Election campaigns are for making promises. But those who are elected must face reality. And so must we. The reality is that our government has accumulated past obligations that are likely to put severe constraints on any new initiatives that the federal government is likely to undertake.
These obligations come in two forms: 1) the public debt, which is associated with the government’s past borrowing; and 2) the implicit, currently unfunded, promises to make payments in the future to people who are or will become eligible for receipt of Social Security and Medicare benefits.
As of Oct. 6, the total public debt of the federal government was $19.68 trillion. Even with the lowest interest rates in generations, the federal government expends about 7 percent of its budget on interest payments. As interest rates rise, so too will these payments.
More important, since 1980, the public debt has consistently grown more rapidly than the income of the nation. This is not sustainable.
Eventually, the interest on the debt would exceed the government’s ability to pay it. Long before that point is reached, the government will find it impossible to borrow from the general public (e.g., Greece). It would then have to rely upon pumping increasing amounts of money into the economy, which, as in post-World War I Germany, will create runaway inflation. We are not yet anywhere near such a point. And, it makes sense to add to the government debt when the economy needs help to recover from a deep recession, as was true in the past nine years.
But thoughtful people ought to be worried about our inability to control the rate of growth of the nation’s public debt in good times, as well as bad. So, it is worrisome when candidates for the presidency propose tax cuts or new programs that will add to the nation’s public debt without clear evidence that they will raise the nation’s productive capacity.
Of more immediate concern is the fact that our population is getting older and we do not have adequate funding to meet our obligations to them. Expenditures for Social Security and health care currently absorb close to 60 percent of the federal government budget. Without significant changes, this percentage will necessarily increase.
Expenditures on Medicare are projected to grow more rapidly than the economy over the indefinite future. For Medicare Part A (hospital insurance), which is funded by a dedicated wage tax, this means that current tax rates will be inadequate to pay for the benefits promised under the program as soon as 2018. For Medicare Parts B (supplementary insurance) and D (prescription drug coverage), this means that subscriber payments and subsidies from the general fund of the U.S. government will have to be continually increased, leaving less money in the hands of both citizens and the U.S treasury.
The Social Security system has a reserve fund. But Social Security benefit payouts are about to exceed the tax collections. Three years from now, Social Security will begin drawing down its reserves. Without changes in scheduled benefits and taxes, that fund will be empty by 2034. At that point the projected tax revenue will be sufficient to meet only 79 percent of the currently scheduled benefits. Beyond 2034, the increasing ratio of retirees to workers will only make things worse.
Therefore, to maintain the current benefits will require a significant increase in tax collections and reduced benefits. This may come through some combination of expanding the wage tax base by including more income subject to the wage tax, raising the rate at which wages are taxed and reducing benefits through such actions as increasing the normal retirement age and changing the way benefits are adjusted for inflation.
Rising interest costs, rising health care costs and an aging population will put inexorable pressure on the federal government. Those who run for office can promise tax cuts and new spending initiatives. But the reality facing those who get elected, and we who have elected them, is that we are going to need more, not less, from taxes to meet the obligations we have already made — and that there will be little room for expensive new initiatives.
Jack Ochs is professor of economics, emeritus, at the University of Pittsburgh (jochs@pitt.edu). He lives in Point Breeze.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.