This probably shouldn’t happen.
When the Penguins and Washington Capitals renew their rivalry Thursday at Verizon Center, introductions won’t be necessary. Despite an NHL salary-cap structure that encourages parity — and often prevents continuity — these bitter rivals have enjoyed remarkable runs of consistency.
There have been a few notable changes from the Penguins’ six-game series win a season ago — Jake Guentzel next to Sidney Crosby, Marc-Andre Fleury in goal, the Capitals acquiring defenseman Kevin Shattenkirk — but the majority of those involved hold vivid, first-hand memories from the teams’ most recent playoff meeting.
Familiarity breeds contempt? For an odd change in the transient world of professional sports, yes.
“It’s a unique situation,” Matt Cullen said. “Both teams have a lot of guys back. It’s not often that, with the salary cap and everything, you can bring a similar team back. It makes for an interesting matchup. I think it will make for an interesting series.”
Penguins players prepare for Game 1 against Washington
Ron Hainsey, Guentzel, Scott Wilson and Carter Rowney are the only Penguins skaters who will be completely new to this playoff rivalry.
Read More
Hainsey was acquired from Carolina via trade Feb. 23. Guentzel scored 16 goals in 40 regular-season games as a rookie, then added five more in the Eastern Conference quarterfinals. Wilson was hurt this time last year, and Rowney — likely a healthy scratch for Game 1 assuming Chris Kunitz returns from a lower-body injury — spent 2015-16 in the AHL with Guentzel.
The most significant change, however, could involve a player who was part of the series last year, just not in a starring role. Or a starting one.
Fleury knows the Capitals as well as anybody on this team but was relegated to bench duty for the duration of the series as Matt Murray’s backup.
With Murray out with a lower-body injury — he hasn’t skated since April 12 — Fleury is back in a familiar spot. In the playoffs, the Penguins’ No. 1 goalie, trying to stop Capitals captain Alex Ovechkin.
“Obviously, he’s one of the better players in the league,” Fleury said. “He still has a very solid shot. But [the Capitals] are more than that. They’re a good team. They have good depth. That’s why they’ve had success over the past few years here.”
The biggest absence for the Penguins will be Kris Letang, who is out for the season after neck surgery. Fellow defenseman Ben Lovejoy was the only regular skater the Penguins did not retain from last season, as he left for New Jersey in free agency.
The Capitals added third-line center Lars Eller at the NHL draft for second-round picks in 2017 and 2018. The Capitals gave up forward Zach Sanford, a 2017 first-round draft pick and a conditional future second-round pick to get the big fish at the trade deadline in Shattenkirk.
Brett Connolly was a depth acquisition July 1 and blossomed into a 15-goal scorer. Other than that, there have been no significant alterations, the upside of having just three unrestricted free agents and plenty of good health. (The Capitals had an NHL-low 49 man-games lost to injury in 2016-17.)
“They have depth, guys who are real good players up and down their lineup,” Bryan Rust said. “I think that’s going to be a challenge for us, to match their depth and play evenly throughout all four lines and all 60 minutes.”
‘It was a big deal’
A five-game victory over the New York Rangers in the Eastern Conference quarterfinals a season ago was great, but beating the Capitals in this series was really what bred belief.
“It was a big series for us to get past them,” Cullen said. “The season they had last year, much like this year, it was a big deal for us beating them on our way to winning it. Once again, it will be a huge challenge.”
For all the similarities between then and now, one difference could be significant. Crosby and Evgeni Malkin weren’t terrible against the Capitals in 2016, but they combined for just one goal and four points.
The biggest source of offense became the HBK line, which combined for seven goals and 18 points. Carl Hagelin’s speed turned into the Capitals’ Kryptonite.
Hagelin hasn’t played since March 10 because of a lower-body injury but returned to practice in a non-contact capacity Wednesday, his skating plenty crisp.
While Hagelin won’t be ready for Game 1, welcoming him back mid-series appears to be a perfectly reasonable expectation.
Until then, Sullivan wants the Penguins to take a by-committee approach to ensure the speed element to their game remains, an absolute must if they want to dethrone the Presidents’ Trophy-winning Capitals for the ninth time in 10 playoff meetings.
“We’ve got plenty of speed throughout our lineup,” Sullivan said. “That’s obviously part of the fabric of this team’s identity and its competitive advantage. We’re trying to play to that. It’s not like we’re going to change our lineup whether Hagy’s in our lineup or he’s not. We do think we’re a more competitive team when we have him.”
Home-road again key
The Penguins played three games against the Capitals last postseason at PPG Paints Arena — then Consol Energy Center — and won them all, two in overtime. They went 1-2 at Verizon Center, falling once in overtime.
That tracks to how this season has played out, too.
The Penguins and Capitals were the best two home teams in the NHL in the regular season, tying for the league lead with 66 points; Washington (32) recorded one more home win.
Obviously the Penguins don’t do something completely different on the road, but counterpunching the Capitals’ attack in the middle of a raucous building likely will be a particularly stiff challenge in this one.
“It’s a great atmosphere,” said Kunitz, who expects to return from a lower-body injury for Game 1. “It’s going to be tough.
“They’re going to be just as urgent we will be. We want to go out there and do our best to beat them in a series.”
Despite averaging nearly a goal per game less on the road than at home — 3.0 compared to 3.8 — the Penguins have some seriously drastic home/road splits in goal.
Fleury was 14-3-2 with a 2.52 goals-against average at PPG Paints Arena in the regular season. On the road, those numbers turned sour: 4-7-5, 3.58 and .887.
“It doesn’t matter,” Fleury said. “It’s all about the next one.”
Fleury admitted he is more comfortable at home, but that doesn’t adequately address why the numbers are so different.
“We’re home a lot,” Fleury said. “I’ve played in the building. I’m more used to it, but it’s not an excuse to be better at home than on the road.”
In Game 4 against Columbus, the Penguins came out flat and never recovered. Sullivan knows that if they do that against Washington, in this building, breaking serve on the road will be next to impossible for them.
“It starts with a mindset,” Sullivan said. “Our leadership group, they have a lot of experience. They’ve been through this before. They know what to expect. We trust that these guys are excited to play and are going to get the job done.”
The X-factors
Guentzel led all NHL players with five goals in the opening round, including a hat trick in Game 3. He became the first NHL rookie with five goals in his first four playoff games since Maurice “Rocket” Richard in 1944.
At least for Game 1, it looks like Sid and the Kids is no more; Patric Hornqvist will occupy Conor Sheary’s spot as Crosby’s right wing. Whoever winds up there, though, Guentzel’s quick release will be a focal point in a series that figures to be short on time and space for all involved.
“He gets it,” Sullivan said of Guentzel. “When we show him film or have a conversation with him about certain situations, he gets it. You tell him once, and he understands. He’s got an awareness both with and without the puck at both ends of the rink, and he’s competitive. He’s a real smart player. I think his hockey sense might be his biggest asset.”
Fleury came out of the bullpen in relief against Columbus, then reprised his longtime role as a starting goaltender.
He punched up a .933 save percentage and a 2.52 goals-against average while making 49 of 51 stops in the clincher, setting franchise records for playoff wins (57) and games played (105) for a goalie.
“We’ve been very fortunate to have two world-class goaltenders all season long,” defenseman Ian Cole said. “Sure, everyone was a little worried when Murray went out, but everyone in this room had confidence in Marc-Andre to step in and really put together the performance that he did in Round 1.”
In addition to Connolly’s breakout year, Eller produced 12 goals in Washington, one of an NHL-high 11 players for the Capitals with that many or more.
The Penguins have 10 players with a dozen or more goals, tied with Nashville for second most among the teams left in the postseason.
Shattenkirk, meanwhile, contributed two goals and 14 points in 19 games with the Capitals since the trade. His performance against the Maple Leafs in the Eastern Conference quarterfinals was not great, however: no goals, three points, a minus-4, helping the Capitals’ shot-attempt game at a 48.4-percent clip.
But the Penguins aren’t fooled. They know the Capitals are a good team, the best in the NHL for the second regular season in a row. And if that wasn’t enough, perhaps the Penguins know this because they either looked in a mirror or flipped back mentally to last spring, thinking about things such as depth scoring and the ability to drive your opponent nuts.
“We’re pretty similar,” Crosby said. “You believe in what gets you to this point. I think both teams believe in their game, believe in what they have to do. You need to have that confidence in your game to get this far.”
Jason Mackey: jmackey@post-gazette.com and Twitter @JMackeyPG.
Scouting report
Who: Penguins vs. Washington Capitals.
When, where: 7:30 p.m. Thursday, Verizon Center, Washington.
Look, listen: NBC Sports Network, WXDX-FM (105.9), PittsburghPenguins.com.
Noteworthy: Penguins are 8-1 all-time in playoff series against Washington; Capitals goalie Braden Holtby led the NHL with nine shutouts this season; Penguins goalie Marc-Andre Fleury is 11-5-2 all-time at the Verizon Center; Capitals winger T.J. Oshie led the team with seven points in the first-round series against Toronto; Penguins center Sidney Crosby is one multi-point playoff game away from tying Mario Lemieux for the franchise record (51); Capitals lead the NHL with 121 overall wins since the beginning of last season.
Did you know? Of the Penguins’ eight postseason series wins against Washington, they trailed at some point in the series in seven of them.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.