Recently the Catholic Church of the Multiplication at Tabgha in Israel was attacked and badly damaged by arsonists. Two persons were hospitalized and the damage is estimated in the millions of dollars.

The attack was all the more shocking because of the great religious and historical significance of the church, which is built on the ruins of a 4th-century shrine marking the place of the Miracle of the Loaves and Fishes on the Sea of Galilee. The church is one of the major Christian sites in Israel, drawing more than 2,000 visitors per day. It is maintained by the Benedictine monks of Dormition Abbey in Jerusalem, who also have a monastery on the site.

In addition to the extensive fire damage from the June 18 attack, Bibles were destroyed and graffiti in Hebrew was spray-painted on the walls accusing Christians of “idol worship.” These actions make it clear that this attack was in fact a hate crime directed against Christians.

Sadly, in recent years, Israel has suffered from a rise of religiously motivated violence committed by Jewish extremists. Rabbis for Human Rights reports that there have been 43 such incidents in Israel since 2009. Nor is this the first attack suffered by the community of Dormition Abbey. Just last year, the cross and the stone altar on the shore of the Galilee were desecrated. The Benedictine abbey on Mount Zion has also repeatedly been vandalized and, in 2012, soon after Pope Francis visited the area, the Church of the Dormition was attacked by arsonists.

Advertise with us

This pattern of violence undermines the culture of religious tolerance that has long been established in Israel. It also represents a setback in the progress toward greater inter-religious dialogue and peace-building in the region. The monastic community itself has for many years worked to promote tolerance by bringing disabled Jewish and Arab children and their families together for retreats at Tabgha.

The attack on the Church of the Multiplication is viewed by many as a turning point in the struggle against extremism. People of faith in Israel and throughout the world are demanding that the perpetrators be found and held accountable for their actions. The perpetrators of these hate crimes have rarely been arrested or punished. Now, however, for the good of the nation of Israel, rabbis and Jewish leaders in the United States and Israel are insisting that must change. Thousands of Israelis have expressed their support for the Benedictines by attending a recent prayer service at the Church of the Multiplication of Loaves and Fishes. Even more Israelis have expressed sentiments of support for the Benedictine monastic community.

Here in southwestern Pennsylvania, the Pittsburgh Jewish Federation issued a statement deploring the attack. “This is an opportunity to reaffirm our commitment to the struggle against extremism and to reach out to build coalitions with all communities who struggle with their own extremists and to promote tolerance and understanding,” the statement said.

On a national level, two rabbis who serve as official Catholic-Jewish dialogue partners with the U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops named steps that Israel should take to end these attacks. They include new legislation by the Israeli Knesset to ensure that such actions are treated as serious crimes and that perpetrators, including minors, receive appropriate punishment.

“No Israeli government would tolerate arson or hate crimes against sacred Jewish spots such as the Kotel [Western Wall] or the Capernaum synagogue. It is time to apply the same standards to sacred places revered by other faiths. We expect no less of the Jewish state,” said the letter from Rabbis David Straus and Gilbert S. Rosenthal to Ilan Sztulman, head of public diplomacy at the Israeli embassy in Washington, D.C.

Advertise with us

Benedictine Abbot Gregory Collins has said that his community is heartened by the support and encouragement that it has received. In responding to the attack, he stated, “We will try to answer this in a Christian way, with forgiveness, love and compassion. We will replace the terrible fire with the fire of God’s love and forgiveness.”

Religion and violence are incompatible, for the essence of religion is love and compassion, never hatred.

The recent acts of hate carried out at the Church of the Multiplication of Loaves and Fishes do not represent Judaism, just as the KKK does not represent Christianity.

We add our voices to those who affirm the right of Christians to worship freely in Israel.

We urge the authorities in Israel to investigate and hold accountable those who commit hate crimes.

Advertise with us

We stand strongly behind those who seek to deepen the respect and understanding between Christians and Jews.

David Zubik is bishop of the Catholic Diocese of Pittsburgh. Aaron Bisno issenior rabbi at Rodef Shalom Congregation in Squirrel Hill.