Varsity Xtra: Halfway through 2018, who's the best player in the WPIAL?

Mike White: Well I blinked and suddenly half of the high school football regular season is over. Five weeks complete. Five weeks left.

Mike White: Some surprises, like most years. Some always-good teams good again. Happenings in past week? Well a Latrobe football player turned down Pitt and WVU to go to East Carolina. Trent Holler. Latrobe basketball player Reed Fenton committed to Lehigh.

Mike White: You know, we probably will have only 6 or 7 seniors go to power 5 conference schools. Will be lowest ever. Says something about the state of the talent in Western Pa. Still plenty of good players. Just not as many big timers.

Mike White: Off we go. Fire away with questions.

Advertise with us

Wike Mhite: Big game this week between Blackhawk and South Fayette! SF hasn’t really been pushed at all since the wk0 loss by 1pt to USC. Blackhawk gave SF some trouble 2 years ago and almost ended the winning streak before a huge and wild comeback. How do you see this one going Mike?

Mike White: Zack Heyward has done a tremendous job in his first season at Blackhawk. Former Blackhawk QB. They're 5-0. I still don't know how good they are. Show me. This game will tell a lot. South Fayette QB Jamie Diven might be breakout player of the year in WPIAL. That Joe Rossi system at South Fayette does wonders for QBs. I'll take South Fayette.

Tom : Quips look tough. How do you think they would stack up against someone like Pine?

Mike White: Definitely Pine. In a one-game event, maybe Aliquippa stays in the game. But there is a major, major difference in 3A and 6A, even if Aliquippa is a dominant 6A team. A lot of people don't realize that.

John 3A: Derry with big win last week. But NC drove 2hrs and kids just seemed down and could not recover. 2hrs much too far to play football game.

Advertise with us

Mike White: Don't use bus ride as excuse. It is what it is. It is WPIAL football today. Blame the six classes. Maybe North wasn't into the game. But teams take long bus rides to games all the time, especially in state playoffs. North just got handled. Plain and simple. Don't blame bus ride.

HeyMike: Daequan Hardy....thoughts on him? And how great the 5A playoffs are going to look?

Mike White: Big Play Dae. Eight TDs so far this year, averaging 52.8 yards. Wow. He has FBS offers. Once offers from Michigan and Michigan State but I wonder how hard those two are still recruiting him. As for playoffs, 5A has a number of good teams. I've seen a number of them now. I think there is a dropoff after Gateway and Penn Hills. Peters and Penn-Trafford are coming on, though.

Wike Mhite: Congrats to Woodland Hills on getting that first W with their season on the line. Huge game for them against West A this week. Do you think Woody can get back in the playoff hunt?

Mike White: Yes they can get back in the playoff hunt. How? Win games.

Advertise with us

Mike White: Woody High defense has been pretty good. Offense seems to be lacking.

Joe: Will we ever see high school football take to the same measures of the NFL to Protect QBs?

Mike White: Doubtful. They haven't taken on same rules to the extent that NFL has.

Panther MBA: Hi Mike. Saw your article about inclement weather. Who has final authority to end a game? Home School AD or on site WPIAL rep? Seems like schools-wpial dropped ball somewhat on Friday. Ringgold-Gaetway game was not called until 4th qtr with outcome more than decided and lightning and downpours on the way. Alot of people involved other than players.. fans, band, cheerleaders, employees with safety at the front.

Mike White: There is no WPIAL representative at regular-season games. Once game starts, officials are in charge of stopping game. Games are only called when both teams agree to it. Both teams must agree. One team can't just say "That's it. Game over." It's a mutual decision. As far as what you said with Ringgold-Gateway game? I don't think you stop a game because rain is coming. Some places it rained, but no lightning. But we now have early dismissals in schools because of heat, so it wouldn't surprised me these days if football game is stopped because we're going to get some rain.

Advertise with us

John: Are you concerned about the future of high school football the sidelines keep getting smaller to me

Mike White: It's the small schools that are hurting. Some small schools are OK, but some are hurting. But funny you ask. Look for story in P-G in next few days about the future of small-school football.

X: I'm starting to drink the koolaid with NA...good line play, solid D, multiple qbs, and multiple rbs. This weekends PR vs CC should provide a decent relevant opponent to evaluate. What do you think NA and PR have as advantages when they play each other?

Mike White: Haven't seen NA yet. Probably won't until Pine game. I don't know of any area that one has an advantage. Pine's sophomore QB is getting better. NA's QBs are obviously getting better. Pine has D-1 guys on the lines. But NA's lines are pretty good, too, from what I hear. Should be a close game. Pine should beat Central, but they better not overlook Central.

Wike Mhite: BF put up little resistance to Aliquippa. Looks like they will roll into the playoffs easily. Do you think Derry can stack up against them? Anybody else that can give them a game??

Advertise with us

Mike White: Aliquippa is the dandruff shampoo team of 3A -- Head and Shoulders above the rest. Awwwww yeahhhh. ... Hard to think anyone can go toe-to-toe with them. But we only need look back to a year ago. Aliquippa was heavy favorite to win it all. Remember 2-0 Quaker Valley.?

Stan Kachowski: I would love to see North Hills pull the upset on Gateway this week, though I'm pretty sure every team they will face has now keyed in on the 3-4 plays they run. And speaking of the Gators, should a Gateway-Penn Hills WPIAL final come to fruition I think it could be one for the ages.

Mike White: It ain't happening unless Gateway has 6 or more turnovers. I wish Gateway and Penn Hills played in the regular season. They are right next to each other but in different classes. I think they are certainly the two best 5A teams.

HeyMike: Will they ever allow City League teams into the WPIAL? That 6 team league is sad. And to see maybe 50-100 people in the stands. Feel bad for them kids...

Mike White: Besides Westinghouse, no City League teams have wanted to join the WPIAL for football. There has been no movement from PItt. Public Schools to join WPIAL for football and basketball. I think some of the coaches would like it, especially in basketball. Would be great to see in hoops. But football would struggle a lot I would think. But in the long run, it might help City teams. Or even fewer kids might come out if they can't compete. Interesting to think about.

Advertise with us

Pittsburgh sports news in my inbox? Yes, please.

Get the PG Sports Feed newsletter each weekday here.

Jinx: Do you think that Charleroi is the surprise team in 2-A this year??

Mike White: Yes and no. I mean, they were 9-2 last year and had a lot of players back. The surprise was what they did to Washington. Winning was one thing, but to score 60 some points on defending WPIAL champ?? I keep wondering how Donnie Militzer feels. He built the program up. Then school let him go after last season. Why? I don't know. Never heard a reason. Mystery.

Mike White: I wouldn't feel good about any other team. Maybe Class A champ, whoever it is??? But Farrell has an excellent team this season. WPIAL 1A champ most likely would have to face Steelers at some point. Farrell Steelers, I mean.

Advertise with us

WPIALGuy: I look forward to reading your article on small school football, Mike. In NE Ohio last Friday, Richmond Heights had 19 players dressed, one got hurt, and at halftime Heights said we are done playing, we forfeit. Can you see this stuff happening more and more?

Mike White: Well Imani Christian and Springdale stopped their game at halftime this year. Because it was hot. Some players got hurt. And both teams rosters were small. Imani was winning by a lot so they agreed to stop the game. It was non conference. RIght now you see lopsided games in WPIAL played with shortened quarters in second half. So it's already happening.

2AFootballFan: I saw the North Catholic result coming. While they have a ton of good RB, WR and QB players, their line play is very shaky. How do you see the rest of the season playing out for the Trojans?

Mike White: I think they have to do better if they want to win the Pac 12. ... Oh, I thought you meant the USC Trojans. Love that North Catholic look of the USC Trojans with the helmets and pants. NC still has to play Elizabeth Forward, who is undefeated right now. That conference isn't exactly full of juggernauts. I see them finishing with, at the most, two losses.

Wpial sports Fan: I know it’s not happening this week but next week OLSH @ Jeannette who you got?

Advertise with us

Mike White: It's non conference game but that is a good one. 1 vs. 2. I think OLSH will score points. But for some reason, I'll take Jeannette.

Quad North Fan: 6A is getting a little boring. Norwin who is a playoff team got beat by Char Valley who is a last place 5A team. Lebo is a playoff team that hasn't beaten a team with a winning record. SV is the only hope outside the big 3 with a close loss against PCC on their record. Sorta sucks. Thank goodness PCC and PR played good week 0 teams, otherwise there wouldn't have been any competition thus far. Does Lebo or Norwin or anybody have anything coming up the pipeline?

Mike White: Agree wholeheartedly with you. 6A really doesn't do much for excitement. But that's the way it is when you have only nine teams in the class. This was supposed to be one of Norwin's better teams in a while. Knights are OK, but obviously the big boys are still on a different level. I know Norwin's QB is only a junior, but I don't know much else. Lebo will always be solid. Honestly, I see this being the same most years if it's only going to be 9 teams. There will be Pine, NA and Central - and then everyone else.

Jinx: Do you think that 7 man football could be an option for some of these smaller schools?

Mike White: I guess if they wanted to start their own league.

Advertise with us

HeyMike: Is there a vote to go back from 6A to 4A any time soon?

Mike White: Not unless the PIAA wants it - and they are showing no signs of wanting it. Look, six classes have actually helped some teams. Some of these teams doing well wouldn't be as competitive if there were only 4 classes. They would still be in a bigger class and it would be tougher for them. That was one of the things that six classes was supposed to do - even the playing field. Teams wouldn't be playing others that were much bigger in terms of enrollment. But there have been not-so-good things with 6A also. Mainly, it has watered down things a lot. But in 10 years, that might not matter when everyone is used to it by then.

Quad North Fan: How about an idea like letting butler or Cmac or anyone opt out of games (mutually) and let them find other competition (and forfeit playoffs).

Mike White: No way. What, let them be in the WPIAL, let them start a season, and once they realize they aren't very good, let them cancel games? Seriously? If you're in, play the games.

Quad North Fan: PCC vs Butler : PCC gets the win and both teams can schedule better games.

Advertise with us

Mike White: You think it's easy to get games in the middle of the season at the drop of a hat? C'mon.

Do you appreciate good journalism? If you do, consider subscribing.

Support journalism. Subscribe today.

2AFootballFan: 2a is the best this year. Plenty of good teams. The playoffs should be very interesting. Shady Side, Steel Valley, Charleroi and Washington are all interesting but keep an eye on Avonworth. Good skill players and a nice big line that is getting better.

Mike White: I would agree with you. 5A and 2A are the best, at least in terms of depth of decent teams. The uprising of the likes of Charleroi and Shady Side have helped 2A's balance. I still say watch for Washington come playoffs. And also Steel Valley.

Advertise with us

Wike Mhite: What happened to Montour? They’ve seemed to have a steady level of success leading up to this year. Now they’ve been shutout 3 games in a row, winless on the season. Sad to see such a sharp decline.

Mike White: I have no idea. I didn't think they'd be great this year. But I didn't expect this. Poor Lou. Bringing back memories of the Dick Butkus year. Oh geez.

Ironman: I look forward to reading your article on the size of teams. Bethel Park cancelled the JV game due to lack of lineman. There is a safety issue with not enough players or putting small kids in a line with bigger kids. The WPIAL needs to work with these schools and combine some schools. Thoughts?

Mike White: It's not the WPIAL's job to combine schools or make coops. It's the schools. School district mergers are tough. It takes two to merge. Many schools don't want to merge. And some of these smaller schools don't like the idea of a cooperative sponsorship with other schools. They claim they will lose their identity. I understand that a little but this is something that's probably not going to get a lot better. Just worse. Face it, for various reasons, fewer kids are playing football.

Quad North Fan: Before the season - teams like Butler know they aren’t going to win. Give them a chance to regroup and get the program better. Who wants to play knowing they are going to get crushed every game. Maybe that can jumpstart some

Advertise with us

Mike White: Well then drop out of the WPIAL. You can't pick and choose what games you want to play in a WPIAL schedule. You're either in or out. Butler is hardest school to figure out. One of the biggest schools in the WPIAL and football program is horrible. I don't have the answer. And neither does Butler. But you can't pick and choose what WPIAL games to play. If they don't like it, then drop out of the WPIAL. But I'll bet the Butler fans would just love to play games far away against teams from other states and the like. How about just figure out a way to get a little more competitive.

HeyMike: Is there still 9th grade football?

Mike White: Not many. I did a story on this 2-3 years ago. I think now there might be at most 15 schools with WPIAL football. Maybe even less than that. This is a numbers thing. But it's also some coaches believe just bring the 9th graders up to the varsity team. I think in five years they will realize that was a bad move. It's just one more thing to discourage kids from playing football. Because I know there are ninth grade kids who won't play simply because they are intimidated and aren't ready to be in a varsity atmosphere. Even if they don't practice with the varsity kids, they're still around that level. And some ninth graders don't want it. So they don't play.

Stan Kachowski: On the topic of 6A: is there an actual fix for this? Since 2010 NA, PR, and PCC have dominated the highest class, and this trend looks to continue for a while. Before that the WPIAL champions definitely had a little more flavor (with certain teams going on runs, obviously). I don't imagine that people who send their kids to PR, NA, or PCC have a problem with it, and I think the result is that 4A and 5A have become way more competitive and fun to watch. I can understand there being some consternation from the folks at the remaining 6A schools, but I genuinely think that the move to 6 classifications - for football, anyway - has actually benefited far more programs than it has negatively impacted. Thoughts?

Mike White: That's what I said earlier, Stan. The move to six classes has definitely benefited teams. It's just a shame that WPIAL 6A has only nine teams. Not good. But please remember this. This was not the WPIAL's decision. The PIAA went to six classes. And it's not the WPIAL's decision to have only six 6A football teams. Classes are determined by school enrollment.

Advertise with us

Jimmy: Should ambridge merge with Aliquippa or something I’m concerned with the future of that program in a few years they might be good again but I’m worried all the younger kids will transfer to different schools because there roster is small

Mike White: Jimmy, like I said before. It's not as easy as saying two schools should merge. There are two sides to a merger. And many times, one of the schools doesn't want to merge. Do you know the Woodland Hills merger in the 1980s was court ordered? Just a thought. Maybe Ambridge doesn't want to merge with Aliquippa. And maybe Aliquippa is just fine having football its own way.

demosthenes98: What happened to Seton LaSalle? In the preseason they were ranked fifth in WPIAL 2A. Now they're tied for fifth in their own conference.

Mike White: Don't know. There are good surprises. Seton-LaSalle is a surprise the other way. Sometimes you have these seasons. Just ask Montour.

O’Malley : what would need to happen for programs to be able to schedule their own non-conference games? I understand that some places would have a hard time finding an opponent but it seemed to work fine during the prior two decades.

Advertise with us

Mike White: Schools can schedule their first game in Week 0 if they choose to play that week. The WPIAL schedules all other games the rest of the season, even non-conference. But again, you're either in the WPIAL or out. Take Butler. They're in a conference with nine teams. So they have eight conference games. That leaves one non conference game and a Week 0 game if they want to play. You need to know that many teams want the WPIAL to schedule non conference games during the season. Sometimes it's hard for teams to find non conference games, especially the good teams. Sure, everyone wants to play someone like Butler in non conference. They know it's a good chance to win. But not many like to play the good teams.

Mike White: Hey everyone that's it for this week. We'll do it again next Tuesday at 11. And may Butler get a few wins - one of these years. So they don't have to leave the WPIAL.