WASHINGTON — Even with the 2015 All-Star Game three weeks away, there has been little speculation in the Pirates clubhouse about who will represent the team at Great American Ball Park in Cincinnati. The way Tony Watson sees it, the Pirates, currently the second-best team in the National League, “have too good a thing going” to think ahead.
A.J. Burnett hasn’t said a word about it, either, but the 38-year-old right-hander with a 6-3 record and 2.05 ERA in 14 starts this season could be in line for the first All-Star appearance of his 17-year major league career. Jeff Locke, his closest accomplice on the Pirates, broke the silence.
“There’s no way, in my eyes, A.J. shouldn’t be at that game this year,” said Locke, a 2013 All-Star. “It has nothing to do with this being his final year. This isn’t his last year on the Hall of Fame ballot, so let’s just get him in. It’s not like that. He’s definitely earned his way to being in that game this year.”
Burnett, who likely will make four more starts before the All-Star break, hasn’t missed out on much else. A two-time World Series champion, he’s thrown a no-hitter, has 161 career wins and is 37th on the all-time strikeout list, with 2,451. In 2012, Burnett was left off the National League roster despite boasting a 10-2 record and 3.28 ERA when the All-Star teams were announced.
“How that happens,” Locke said, “I’m not sure.”
The next year, Burnett stumped for Locke, who made the team with an 8-2 record and 2.15 ERA. It was only then when Locke realized Burnett never had been an All-Star. Locke recalled Burnett teasing him that the honor was “the only thing you’ll ever have that I don’t.”
The Pirates might get two starting pitchers in the All-Star Game for the first time since 1960, when Bob Friend and Vernon Law went. Gerrit Cole (11-2) ranks second among National League starters with a 1.78 ERA, and Burnett is fourth. Their matching 2.3 Wins Above Replacement totals are tied for fourth, too.
While position players are voted upon by fans — a controversial process of late because seven of nine Kansas City Royals are currently slated to start for the American League — pitchers are selected by the votes of players, coaches and managers.
Closer Mark Melancon, another 2013 All-Star, called the nomination a “special honor” and “privilege,” while Locke and Watson, who went in 2014, agreed the selection process for pitchers means more because it isn’t a “popularity contest.”
“The All-Star Game is so fixed in so many ways, with the fan voting,” Locke said. “I know when I went to the All-Star Game in 2013 it’s almost like you were prouder and appreciated it more knowing you’re not selected by the fans. You’re selected because you were one of the best.”
The biggest blemish on Burnett’s All-Star case came Friday night when the Washington Nationals managed 14 hits, a career-worst. Still, Burnett held them to three earned runs over 6⅔ innings, and, in a way, it was a “perfect example” of Burnett’s mastery, Locke said.
Locke recalled a point in the game at which right-hander Charlie Morton turned to him and said, “Geez, I’d take that outing every time out. Yeah, you’d have an 8.00 WHIP, but you’re keeping the team in the game every time you go out.”
Burnett, who went 8-18 in 2014 and led the league in earned runs and walks, set a franchise record this year by allowing two runs or fewer in his first nine starts. It’s like he has found “a fountain of youth,” Locke said, echoing many around the league. Burnett’s simple explanation is he has learned to pitch, not just to throw. And he is as fearless as ever.
“The guy is 38 years old, I’m 11 years younger, and I promise you I never want him to see on my face that I’m tired,” Locke said. “He’s 38 and he doesn’t look tired. Why should I?”
There has been no sweeping social-media charge to get Burnett to the All-Star Game. It’s only folks around the majors who need to be convinced, and they’ll hear from the Pirates. Manager Clint Hurdle, for one, said “it would be fantastic” to see Burnett pitch July 14 in Cincinnati.
“If there’s any way, shape or form we could influence whether or not he gets to go to that game, I think everybody would be on board,” Locke said. “Not because this is it for him, but because he deserves the recognition.”
Stephen J. Nesbitt: snesbitt@post-gazette.com and Twitter @stephenjnesbitt.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.