The NCAA board of governors and board of directors has endorsed the formation of a Commission on College Basketball, a body that will be chaired by former U.S. Secretary of State Condoleezza Rice, NCAA president Mark Emmert announced Wednesday in a statement.
As part of examining aspects of a system that Emmert said “clearly is not working,” the commission will have three primary areas of focus — the relationship of the NCAA, its institutions and athletes with outside entities, namely apparel companies, amateur basketball and agents; the organization’s relationship with the NBA, particularly as it relates to the effects of the league’s “one-and-done” rule; and working to improve the level of transparency and accountability between the NCAA’s national office and its schools. The committee will begin its work in November and deliver its proposed changes at the NCAA’s April meetings.
In addition to Rice, the committee features 13 well-known figures from higher education, basketball and business, a group that includes Emmert, former NBA stars David Robinson and Grant Hill, former Georgetown coach John Thompson III, Notre Dame president the Rev. John Jenkins, USA Basketball chairman Gen. Martin E. Dempsey and Ohio State athletic director Gene Smith.
The announcement comes two weeks after college basketball was rattled by revelations from an FBI corruption investigation. At the center of the probe were details about how top prospects were paid upwards of $150,000 in an effort to attract them to certain schools, financial advisers and shoe companies, findings that led to the indictment of four assistant coaches from major-conference programs.
“Individuals who break the trust on which college sports is based have no place here. While I believe the vast majority of coaches follow the rules, the culture of silence in college basketball enables bad actors, and we need them out of the game,” Emmert said in the statement. “We must take decisive action. This is not a time for half-measures or incremental change.”
The third and final of the NCAA’s listed objectives is something of a look inward. Through the work of subpoenas, wiretaps and threat of prison, the FBI’s investigation not only brought to light many seedy elements that had long lingered in the shadows, but it highlighted the limitations of the NCAA’s enforcement arm.
Read More
In his statement, Emmert said the commission will evaluate whether “the appropriate degree of authority is vested in the current enforcement and eligibility processes, and whether the collaborative model provides the investigative tools, cultural incentives and structures to ensure exploitation and corruption cannot hide in college sports.”
Those within the NCAA’s national office aren’t the only ones to question whether the organization is properly equipped to deal with such large-scale problems.
“The one concern a lot of us have is, our conferences and the associations like the NCAA and others that were really designed to ensure fair and equitable competition, are they really up to the task of dealing with this?” Pitt chancellor Patrick Gallagher said Tuesday in a meeting with Post-Gazette editors and reporters. “The FBI, by virtue of what they can do, has certainly brought a whole different set of tools and suddenly brought to light something I think some people have suspected for a while. I think that’s really the tension.”
The NCAA’s move has caused some to question whether the formation of the committee only further showcases that disconnect, particularly since the group doesn’t feature anyone with extensive firsthand experience working in the peripheral areas of the game that helped birth the scandal.
To those same critics, the news Wednesday simply signals more of the same from college sports’ governing body.
“What we have is an impotent enforcement system that has an inherent conflict of interest,” said Gerald Gurney, a professor at the University of Oklahoma and a former compliance director at the University of Maryland. “It doesn’t serve the NCAA’s purpose to expose this corruption. I think that says it all. I have no faith in any commission the NCAA puts together because they are receiving a billion dollars for media rights per year. The last thing the NCAA really wants to do is turn over the rocks in men’s basketball because they know what they will find.”
Craig Meyer: cmeyer@post-gazette.com and Twitter @CraigMeyerPG.



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.