Westinghouse Electric Co. sought to reassure employees that their pensions aren’t underwater after a report published Friday estimated the bankrupt Cranberry-based company’s plan is underfunded by $937 million.
The assessment came from the Pension Benefit Guarantee Corp., a government agency that insures certain private employer pension plans and, in some instances, takes them over.
One such instance is when a company decides to terminate its plan in bankruptcy — something Westinghouse hasn’t yet tried to do.
But the possibility is not remote: Westinghouse filed for bankruptcy reorganization in March and is currently being marketed for sale. While its five-year business plan includes paying its pension liabilities, there’s no way to know yet how that plan would be received by a potential buyer.
In the meantime, Westinghouse has told its employees that their pension is funded at 80 percent and the company plans to reach out to its retirees in the near future.
There are 9,714 beneficiaries — both retired and still employed — of the Westinghouse pension plan, according to the U.S. Department of Labor, and another 457 split between boilermakers who work at or are retired from facilities in Newington, N.H., and Windsor, Conn.
Funding shortfall
The Pension Benefit Guarantee Corp. filed its claims as part of Westinghouse’s bankruptcy case but said they would be relevant only in the event that Westinghouse tries to end the plan.
In the claims, the agency said it relied on annual actuarial valuations of the company’s assets and liabilities, and on reports that Westinghouse has filed with the U.S. Department of Labor. Those reports show that Westinghouse’s pension has been funded at levels between 80 percent and 108 percent over the past five years.
That’s a measure of the market value of the fund’s assets compared with how much the fund will need to pay out to all of its beneficiaries.
If the PBGC isn’t on the brink of taking over a plan, it is unlikely to delve deeply into how a company is valuing the assets.
Where the agency will make adjustments is on the liabilities side. This is where the PBGC estimate has diverged dramatically from Westinghouse’s.
The agency’s goal is to estimate how much the plan would cost to administer if Westinghouse were to terminate or sell it to a private administrator.
In making those calculations, it is also likely to use current — that is, currently low — interest rates to calculate how much investments will appreciate in the coming years. Westinghouse — as it has been allowed to do by federal law since 2012 — uses a 25-year average of interest rates in making its projections.
The 25-year average rule was written into a federal highway funding law and, as explained in a document sent in April to Westinghouse pensioners, “This means that interest rates likely will be higher and plan liabilities lower.”
“As a result, your employer may contribute less money to the plan at a time when market interest rates are at or near historic lows.”
For 2016, Westinghouse told retirees that their pension plan was funded at a rate of 102 percent. But using a two-year interest rate average, that number dropped to 80 percent and translated to a shortfall of $226 million.
Claims abound
There are also funding shortfalls in two other pension funds for Westinghouse employees in the United Kingdom, where the company has a nuclear fuel factory and a subsidiary called GPS Energy Solutions.
The Combined Nuclear Pension Plan, a government entity that administers a pension plan for nuclear workers in the U.K., has filed a claim for $208 million.
Sarah Cassella, a spokeswoman for Westinghouse, noted that those subsidiaries are not involved in the company’s bankruptcy and therefore should not be impacted.
In addition, a number of former Westinghouse executives have filed claims since the company terminated its executive pension plan in the spring and some former executives have also sought to recover their deferred compensation.
Jeff Benjamin, who served as senior vice president of new power plants from 2013 until earlier this year, said in a filing that he’s owed $1.9 million.
Danny Roderick, Westinghouse’s former CEO, told the bankruptcy court he’s out $4.2 million in deferred income.
Mr. Roderick has also filed a claim that he is owed $24 million as per his employment agreement, which he attached to his claim with the vast majority of its 24 pages blacked out. The parts that weren’t redacted dealt with “termination without cause.” Mr. Roderick is still employed by Toshiba Corp., Westinghouse’s parent company.
Anya Litvak: alitvak@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1455.
EDITOR’S NOTE, Published Sept. 26, 2017: The Pension Benefit Guarantee Corp. was misidentified in a previous online version of this story.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.