Opponents of nuclear deal in Iran speak up

Share with others:

Print Email Read Later

TEHRAN -- As Iran and world powers move closer to a long-term agreement over the Islamic republic's nuclear activities, domestic political struggles here are threatening to undermine the diplomatic process, which both the White House and the administration of Iran's president, Hassan Rouhani, say is on the right track.

Despite wide public support and the approval of important blocs of politicians and clerics, a range of opponents -- mostly in Iran's parliament -- worry that they could lose influence if a solution to the nuclear dispute is struck without their involvement in the negotiations.

The tough line taken by Iranian lawmakers mirrors that taken in the U.S. Congress, who are pushing for more sanctions on Tehran. President Barack Obama has vowed to veto any new sanctions legislation while talks are ongoing.

On Monday, Iran's Foreign Minister, Mohammad Javad Zarif, told the German Council on Foreign Relations that "with good will, we can reach an agreement within six months."

But skeptics in both Tehran and Washington caution against rushing into a deal that could potentially favor the other side.

As new talks are scheduled to begin Feb. 18 in Vienna, these figures are becoming increasingly critical of the Islamic republic's negotiating team.

"The West has so far not shown any serious intention to solve this issue that they created themselves," Vahid Ahmadi, a cleric and lawmaker who sits on the parliament's foreign relations commissions, said in a parliament session Monday. "Although we will keep our commitments, we will never cross our red line, which is to maintain our nuclear achievements."

Since the nuclear dossier was transferred to the control of Iran's Foreign Ministry soon after Mr. Rouhani took office, the hard-line press and conservative members of Iran's parliament have sought to require more oversight in future rounds of nuclear talks, citing a lack of transparency as their biggest complaint.

"I am telling our nation today that we are neither informed of foreign policies of this government, nor of what they are doing domestically. They are doing whatever they like," lawmaker Mehdi Kouchakzadeh, a harsh critic of the government, said in parliament Monday.

On Sunday, in a sign that conservatives may be regaining some political clout lost since Mr. Rouhani's election, members of the foreign policy commission said they had reached an agreement with the administration to add a member of parliament to the negotiating team, which would likely quiet some of the loudest critics among them.

Members of Iran's political establishment who have long argued that the conflict with the U.S. is an existential one, and who consider normalized relations incongruous with decades of anti-Western policy and rhetoric, stand to lose the most if a compromise is reached, analysts say.

For these hard-liners, "the mere reaching of an agreement will cause an ideological crisis," said U.S.-based Iran analyst Farideh Farhi, who recently returned from several months in Iran.

Beyond the political arena, there are others profiting financially from sanctions on Iran, who would lose if conditions normalize. "There are many vested interests that see little benefit in Iran opening up to the world," Tehran-based analyst Mohammad Ali Shabani said.

The most notorious case is that of Babak Zanjani, who amassed billions of dollars selling oil that illegally evaded sanctions. He is being held in prison on corruption charges.

In addition to well-connected syndicates, countless smaller players are earning large returns on smuggling in everything from cars to basic foodstuffs. Currency speculators also fall into this category and have profited heavily from the discrepancy in official and street rates, as well as stoking public concerns about a collapse of Iran's currency, the rial.

"Our people expect the president to expose those who are exploiting the sanctions to the nation and judiciary," Kamaloddin Pir Moazen told fellow parliament members this week.

While identifying many individuals and entities illegally profiting from sanctions on Iran is difficult, there are also vast Iranian companies, including domestic automakers, food producers and petrochemical firms, that benefit from the longtime lack of competition caused by the sanctions.

Despite these vocal foes of compromise, there is consensus among the majority of the political establishment, as well as Iran's private-sector business community, that finding a solution to the decade-long nuclear dispute would serve the country's interests.


Create a free PG account.
Already have an account?