry added. “He was an absolute mental wreck.”

In 2014, Hayden tried hitting. He batted .245 in 15 games. He started waking up at 5:30 a.m. to lift in the weight room. There, he was in control. He got huge, one teammate remembered. He looked like a football player. “Guys kind of gave me some weird looks, like What are you doing?” Hayden said. “It’s just the way I’m wired, I guess.”

After the Pirates’ fall instructional league in 2014, Hayden considered his options. He and his parents toured Florida’s campus with a recruiting coordinator who felt he’d fit as a walk-on wide receiver. Hayden said he’d see how spring training went and then decide.

Advertise with us

Shortly after spring training, Elarton called Jerry and asked him to drive to Bradenton. Hayden had decided. They met in the clubhouse and talked about football. Later, from a parking lot in Siesta Key, Hayden phoned Larry Broadway, the Pirates director of minor league operations, to say he was retiring.

“I hope you find something in life that you can stick with,” Broadway told him.

When asked last week what he recalled from that conversation, Broadway responded via email, “Simply that. I wanted to challenge him with whatever he was going to do next in life to do it to the fullest.”

For Hayden, those words were fuel.

“After the phone call ended, I knew I didn’t have to wake up and go back to baseball all over again,” Hayden said. “I really exhausted all my resources trying to figure it out. It didn’t work.”

Advertise with us
The Hurst family — Kylie, Jerry, Cathy and Hayden — pose at their home in Jacksonville, Fla., prior to the 2018 NFL draft. (Courtesy Jerry Hurst)

From bust to Baltimore

Hayden walked on at South Carolina after Florida pulled its offer. He was a team captain his sophomore year and first-team All-SEC as a junior. He was given a familiar draft grade — late first round to early second. On draft day, Hayden stayed near home. He went to the beach, then watched the first round with his family and four close friends.

“He was fine until about the 20th pick,” Cathy said. “And then he got very quiet. I knew he started going through that, ‘Oh no, it's all happening over again. Oh my god.’ ”

Elarton was watching too. “I was honestly more nervous on his draft night than mine,” he said. Baltimore selected Hayden at No. 25, exactly where the Houston Astros drafted Elarton in 1994.

This fall, Hayden and his mother are finalizing the paperwork to establish the Hayden Hurst Family Foundation, which will provide funding for facilities and programs based in Jacksonville, Columbia, S.C., and Baltimore which address adolescent mental health issues.

Advertise with us

“Mental health has always hit home with the Hurst family,” Hayden said. Two extended family members died by suicide, and others, including Hayden, have dealt with depression.

When Hayden invited Elarton to a South Carolina game two years ago, Elarton was struck by the smile he saw beneath the face mask. “I could just see that he was happy,” he recalled. “After seeing where he'd been at, that, for me, was refreshing to see.”

Recently, Hayden caused controversy in the Elarton home. During the family’s fantasy football draft in August, Elarton’s son and daughter both wanted to draft Hayden in the first round. Since his daughter drafted Hayden first, his son got a Hurst No. 81 Ravens jersey to wear on Sundays. When Hayden heard that story, he laughed. He said he owes a lot to Elarton.

“To put it blankly, the guy pretty much saved my life,” Hayden said. “I was at a pretty low point with the Pirates. His guidance and the stuff he said to me day in and day out kept me going. He gave me the final shove in the right direction. I can’t thank him enough for it.”

Stephen J. Nesbitt: snesbitt@post-gazette.com and Twitter @stephenjnesbitt.

Advertise with us

Do you appreciate good journalism? If you do, consider subscribing.

Support journalism. Subscribe today.