Pennsylvania infrastructure passed, but barely. A report card released Wednesday by the American Society of Civil Engineers gave the state's infrastructure an average grade of C-, citing the commonwealth's aging and deteriorating water and sewage systems as the biggest problem areas.

Across 18 categories, including rail, transit, aviation, and water management, the report gave the state a grade below C- a third of the time and above C+ in just three areas.

The state got the same grade the last time the report card was issued in 2014, but Society of Civil Engineers identified different problem areas at the time: bridges and roads. The state's roads have been bumped up from a D- to a D+, while the bridges have held steady at a D+.

The state's C- beats the D+ the national organization gave the entire country in 2017. Pennsylvania stands out on parks and recreation and hazardous waste infrastructure, two categories in which it scored a B- while the country as a whole scored a D+ on those categories.

Advertise with us

Dozens of Pennsylvania civil engineers used methodology set and reviewed by the national group.

"The grades unveiled today reflect the current state of our infrastructure and are not reflections of the agencies in our state that are tasked with maintaining our infrastructure, often with limited budgets," said Bob Dengler, president of American Society of Civil Engineers Pittsburgh section, at the report's unveiling.

Wastewater infrastructure earned Pennsylvania's worst grade, a D-, and drinking water, stormwater, inland waterways and transit all received Ds. The report noted that many of the state's sewer systems are more than 100 years old, and there's an overall $8.4 billion funding gap in upgrading them. Drinking water faces an even larger $10.2 billion gap, the report said. Cast iron water mains, which make up the majority of the state's water mains, have seen a 43 percent increase in breakage rates since 2014.

Ralph Gilbert, past president of the Pittsburgh chapter, said the problem came in part from water utilities fees falling behind costs.

"We're encouraging and supporting the passing of legislation to allow municipalities to align user fees with the true costs," he said.

Advertise with us

Another problem cited was the increasing frequency and severity of major storms, which puts pressure on the stormwater infrastructure.

"Stormwater management has been based on the assumption that variation is within a fixed band. Now we're seeing that variation is changing, frequency of outlier storms is increasing and the size of variation is increasing. The assumptions of our systems are being challenged," said Greg Scott, a senior engineer at Buchart Horn who wrote the report's wastewater section. The stormwater grade went down from 2014, when it received a D+.

Inland waterways, including Pittsburgh's extensive lock and dam system, saw an identical decline, from D+ to D.

"Natural waterways are one of the most green forms of transportation available," pointed out Mr. Scott. If waterways became unnavigable, moving the goods they move to trucks and trains would greatly increase pollution.

The highest grade was a B, given to the state's freight rail system, which includes 5,604 miles of track, the fifth largest network in the United States.

Advertise with us

Mr. Scott said freight hauled has increased 20 percent in the last 10 years, “but there's been no corresponding increase in derailings or accidents.” The Station Square derailment, he said, "could have been a lot worse."

"An A is brand-new gleaming infrastructure, so it's hard for everything to be an A," said Mr. Gilbert.

The report credited Act 89, a 2013 law that raised the cap on the oil company franchise tax (paid by fuel distributors) and funneled the money into infrastructure spending, with the increase in the state's roads score from D- to D+. It resulted in "2,600 projects that are currently in progress or have been completed," according to the report.

Act 89 also helped lower the number of bridges in poor condition, from 24 percent in 2014 to 18 percent today, but the bridges grade was unchanged.

"While PennDOT has removed a lot of bridges from the list, a lot of other bridges are aging and being added," said Mr. Scott.

Advertise with us

The report identifies two big funding threats to continued improvements of Pennsylvania's infrastructure. In 2023, annual funding from Act 44, a 2007 law that expanded the Pennsylvania Turnpike's mandate beyond the Turnpike, declines from $450 million to $50 million. Additionally, there is a pending lawsuit by a group of truckers challenging the use of turnpike tolls for non-turnpike infrastructure spending.

Most of the progress identified in the report was on catching up on maintenance, said Mr. Scott. "The state has made improvements on deferred maintenance, but we haven't moved the needle on economic development." Part of the problem was a lack of federal funding.

"We're encouraged by some of the conversations occurring in Washington about infrastructure being a shared priority among all parties," said Lance Chimka, director of Allegheny County Economic Development.

"If and when an infrastructure bill comes out, they'll find a willing participant in Allegheny County," he said.

Christopher Huffaker: chuffaker@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1724 or @huffakingit.