Mike White: Sorry a few minutes late. Needed to finish that "bear claw" danish. Ready to go. Fire away.
Willie Hunnids: Will Riverview ever win a game again?
Mike White: Ahhhh, they've won two in a row.
WPIAL 2A: In your opinion what do you think the committee will value most when seeding 2A? Seemingly there will need to be a lot of discussions as to strength of schedule/conference champs/ By the looks of it, the first 6/7 seeds will all be very very good and seeding will be critical.
Mike White: Lot depends on next week's Shady Side-Avonworth game. If Shady Side wins, they'll undoubtedly be No. 1 seed. If Avonworth wins, three-way for first with Steel Valley. Question is what do you do with Burgettstown? They're going to likely finish undefeated. But I don't see them getting one of top two seeds, just because of the strength of that conference. Would the WPIAL even push them down to 4?
Fawn Lebowitz: Two questions. Why no love for USC in your rankings (and a 3-5 team in 6a) ? And why can't Chartiers Valley ever get its act together with Football ? They have a comparable tax base and population to Mt Lebanon and South Fayette and Bethel but can't ever be any good. Why is that ?
Read More
Mike White: To Fawn, Can't put USC ahead of West A. Same record and West A beat them. Penn-Trafford been playing better lately. USC has had other close games. ... As for Char vValley I have no idea. ... As for why a 3-5 team at No. 5 in 6A?? Well who do you suggest we put in there?? Remember there are only nine teams in 6A. Right now, Mt. Lebanon has leg up on finishing as No. 5 team. So what else are we supposed to do?
PHAlum: Think Penn Hills will finish the season strong and make a run?
Mike White: Yes, they will finish undefeated. I would expect them to play Gateway in finals, but still some pretty good teams in 5A besides Gateway. 5A and 2A are the strongest classes.
WestmorelandWill: At this point in the season....is there a team that you expected more from that underachieved a bit (or quite a bit)?
Mike White: Sorry for delays answering. Wi-fi problems here at the White House. Should be good now.
Mike White: To WestmorelandWill. Montour's 0-5 start was a little shocking, considering the past. But Sweet Lou's team has won five in a row and is scoring points now. Big game vs. Beaver this week because it will decide third place in conference. Finish fourth and you probably get TJ in first round. Not good.
‘T’ from Green Tree: Are the Quips that good or are they in a weak conference...or a little of both?
Mike White: Both. They are good. Very good. That was expected. And I don't think 3A is all that strong and that conference isn't exactly full of juggernauts, either. Beaver County football doesn't look like it's as strong as it used to be overall.
GH: How about that Burgettstown team...undefeated thus far!!
Mike White: How about them? Haven't finished regular season undefeated since 1974.
Todd: Montour is starting to find its footing...will Montour make the playoffs?
Mike White: They're already in playoffs. Even if Montour loses final two games, they will be tied with either Knoch or Highlands. Montour beat both, so they will go.
John Steigerwald: Mike, I respect both Palko and Walker, but I think its great they are being called on the carpet for wanting to change the rules for their matchup this week. If both teams want to play the JVs the whole night, that is fine. Don't change the rules though
Mike White: Johnny, I totally get West A and NA and what they were thinking. I don't blame them. Looking back, if they wanted to do this, they probably should've just agreed to play shortened quarters in second half. But as it stands now, they will play regular game. They have taken plenty of heat on social media. The thing has stoked many opinions. I understand NA and West A. I also understand the people who say this shouldn't happen. It doesn't look good. It's good now.
Quad North Fan: So, here we go. Its down to the last two weeks in 6A. SV has looked pretty good defensively, while P-R has been good but inconsistent on offense. Do you think SV has enough on the defensive side to hold P-R under 28? I don't think SV has enough on offense to get more than 2 scores so it may not matter. Then next week you have P-R at NA. I think SV may be a tougher test for the Rams than NA, but the Tigers, coming off their bye week should be well rested. That will be an triply interesting game with the conference championship up for grabs, NA coming off a bye week, and last years band/flag/banning incident.
Mike White: I think Phil took the flag to Notre Dame, so there will be no incident and no one will be barred from field hockey games. ... As for Seneca, they can't score enough to beat Pine. I disagree about Pine's offense. They don't seem to have trouble scoring points.
HeyMike: Any update on the private/public school separated playoffs
Mike White: No except there are no plans in PIAA for it to happen.
Le’veon Bell: 2A has some depth at the top end of the classification. With Shady Side being a clear #1 how do you personally seed the next 4 or 5 teams as it stands today?
Mike White: It all could change in a week. And you can't say as it stands today because Avonworth hasn't played Shady Side yet. That means a lot. Too hard to call until that game.
QB: What year did HS football begin to get some much coverage- TV and newspapers?
Mike White: Not sure about TV. but it has gotten plenty of coverage in newspapers - even before my time. I go back and look at microfilm of Post-Gazette in the 60s and stories were on front page of sports often. A few pages inside of Friday coverage. I think the Friday night coverage started to increase maybe in the 90s. But hey, they used to read all of the scores on Friday night TV.
John: JV games should be mandatory to play. Too many blowouts and kids not getting enough reps. If your not playing on Friday night you should be on Saturday morning
Mike White: No they shouldn't. If you only have, say, 24 kids on your team, maybe you don't have enough to play JV. You can't MAKE teams play a game like JV. It's a numbers thing with JV games.
Sir: Wm and bv close game most of way . Wm was missing one of best defensive players at DE due to suspension. If they play them in the playoffs w/ BV quarterback out and having a healthy defense Wm can give them a game. Especially if they decide to pass a little bit. Bv dbs were getting blown up all night
Mike White: I would hardly say Belle Vernon DBs were getting blown up all night. West Mifflin QB threw for 147 yards and threw only 14 times. I think he was intercepted twice. Hardly blowing up BV DBs. I was at the game. I thought Belle Vernon was in control the entire game.
Jinx: Do you think charleroi will get one of the top four seeds??
Mike White: They should win their conference and I think, yes, that should give them a top four seed. If Shady Side beats Avonworth, Charleroi is an easy top 4 seed. If Avonworth wins, I still think Charleroi should get top 4 seed, but it will be a mess then.
Quad North Fan: What's going on at Norwin. Have some great individual talent, but they are looking at missing the playoffs after a big loss at home to an improving CMAC?
Mike White: Maybe all that "great" individual talent isn't all that great. Just sayin.
1A Mess: Why did the WPIAL change the 1A playoff structure? There are going to be teams that have two to three losses that will miss out. Why not break up the 1A Eastern Conference? Top four teams in that conference are most likely better than first second and third place teams in other conferences. There is no balance and little room for other schools to improve. It doesnt help the dwindling numbers if your team goes 8 and 2 or 7 and 3 and cant make the playoffs.
Mike White: I have no problem with it. Top two teams in each conference qualify as well as two third-place teams. What's wrong with that? People complain when conferences aren't set up with geography in mind. Then some complain competitiveness should be taken into account. Everyone wants everything. The WPIAL cut the Class A field to eight because they said they felt a field of 16 lets too many bad teams in and the blowouts in Class A games in the first round were getting out of hand. I don't have a problem with it.
Late’veon Bell: When I win the mega millions tonight I’m starting a school like IMG. The catch is that it will be dedicated to the art of sports writing/coverage. Will you be the President if the school? Figured it’d be real easy to flip half a billion into a trillion with my plan and you together.
Mike White: Woooo-hoooo. Hey, Late'veon will be here all week. Tip your waitresses. Try the veal.
Hs fan : Why are the egomaniac coaches allowed free reign at so many wpial schools even when they're not winning?
Mike White: Tremendous insight.
Tigerbeat : Can we all pray to the good lord baby Jesus that this NA WA thing will get the WPIAL back to letting teams schedule their non conference games? The fact that it is “random” but we get so many marquee matchups is a total line of Bs.
Mike White: Tigerbeat. I agree. No way it's all random. Some of if it is, but not all of it, no matter what WPIAL says. When Clairton played Aliquippa Tim O'Malley said that game was set up. I think the WPIAL might let teams schedule their own nonconference games. But hey, it used to be that way and teams then asked WPIAL to schedule all games. WPIAL gets criticized a lot. Some of it is just. But many times, it is not. Everyone wants things their own way.
Peter Griffin: Any chance the wpial will go to a Gardner point system? This would create good competitive sections in 5 and 6a. It would also eliminate the situation occurring this week having a meaningless non conference games late in the season....all games would have meaning.
Mike White: Have no idea what you're asking. Gardner Points is a system used to break ties for playoff spots.
WashCoFan: What's going on at Ringgold? Football and basketball are embarrassing. Used to have great athletes.
Mike White: What's going on is they are bad. Sometimes that happens. I don't think there is much talent there now. Hey, two years ago Ringgold was 8-3.
1st Timer: Mike, I've seen this happen twice this year. With HS rules, the 25 second play clock doesn't start until the head official blows the play in. Different crews set the ball at different times. At the end of the game, it looks like coaches don't know if they are able to "take a knee" to run the clock out or not... Do you think HS will ever adopt a rule like NCAA or NFL that immediately starts the play clock after the previous play ends?
Mike White: I don't know of such a movement.
City Footballer: I saw Brashear didn't make the city playoffs. I know the city is down but how many years has it been since this has happened? 15, 20, 25 years?
Mike White: Actually City Footballer, it has been 22 years. Brashear missed in 1996 when they were 2-7.
WashCoFan: Who are your top 5 WPIAL teams regardless of class?
Mike White: Pine, NA, Gateway, Penn Hills and probably Central. On a one-game basis, TJ would be able to play with Central, Penn Hills and Gateway.
City Footballer: Whats going on in the city league? Playoffs already started and Brashear is not in? how long has that been since they missed 15/20 years? Change of Hc that big a deal
Mike White: Already answered.
District3MikeD: Don't discount AB Wood. Their losses are all to powerhouses. I think they're still the favorite in 5A. Tho Warwick, Cocalico or Manheim Central, or who comes out of D3 will give them a fight.. L-L League is pretty good this year.
Mike White: I agree. But I don't think they're as good as they have been.
HeyMike: With not many P5 players in the 2019 class. What does 2020 & 2021 look like
Mike White: Story coming on this in Friday paper. Next year not any better. People don't like to admit it but Western Pa. football talent, at least major-college talent, has dropped considerably in past decade. Numbers prove it. This year, only 4 players are committed to Power 5 schools. Will end up with only maybe 5 or 6. Lowest ever. Look for story later in week.
HSfootballfan : Palko and Walker had to see this coming, why not just agree on a time frame to play the starters, then let the back-ups and JVs play the rest of the game. they both have to have Sr's that don't see the field. give those kids a chance to play some snaps!!
Mike White: Agree. That's what probably will happen now.
1A Mess: There is no way that one conference should be loaded with 3 or four good teams while the other two are weak. The third and fourth place teams in that conference deserve to get a shot at the playoffs and would likely make the playoffs in either of the other conferences. There is no way that it should have been limited to 8 teams. Yes there is a change for blow outs in the first round but its like that in all other classifications too.
Mike White: This has long been a complaint. Nothing new.
Panther MBA: And two years ago, Ringgold beat TJ . Ringgold Middle School Team is Undefeated. The home of Joe Montanna will be back!
Mike White: I say bring up those middle school players. Use a running clock.
1st Timer: ... from a different perspective: Think the whole NA / WA thing is adding fuel to their final week opponents (PR / Moon)? Who do you pick in those final week matchups? NA vs PR, WA vs MOON
Mike White: I'll take Pine and West A.
Mike White: That's it for now. Hey, a man's gotta eat lunch and there is a running clock on my sandwich. See you next Tuesday at 11.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.