Those Indian kids sure spell well: Yes, they're inspiring, but don't buy into the 'model minority' myth

Share with others:

Print Email Read Later

When Snigdha Nandipati became the fifth consecutive Indian-American to win the Scripps National Spelling Bee last month, the 14-year-old did it by successfully spelling out "guetapens," a French-derived word that means "trap" or "snare."

In fact, Ms. Nandipati is the 10th Indian-American to claim the title in the last 14 years. What a model minority, right?

Ah, don't fall into this guetapens.

The myth of the "model minority," typically applied to Asian-Americans (including Indian-Americans), is a fiction that reinforces a single stereotype of an extraordinarily diverse community. This myth falsely suggests that Asian-Americans have overcome the same challenges other communities of color have failed to surmount and ignores the history of selective immigration and the significant number of Asian-Americans who are struggling to make ends meet.

In "The Karma of Brown Folk," Trinity College professor Vijay Prashad credited the disproportionate success of certain Asian-American communities to the 1965 Immigration and Nationality Act, passed by Congress to actively recruit scientists to the United States. For instance, between 1966 and 1977, 83 percent of the Indian immigrants to the United States were professionals such as engineers and medical doctors.

More recently, the information technology boom has created a new wave of Indian-American professional immigrants, including the parents of the past five Spelling Bee champs (all IT professionals or professors). Further explaining Indian-American success in the Bee, an entity called the "North South Foundation" acts as a sort of minor-league circuit for aspiring Indian-American spelling champions, training thousands of children every year, including the past five winners.

These hand-selected, highly educated immigrants ensured that their children would get the best educational opportunities and the resources to take advantage of them.

If the slave trade had centered on Thailand instead of West Africa, if China happened to border the United States to the south or if Columbus had actually colonized (Asian) Indians, Asian-Americans would likely have a very different reputation today.

Mr. Prashad theorized that the American (white) establishment created the "model minority" concept to blame traditionally disenfranchised communities of color for their economic plight: "These non-white people are successful, why aren't you?"

This tactic diverts attention and culpability from factors that perpetuate poverty in these communities: past government injustices, such as land theft and slavery, and more recent discriminatory actions, such as redlining and predatory lending.

Despite the relative success of some Asian-Americans, others are struggling to get by. The 2010 American Community Survey estimated that 16.4 percent of Asian-Americans live in relative poverty and 18 percent of Asian-Americans live without health insurance.

According to a recent study by the Economic Policy Institute, Asian-Americans suffer from the highest rates of long-term unemployment when compared to whites, African-Americans and Latinos. The widespread and false notion that all Asian-Americans are successful, however, allows policy makers to ignore this segment of the community when crafting policies to help Americans get by.

Furthermore, Asian-Americans, having origins in markedly dissimilar regions and countries and immigrating to America under widely different circumstances, are too diverse to lump into one demographic category. For instance, Cambodian-American and Bangladeshi-American families often have more difficult challenges than Japanese-American and Indian-American families. Disaggregated data for each community, such as those provided by the American Community Survey (now under attack by congressional Republicans), would yield a truer picture of Asian-American success.

Lifting the veil of the "model minority" myth should not detract from Asian-American successes, typically achieved through discipline, hard work and despite obstacles such as language barriers, coerced assimilation and racial bias. And Ms. Nandipati's laudable achievement should be unconditionally celebrated.

But all Americans, including Asian-Americans who have bought into this fiction, should act as "mythbusters" and start talking about the real reasons some communities of color are not doing as well as others.


Anand Subramanian is an attorney and program manager for the Closing the Racial Wealth Gap Initiative at the Insight Center for Community Economic Development in Oakland, Calif. This article originally appeared at (C) 2012 Independent Media Institute.

You have 2 remaining free articles this month

Try unlimited digital access

If you are an existing subscriber,
link your account for free access. Start here

You’ve reached the limit of free articles this month.

To continue unlimited reading

If you are an existing subscriber,
link your account for free access. Start here