The Shell ethane cracker plant planned for construction in Beaver County has raised many concerns regarding its potential public health impacts in the community and region. A few years ago, when the facility was first being proposed, our group at the Center for Healthy Environments and Communities in the University of Pittsburgh School of Public Health prepared a report about a class of air pollutants termed “hazardous air pollutants” and some of the specific issues they pose for southwestern Pennsylvania. As part of that report, we attempted to discern what an ethane cracker of this size might mean to air quality in the region.
Using emissions data from a similar facility operating in Louisiana, we noted that such a plant would likely release significant amounts of air toxins known as volatile organic compounds as well as nitrogen oxides. These pollutants have adverse effects on their own, but one significant concern is their ability to promote the formation of ozone. Ozone is one of six air pollutants for which the Environmental Protection Agency sets standards because of its ability to exacerbate lung diseases such as asthma. The linkage between ozone and motor-vehicle traffic in many parts of the United States is indisputable. Therefore, I thought it useful to portray the cracker’s expected emissions in terms of motor-vehicle traffic to give readers perspective of its magnitude.
Shell’s own estimate for release of volatile organic compounds by the proposed plant is 484 tons per year. The EPA estimates an average automobile driving 12,000 miles annually emits about 27 pounds. Therefore, the proposed cracker would emit about as much as 35,800 cars. Emissions of nitrogen oxides from the plant also would be about the same as 36,000 cars (the plant would release about 327 tons per year).
Southwestern Pennsylvania — especially Allegheny County, which sits downwind of Beaver — already has some of the worst air quality in the nation and often ranks poorly in the daily Air Quality Index due to ozone.
The question then becomes, what would be the impact of putting an additional 36,000 cars on the road in the region?
Operation of the cracker would be similar to increasing existing vehicular traffic in Beaver County by about 25 percent. This alone is likely to make a significant impact, but it portends even larger increases in ozone should the promise of spinoff industrial expansion come true.
Therefore, state and local governments should not blindly support such industries simply for the sake of job creation. To at least maintain the status quo in terms of air quality, they should similarly invest in opportunities to mitigate the burden of air pollution in our region. These might include subsidies or tax breaks to encourage the use and expansion of regional mass transit and the design and construction of communities “friendly” to alternative modes of transportation, such as walking and biking. They also should similarly recruit “green,” sustainable, energy-efficient industries to the region.
Sadly, outside of the city of Pittsburgh, there seems little effort to do such green things, even though they, too, could stimulate the regional economy.
Moving forward, it will be critical for Shell, community groups and regulatory agencies to work cooperatively and transparently at the earliest stages of the cracker’s development to ensure that the best available methods and technology are employed throughout construction and operation so as to minimize adverse effects on the community and public health.
Because of this region’s industrial legacy and high level of community engagement, many residents of southwestern Pennsylvania are well-informed on environmental issues. Shell, regulators, local officials and others should not dismiss their concerns as trivial.
James P. Fabisiak is an associate professor of environmental and occupational health at the University of Pittsburgh.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.