Politics is not always so much about what a candidate says as how he says it, and Donald Trump’s antic style — hyperbole, bravado and belligerence — is making it impossible for many Americans to vote for him.

Mr. Trump’s core message is not far off from most mainstream conservative thinking. Our national borders are too porous. America projects an aura of weakness in a world that respects strength. We don’t win often enough in a game of international trade stacked by product dumping and other unfair practices by our ostensible trade “partners.”

The problem is that Mr. Trump’s muscular political style and lack of details suggests an autocrat, not a leader.

In the best-run companies, the CEO encourages frank advice from subordinates. In the worst-run firms, employees are afraid to point out even fatal flaws to the boss. One has to wonder whether the advisers to CEO Trump are willing to speak the truth to him.

Advertise with us

So let me be direct.

I’m a lifelong Republican and conservative. Yet, if Donald Trump doesn’t trim his rhetorical sails and provide more policy substance, I won’t be joining him on his journey should he win the nomination. His core message, however salient, is being obscured by rhetoric that won’t allow him to build working coalitions to make good on his promises.

Confrontation is useful in limited instances. With Mr. Trump, it seems to be the default setting. Gridlock is what we are attempting to overcome, and that’s not done by ramping up divisive rhetoric and demonizing the opposition.

For instance, how does Mr. Trump seriously hope to defeat Islamic terrorism without help from moderate Muslims? While his proposal to ban all Muslims from coming into the United States has campaign appeal for some Americans, he can’t make such a proposal and reasonably expect to gain the assistance of U.S. Muslims or of moderate leaders in countries such as Turkey, Jordan, Pakistan and Egypt who can fight terrorism at its source. It is not a serious solution; it is a recipe for continued failure.

Last weekend, Mr. Trump was asked on national television to condemn the racists and extremists who have latched onto his campaign, notably the Ku Klux Klan. He said he’d get back to us. Seriously, what is so difficult about denouncing the Ku Klux Klan? If he wants the support of people like me and others he needs to win in November, he must stop using rhetoric that draws racists to his cause.

Advertise with us

Mr. Trump’s degrading remarks about women, his poking fun at a disabled reporter and his juvenile use of words such as “loser” and “liar” from the debate podium have debased the electoral process to a level not seen since the 19th century. Refraining from such talk is not political correctness, it is common decency. How does he expect parents like me to teach our kids about treating others with respect and then turn around and cast a ballot for him?

He needs to dial it back, or he’ll lose the votes even of Republican lifers like me.

Ron Francis is a Gulf War veteran, former member of Allegheny County Council and partner specializing in international mergers and acquisitions at the law firm Reed Smith.