On Wednesday night, during the annual ESPYs telecast from Los Angeles, Jim Kelly will accept the Jimmy V. Award for Perseverance and offer a short speech, the only kind possible when your face and jaw form a virtual cauldron of unrelenting pain.
The audience inside the Microsoft Theater, thick with star athletes and A-list celebs, will include a contingent of NFL defenders who’ve rearranged a quarterback’s face, but none of them could dream of what doctors at Lenox Hill Hospital in New York City have done with Jim Kelly’s.
“He had part of his fibula taken out and they re-created his jaw, and then they took the tissue from his calf muscle and re-created the roof of his mouth,” Dan Kelly, younger brother of the Hall of Fame passer, was saying this past week.
“Then they put five posts in his mouth where his teeth are eventually going to go into, then they had to trim all the excessive tissue across the entire mouth, so he had stitches from the left side to the right side. It was just a lot more invasive than he anticipated or that anybody anticipated.”
Dan’s description draws only the outline of what happened June 21, date of the third surgical response in five years to a diagnosis of cancer in his big brother’s jaw.
As joyous and raucous and inspirational as the football career Jim Kelly launched from tiny East Brady 40 years ago surely was, it’s been matched and some might posit even surpassed by the countervailing winds of a post-football existence packed with pain and inequitable suffering for the former Bills quarterback, for his immediate family, his extended family, the city of Buffalo, and for all who know and care about him in Western Pennsylvania and from coast to coast. A book authored by Kelly’s wife, Jill, and younger daughter, Erin, describes the role of the family’s unshakable faith in all this, but the heartache within the pages of “Kelly Tough” practically comes off in your hands. And that was written three years ago.
Read More
Jim Kelly’s is a quintessential American sports story laced with tortured allegories, rueful ironies, even weird numerology.
He was one of six quarterbacks taken in the 1983 draft that included John Elway and Dan Marino, and he is one of six Hall of Fame quarterbacks from Western Pa. His Bills jersey was No. 12, two sixes, and 12, only 12, is the exact number of quarterbacks in nearly 100 years of National Football League history to win more games than James Edward Kelly.

By the end of Valentine’s Day, 1960, the day Jim was born in Pittsburgh, Joe and Alice Kelly had already produced four boys, so the next time Alice delivered, it was, naturally, twin boys. Jim would have his own son, Hunter, 37 years later to the day. Valentine’s Day. For the NFL Network special, “Jim Kelly, A Football Life,” Jill told interviewers what it was like for her husband, the only quarterback ever to lead a franchise to four consecutive Super Bowls, when Hunter was born: “You’d have thought Jim won all four of those Super Bowls and then 10 more.”
But Hunter never spoke a word.
Doctors found globoid-cell leukodystrophy, aka Krabbe disease, told Jim and Jill not to expect Hunter to reach his second birthday and said to try to make him comfortable. Born a Kelly, Hunter was having none of it. Fought like a lion for more than eight years before he passed in 2005, so he was ringside for his father’s 2002 Hall of Fame speech, the one where Jim’s voice quaked just that once, in the sentence that began, “It’s been written throughout my career that toughness is my trademark.” It ended with a voice rising to meet his emotions: “Well, the toughest person I’ve ever met in my life is my hero, my soldier, my son Hunter. I love you buddy.”
Kelly walked off fully composed, but not before thanking Buffalo, which had provided him such abundant love along with its own multiple ironies. A town filled with sufferers — cough sufferers, cold sufferers, but most especially football sufferers — Buffalo found in Jim Kelly not just a gunslinger of a quarterback, but a soulmate.
“I never thought of us as losers, ever, and I don’t think he did either,” said longtime Pittsburgh PR ace and Buffalo native Saul Markowitz. “Try bringing a team to the Super Bowl four years in a row, like he did. What other quarterback would be able to do that? Four years, to say every year, ‘We’re coming back.’ Every year.
“I really believe, as a long-suffering Bills fan, that one day we’re gonna win one for him and when we do he’ll be part of that team. You can’t separate the two. Ever.”
That’s another self-evident truth that is wrapped in Kelly’s unique ironies. Jim tried hard to separate himself from Buffalo even as that famous 1983 draft approached. He wanted to play where it was warmer (and where isn’t it, really?), even bolting to the fledgling USFL’s Houston Gamblers to start his pro career, once telling Bills quarterback Frank Reich, “I promise you, I will never play for the Buffalo Bills.”
When the USFL folded in 1986, Bills general manager Bill Polian and owner Ralph Wilson changed Jim’s mind, along with nearly 8 million of Wilson’s dollars, then the NFL’s biggest contract.
Paired with head coach Marv Levy and the soon-to-be-celebrated K-Gun offense that allowed him to call most of the plays at the line of scrimmage, Kelly brought a capacious skills array to the league, brought Buffalo to the postseason in eight of his 11 seasons and brought this enduring observation from Levy, the Harvard-educated coach who’d worked in the game for most of five decades: “The toughest SOB to ever take a snap from center.”
The unfortunate aspect of that singular accolade is that it has to be paid for in pain. Pain appeared throughout Kelly’s dossier going back to college at Miami. He’d had three metal rods inserted in his shoulder after ripping it apart against Virginia Tech. He’d been concussed from the stage, knocked out cold, by Alabama. He’d been mistreated by Penn State even as he was beating the school that had wanted him to play linebacker there twice, once as a freshman at Beaver Stadium and once when the Nittany Lions were ranked No. 1. Kelly shuffled injuries and ironies like a Vegas dealer. When his career reached its apex, he was concussed in one Super Bowl and blew out his knee in another.
NFL fans still laugh at the video of Ben Dreith calling a personal foul penalty against New York Jets defensive lineman Marty Lyons, in which Dreith pantomimed a repeated punching motion and explained, “he’s givin’ him the business down there!”
And who got Lyons’ business that day?
Who else?

Now 58, coming up on the first anniversary of losing his father and the 13th of losing his son, facing another surgery in the coming months, even those who are unfaltering in their faith might wonder if God is through giving Jim Kelly the business.
“We’re a real Christian family and I believe this with all my heart, that God doesn’t put more on your plate than you can handle and that He chooses people who can make a difference and handle it,” Dan said. “I don’t think I could handle it and that’s why [Jim] is chosen to carry that torch. He can handle it. He can overcome all those adversities and be an example for others.”
Pat Kelly, oldest of the six brothers, told me he’s run the same mental gamut.
“I’ve often thought, ‘Why him?’ as much as he’s done for children, even before his son Hunter was born, he had the Kelly for Kids Foundation,” Pat said. “It just doesn’t seem fair. I don’t think there’s anybody out there that could handle it the way Jim has.
“After this last surgery, he didn’t want to miss his football camp because he didn’t want to let the little kids down. Every year kids look forward to Jim throwin’ them a pass, so they could say they caught a pass from a Hall of Famer. I saw him pushing a kid across the field in a wheelchair.
“He just doesn’t want other people to see his pain. The brothers know about it because I can look in his eyes and I can tell. I’ve been around him long enough I can tell.”
Terry Henry, who coached Jim and older brother Ray at East Brady, was at that camp as well and has been with Jim to 30-some Super Bowls and countless Bills games, every home version of which culminated, win or lose, with his teammates invited to a huge house party.”
“I saw him two weeks ago at his football camp and I haven’t seen him that bad as far as pain, his mouth hurting,” Henry said the other day. “But he came to camp every day. He worked with the kids, but he’d have to go inside sometimes and lie down. I can tell you this, when it was announced he was getting the Jimmy V. Award, he was very proud, and he always likes to come back to East Brady and get out on the river.”
As a boy, Jim Kelly would whip stones toward the Allegheny to measure the strength in a golden arm. May he again, for years to come, know that kind of peace and joy.
Gene Collier: gcollier@post-gazette.com
Pittsburgh sports news in my inbox? Yes, please.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.