We’ve all done this long enough to know: There’s a difference between watching Sidney Crosby play a hockey game and watching A Sidney Crosby Hockey Game.

The former has happened about 100 times this season. The latter is a little different; it’s an event. There’s an exertion of will. The man, more than anyone else currently in his sport, can control his environment.

On Thursday night, in Game 5 of the Stanley Cup final, we got one of those, and we knew it five seconds in, when he split Predators defensemen Roman Josi and Ryan Ellis, dragged Ellis toward Pekka Rinne and fired a shot off the post.

“Sid led the charge from the first shift and the rest of the team followed up,” center Matt Cullen said.

Advertise with us

Then, Crosby spent 59:50 reinforcing what we know about him to be true. That’s why people here love him, and why plenty elsewhere hate him. Of course, Ellis wound up in the penalty box. Of course, Justin Schultz scored on the ensuing power play off a feed from Crosby, the first detonation in a 6-0 demolition that’d shift momentum, if momentum were real. Of course Crosby added two more assists, finally finding some 5-on-5 domination in a reunion with Jake Guentzel and Conor Sheary.

He’s still the best hockey player on the Earth. He’s also still a hockey player, though — capable of hitting levels that most others couldn’t find with a map, but as prone to as much in-the-moment greasiness as nearly anyone else. It’s not about taking the bad with the good. It’s just … the way it is. It’s part of the Sidney Crosby experience.

We saw it for sure late in the second period, when he got tied up with Predators defenseman P.K. Subban — he of the endless Listerine bit and in-game targeting throughout the series — and, uh, did some stuff.

There they were, on the ice. You could see Crosby bouncing Subban’s head off it from the press box. What wasn’t clear right off the bat was that Subban, who’d lost his stick, had applied the Ken Shamrock ankle lock. These things tend to be cyclical.

“I dunno what he was doing, some UFC move on my foot,” Crosby said. “I dunno what he was trying to do but, I was trying to get out of there. He had lost his stick. He was just trying to hold me down. I dunno what he was trying to do my ankle there, but …”

Advertise with us

So that’s why you did the thing with his head?

“Yeah. I was just trying to — I was in some kind of lock there.”

Lock or not, it was an easy thing to criticize; Sidney Crosby, the face of brain injury awareness, dribbling another player’s helmeted skull. Predators coach Peter Laviolette didn’t like it. Subban wasn’t overly concerned.

“It’s hockey, man,” Subban said. He shrugged off the fact that both wound up in the penalty box, even though an ankle lock is objectively lower on the totem pole of injurious plays than whatever Crosby did to him. While he was there, Evgeni Malkin scored the Penguins’ third goal of the game. Then, the first period ended. The game wasn’t decided, but it felt close.

Someone from Nashville watches that, and it’s Crosby getting away with garbage because of who he is. Someone from Pittsburgh watches that, and it’s Crosby doing what he has to do to get out of the latest bit of targeted harassment. Both can be true. Both probably are.

Advertise with us

Love our Pens coverage? Consider subscribing.

Support journalism. Subscribe today.

Asked if things had gotten personal with Subban, Crosby shrugged. “Nah, I mean, everyone’s out there trying to compete. He’s trying to do his job and I’m trying to do mine. Both teams want the same thing, so they’re both doing their best to go out there and try to accomplish it.”

Still, it was intense and ridiculous enough to make it seem eminently possible that Crosby, in the second period, deliberately hurled a water bottle on the ice. He’s come unhinged! If the initial evidence was damning, he did a better job explaining himself there than regarding Subban.

He said the bottle flew out of his hand while he was trying to make a gesture. “I wouldn’t start throwing water bottles at this point. I haven’t done it yet,” he said. “I have a better arm than that, anyway.”

Advertise with us

Sidney Crosby explains the water bottle toss

Most of it is Crosby being himself, for better or worse, just like his opening-shift statement was him at his best. Cullen called him “an inspiration.” Chris Kunitz, Crosby’s linemate for the majority of their careers, called it the sort of play “that drives everybody to try and be better and go out there and work.”

Mike Sullivan, after the Penguins officially came within one game of another Cup, put it better.

“I think that's an indication of his leadership and his will to win, and so, you know, I think Sid really understands the opportunity that this team has, and he's not taking anything for granted. He's as driven an athlete as I've seen. He's as hungry as I've seen a player, and [I just think] he understands it.

“He sees the opportunity in front of us, and he's doing everything within his power to try to help us be successful.”

Yep, everything. Most of it is legal, and all of it is him.

Advertise with us

Sean Gentille: sgentille@post-gazette.com, Twitter: @seangentille.

Fans celebrate the Penguins' 6-0 win against the Predators in Game 5