It was the play that defined an ugly loss. The Pirates can only hope it doesn’t come to define any more than that.
With the bases loaded in the eighth, Chris Gimenez hit a grounder to shortstop, and Sean Rodriguez threw home. Elias Diaz caught the throw and stepped away from the plate to throw to first. Anthony Rizzo proceeded with his slide, clipping Diaz on the right leg. Diaz’s throw got away, two runners scored, and the Pirates catcher writhed in pain on the ground.
Diaz didn’t think Rizzo made a good slide; neither did his manager, Clint Hurdle, who was ejected when the play was reviewed but not overturned.
“When I saw the replay, I was like, ‘Man, this guy could have ended my career right here,’ ” Diaz said through interpreter Mike Gonzalez. “And I understand they called it a legal slide, but out of what I’ve been trained and what I’ve been told, that was not a legal slide.”
The Pirates lost badly on Monday. It wasn’t just the score, although a 7-0 shutout by a division rival during a long stretch against winning teams isn’t a move in the right direction.
The events surrounding the loss somehow made it worse: the fact that the Cubs reportedly had arrived at their hotel in Pittsburgh at 3:30 a.m. after a Sunday night game; the fact that the Pirates mustered only two hits off Chicago spot starter Mike Montgomery, who was perfect through 4 1/3 innings, and the Cubs bullpen; the fact that third baseman David Freese and third base coach Joey Cora got into a heated argument in the dugout after the game.
Read More
The Pirates (28-25) have dropped three in a row and eight of their last 10 games. The team assembled for a meeting after the game.
“What needed to be said actually was said,” Rodriguez said. “It was definitely spoken about. We definitely had to get together and some things were said. … It’s either you bond together and move forward together, become that much stronger, or let something like this obviously separate you.”
“We’ll take care of things in house,” Hurdle said when asked about the fight between Cora and Freese. “We do a lot of it. Sometimes you hear about it, sometimes you don’t.”
Home plate umpire Bill Welke said the slide was legal because Rizzo could touch the plate, according to Rodriguez.
“[Diaz] makes the play just like he’s supposed to make and he gets wiped out with a hard baseball slide,” Hurdle said. “There’s potential injury and I don’t see the rule fitting the means there. If it’s open season, it’s open season. Everybody is going to see the play and knows this is a play you can make on every catcher in his most vulnerable position.”
His Chicago counterpart, Joe Maddon, disagreed, calling Rizzo’s slide “a perfect play.”
“You’re teaching the fans the wrong things,” Maddon told reporters after the game. “You’re worried about not getting people hurt, but then Rizzo, in the eyes of the Pittsburgh fans, did something wrong or dirty, and that is absolutely incorrect.”
Rodriguez seemed to fall somewhere in the middle. Rodriguez said he would probably have tried to break up the double play at home, too, and he didn’t think Rizzo’s intent was malicious.
“Coming from somebody who obviously plays the game on that edge, on that fine line, it’s obviously open to interpretation,” Rodriguez said. “Everyone is going to have their own opinion on it. … Did he go out of his way to go hit him? That’s what it looked like on the replay.”
The Pirates did not retaliate. When Rizzo stepped up to the plate in the ninth, Pirates fans loudly booed him, an effect that was somewhat counterbalanced by the large contingent of Cubs supporters at the game. Diaz, who had remained in the game, said Rizzo apologized to him.
“He said it was a difficult play, and he apologized, and I waved him off and said let’s just play ball,” Diaz said.
Richard Rodriguez threw a wild pitch against Rizzo, and two runners advanced, later scoring on Rizzo’s single.
Diaz didn’t seem overly concerned about his leg, although Francisco Cervelli, who was off for the second consecutive game due to flu-like symptoms, was available if absolutely needed, Hurdle said.
“For me to come out of that game, he needed to break my leg,” Diaz said.
While Corey Dickerson’s fielding and a gritty six-inning performance from Chad Kuhl put the Pirates in a decent position, they could muster no offense against Montgomery, who entered the game with a 5.33 ERA. Having not started all season, Montgomery faced the minimum for five innings, gave up two singles and walked none over 5 2/3 innings. The Pirates generated no other offense.
Kuhl struggled early with his command but ultimately settled in for a fine outing. He gave up a solo homer to Rizzo and walked four, including three in the third inning. Dickerson robbed Kyle Schwarber of a homer in left field and made another fine sliding grab in short left field. Of Kuhl’s 93 pitches, 32 were sliders and 53 were strikes.
“One of those games where it could have easily gotten away, but it’s really nice to just battle and get through six just giving up one run,” Kuhl said.
For the first time all season, Steven Brault pitched two games in a row, and he gave up a two-run homer to pinch-hitter Addison Russell.
Elizabeth Bloom: ebloom@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1750 and Twitter @BloomPG.
Clarification, posted May 29, 2018: A paragraph that broadly described the Pirates' attitudes toward Anthony Rizzo's slide was removed because it did not precisely reflect the referenced individuals' viewpoints on that play.



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.