The success of Open Streets Pittsburgh leads to a question: Who needs cars Downtown, anyway?
Whether biking down a car-free Penn Avenue last Sunday, running the Pittsburgh marathon or strolling across the Clemente Bridge before a Pirates game, the experience of navigating a city street, minus the traffic, is an exercise in exhilaration. When cars are present, it’s more often an ordeal. Most of us use our cars just 5 percent of the time anyway, and much of that is spent sitting in traffic, searching for parking and cussing.
Since we need cars to get Downtown, but not so much after we’re there, why not ban them, not just for four hours on three Sundays a year, but all the time? It’s a radical idea for which I can’t take credit.
Hamburg, the second largest city in Germany, is preparing to boot cars out of its center by 2034. Pundits call it the Auto-Ban. The city is constructing beauteous thoroughfares, called the Green Network, to enable its residents and workers to get around easily on foot, bike or public transportation.
Five hundred miles south, in Freiburg, cars already are prohibited. Workers and residents can park their cars in a garage or use public transportation to get there, but once within the “pedestrianized” community, it’s foot, skate or bike — Open Streets, 24/7. And why not?
Streets without cars have fewer potholes and generate less pollution and road rage. They demand physical exertion (something Americans need even more than Germans). They encourage humans to look at each other, not each other’s bumper stickers. They extract us from the bubble, immerse us in scent, allow us to inspect magnificent architecture concealed by the roofs of our cars.
Open Streets, which more than 100 U.S. cities have embraced, gives us a taste of that heady freedom, but only like a chef who offers a spoonful of stew and then slams the lid on the fragrant pot. More than 15,000 people enjoyed this year’s first day of Open Streets Pittsburgh in May, but the last one Downtown is July 26, and that’s it for the year. Not to be ungrateful, but that’s not enough.
In Bogota, Colombia, where “Ciclovia” began, 70 miles of streets are closed to cars every Sunday and on holidays. More than 1 million people take to the streets there each week. When they do, they are physically active for four hours and 15 minutes. (Americans exercise for an average of 17 minutes a day, the Bureau of Labor Statistics recently reported.)
In Guadalajara, Mexico, 41 miles of roads have been closed to auto traffic every Sunday for a decade.
Phoenix has “Silent Sundays” on the streets of its massive nature preserve. Near New York, 6.5 miles of the Bronx River Parkway are shut down between White Plains and Yonkers each Sunday during May, June and September.
Pittsburgh has a big white reason it can’t have Open Streets all year: a grumpy old season called winter. (Although Matthew Philips’s YouTube video of dog-sledding through empty streets makes even snow-clogged empty streets look appealing.) But having one event a month from April to November should be achievable. Having one every weekend should be a goal. Open Streets forever is a dream. (In mine, there are horses.)
There are negatives, of course, even just expanding Open Streets to more days in the year. In its infancy, it’s expensive. The budget for each event was $65,000, the bills borne largely by Highmark, The Heinz Endowments, and the Grable, Benter and Colcom foundations, said Ngani Ndimbie, communication manager for Bike Pittsburgh, one of the lead organizers.
Moreover, some business owners, including a meat vendor, are complaining of lost revenue on Open Streets days. (When vegans are doing yoga in the street, some types of businesses are likely to suffer.) Other businesses, however, reported increased traffic, including the owner of Enrico Biscotti Bakery and Cafe, who enjoyed a 30 percent jump in sales.
As for closing Downtown streets for good, naysayers need go no farther than East Liberty to assemble an argument. In the 1960s, the community closed several streets and demolished homes to create Penn Circle. Instead of attracting people to East Liberty, it drove them away and, when East Liberty Development Inc. was formed in 1979, one of its first jobs was to reopen Broad Street, Penn Avenue and Highland Avenue to traffic.
At the time East Liberty was closing its roads, however, the embarrassed children of the late running guru George Sheehan were asking their father why he was running around town in his underwear. It would be another decade before the fitness boom took off, a half-century before it would be completely normal to see balding men rollerblading and octogenarian nuns running on public streets.
Closed streets in East Liberty might not work even today. A car-free zone needs a captive population of workers, a magnet of activity and aesthetics that pulls people out of their cars. Good biscotti helps, too.
Banning cars Downtown is a crazy idea. But so was building a light-rail system that primarily serves the South Hills. Somehow that got done (and someone should be punished). As Europe blows past the United States with its car-free cities and bicycle superhighways, it’s inevitable that some American city will be bold enough to envision its own Auto-Ban in the coming decades. Would that it be done. Would that it be here.
Jennifer Graham is a Post-Gazette columnist and associate editor (jgraham@post-gazette.com,412-263-1668).





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.