The difference between what we as Americans say we believe and what we — or, in this case, our leaders — actually do bothers me all year round but gets under my skin most intensely at Christmas. Maybe it’s the seasonal music on the “T.”

This year it is a close contest between Supreme Court Justice Antonin G. Scalia and presidential candidate Donald J. Trump for scummiest behavior of the season.

Justice Scalia, in arguments at the Supreme Court this month, stated a view of black Americans that would likely force the resignation from office of any other American public official: “Most of the black scientists in this country don’t come from schools like the University of Texas. They come from lesser schools where they do not feel that they’re being pushed ahead in classes that are too fast for them.”

The statement by the 79-year-old justice was made in the context of a discussion about whether it is constitutional for a university to consider race in admissions. It also should be considered in the political context of the “Black Lives Matter” movement and the growing debate about race on American campuses and across American society.

Advertise with us

What Justice Scalia said was, basically, that most black Americans who aspire to be scientists cannot keep pace with classes in schools like the University of Texas and should study at “lesser” institutions where they would not feel pushed in classes that are “too fast” for them.

That would mean, for example, that Republican candidate for president Ben Carson probably should not have been admitted to Yale. Nor should President Barack Obama have been allowed into Columbia or Harvard Law School. Would Justice Scalia consider his own undergraduate university, Georgetown, to be in the lesser or higher category of institutions of higher learning? The University of Texas is currently ranked No. 52 in U.S. News and World Report.

Justice Scalia’s statement is flat-out racist. He should resign or retire from the Supreme Court immediately. The need for justices to have independence of thought is one thing. Stating a belief that black Americans are inherently inferior — to whom?  to white Americans?  to Mr. Scalia? — is to state a falsehood.  It is unacceptable for a justice on America’s highest court.

It is also worth noting that Mr. Scalia is Catholic. Has he heard of Pope Francis? He probably considers himself a Christian. If he hasn’t heard of peace on Earth, it is possible that he has heard of good will to men on Earth.  This does not mean “to white men on Earth” or “to overweight white Catholics on Earth.” No wonder some Americans have little confidence in our judicial system.

Donald J. Trump might be worse.  At least no one is talking about making Justice Scalia president.  It will be interesting to see if Mr. Trump’s position on excluding Muslims from entering the country costs him the Republican nomination, or the presidency if he gets the nomination.

Advertise with us

What he has in mind is unconstitutional as well as absurd. Would we have to state our religious affiliation on our passports, or on a new identity card?  Would the silly claim that President Obama is a Muslim become a basis for possibly excluding him from entering the United States if he tried to return home from abroad?

Mr. Trump’s behavior toward the Republican Party establishment and the American people may be the most ironic part of the presidential campaign. His actions and words are so outrageous that I have to wonder if he isn’t, in fact, trying to run some Atlantic City-type game on us, posing as a presidential candidate while laughing at us in private and eating up the publicity, so good for his various businesses and his speaking fees.

Will he, at some point, no longer be able to keep a straight face, or run out of hairspray and own up to the joke?

In the meantime, the anti-Muslim part of his spiel is truly out of line — un-American one might say — and causes Muslims to join the other groups of Americans that Republicans have alienated, among them women, blacks, Hispanics, Asians and gays.  I have to wonder if the party’s leaders have any sense of America’s evolving demographics.  I would have to guess not, considering the positions their candidates have taken.

“Anti-Muslim” also spills over into “anti-immigrant,” a truly astonishing position for a candidate of a major American party to take given the heritage of this country. Even if one were  lily-white, with an Anglo-Saxon background, chances are that some of his or her ancestors came to this country in the mid-to-late 19th century. I have a drawing on my wall of a great-grandfather who emigrated from England in that time frame to work in the steel mills. If I were anti-immigrant, I would not be able to look him in the eyes with a clear conscience.

Advertise with us

The bottom line with both Justice Scalia and Mr. Trump is that neither of them is kind, or of good will, although both probably profess to be Christians. I know quite well that the world isn’t the little town of Bethlehem. (We should be glad, relatively speaking, given the situation of Bethlehem in the Israeli-occupied, Palestinian majority West Bank, a subject for another day.) But couldn’t these two, and the rest of us, try to think about tidings of great joy at this time of year?  We don’t need more trolls.

Dan Simpson, a former U.S. ambassador, is a Post-Gazette associate editor (dsimpson@post-gazette. com, 412-263-1976).