OTTAWA, Ontario – If any NHL team should be able to process the impact that a superb goaltending performance can have on a playoff game, it's the Penguins.

Whether it's been Marc-Andre Fleury or Matt Murray, the Penguins have gotten both.

On Tuesday, with a chance to close out the Eastern Conference final against the Ottawa Senators in Game 6, the tables were turned.

The Penguins mostly played the way they wanted to, checking pretty much every box except for beating Craig Anderson more than once. As a result, they suffered a 2-1 loss at Canadian Tire Centre that sends this series back to a Game 7 Thursday in Pittsburgh.

Advertise with us

"I thought we were pretty good [Tuesday]," Trevor Daley said. "We didn’t get the bounces that we probably deserved tonight. That’s hockey. That’s the way it goes. There was a couple nights that happened to us, and it went the other way. It is what it is. If we do a lot the same at home, we’ll be fine."

The Penguins threw 46 shots on goal at Anderson. Only one from Evgeni Malkin beat him. The Penguins also had a 75-46 edge in attempted shots, an indication of how much they dominated possession.

The only hiccups were a five-on-three power-play goal for the Senators, the Penguins’ inability to do anything on their own power play and the fact that Matt Murray was screened on the Senators' second goal, a rocket of a shot from Mike Hoffman at 1:34 of the third period.

All in all, nothing to freak out over.

"I think we played the way we needed to, honestly," Murray said. "Credit to them. They played a solid, defensive game. At the same time, we were controlling the play for the most part. Anderson had a big night. If not for him, it’s a different result. We just keep our same focus. Worry about what we’re doing. I think today we played the way we needed to.”

Advertise with us

Even the game-winning goal was a bit of a fluke. Or one where you tip your cap, although that isn't exactly Murray's style.

Mike Hoffman got it at 1:34 of the third period. Powerful shot from above the left circle. Clank, clank and in.

Murray was screened on the play. Hoffman waits just long enough before unleashing a powerful shot.

"I’m not really one to tip my cap," Murray said. "He’s a good shooter. He’s one of the best shooters in the league. I just tried to be aggressive. I knew there wasn’t a pass option. He did a really good job at holding it and waiting for that screen to get to the net. The guy in front, I think it might have been [Mark] Stone skated by right at the release point. I was late picking it up. He puts a pretty good shot post and in. That was a pretty good shot."

Some good news for the Penguins and their fans: Ottawa has never won a Game 7 in its history, going 0 for 5 when faced with that situation.

Advertise with us

The Penguins, meanwhile, failed to close out a series on their first try for the third time these playoffs and fifth consecutive time overall.

Now, they face the challenge of trying to win their third consecutive Game 7 and second during this postseason run.

"We know how to play in these types of games," Bryan Rust said. "We’re going to be at home in front of our fans. That’s going to give us a bit of a boost. We’re going to come out with a lot of energy."

A disallowed goal loomed large in this one.

At 3:04 of the second, Daley pushed a puck through in a scrum. Ottawa coach Guy Boucher argued for goaltender interference.

Advertise with us

The easiest way to explain the reversal is this: Daley kept pushing Anderson while the puck was away, preventing him from making the save.

Or at least that’s how those reviewing the call interpreted it.

"I didn’t agree with it," Matt Cullen said. "Those are 50/50s nowadays. It’s hard to know exactly where those stand. I don’t know if anybody is 100-percent sure which direction those are going to go. It’s the breaks of the game. We always handle the adversity really well. I thought again tonight we did. We responded. We played well. We just weren’t able to finish it."

Malkin put the Penguins ahead, 1-0, at 4:51. He curled out to the bottom of the right circle, with Ottawa’s Zach Smith trailing him. Anderson stopped Malkin’s initial shot, but Malkin backhanded the rebound to complete a fantastic individual effort.

A bad turnover from Olli Maatta nearly resulted in the Senators tying the score, but Bobby Ryan misfired on a pass to Derick Brassard.

Advertise with us

Ryan would atone for the gaffe, however, when he tied the score at 13:15 of the second.

The Penguins were down a pair of defensemen when Ron Hainsey went off for interference and Ian Cole picked up two minutes for high-sticking just 36 seconds later.

Without their two best penalty-killing defensemen, the Penguins gave up a power-play goal for the first time this series, Ryan blasting a one-timer from Kyle Turris from the right circle.

That snapped an 0-for-29 skid for Ottawa’s power play, which hadn’t scored since April 27. Their first power-play goal in 11 games snapped a scoreless stretch of 98:16.

The Penguins generated a ton of offense. Malkin produced seven shots on goal and Sidney Crosby six, including a pair of backhand attempts. In the second period alone, the Penguins registered 23 shots on goal to 10 for the Senators.

Advertise with us

Crosby was also a consistent presence around the goal mouth, another good sign. Two that weren't: Stone elbowing him in the head and Kyle Turris tackling him, evidence of how much attention the Senators paid to Crosby.

Love our Pens coverage? Consider subscribing.

Support journalism. Subscribe today.

“We generated a lot of good chances,” Crosby said. “You got to convert on those. But the chances were there. If we bring that same effort in Game 7, we’ll give ourselves a good chance.”

After three games, there was not a good feeling after a Penguins loss in this building.

Advertise with us

Way different Tuesday.

A sense of what they've done the past two games: just keep playing the way they want and a belief that the dam will eventually break.

“We’ve been in this situation before,” Daley added. “We’re a confident team in here. We have a lot of veteran guys. We’ve been here before. We know what we need to do to get the job done in Game 7.”

Jason Mackey: jmackey@post-gazette.com and Twitter @JMackeyPG.