Suit: Penn State blocked fair election

Share with others:

Print Email Read Later

UNIVERSITY PARK, Pa. — Penn State Univer­sity has been in the un­usual po­si­tion the past few months of de­fend­ing it­self from a law­suit brought against it, in part, by its own trust­ees. Now, the uni­ver­sity is about to face a law­suit from some­one who wanted to be a trustee.

Former state Rep. Jess Stairs filed a no­tice Tues­day in Cen­tre County that he in­tends to sue Penn State and trust­ees Keith Masser and Betsy Huber re­gard­ing re­sults of the board of trust­ees elec­tion of ag­ri­cul­tural trust­ees.

Mr. Stairs is not seek­ing mon­e­tary dam­ages. His law­yer, Dean Pier­mat­tei, said Mr. Stairs wants a res­o­lu­tion of a fair elec­tion pro­cess.

Mr. Stairs ran against in­cum­bents Mr. Masser and Ms. Huber in the May elec­tions. Mr. Masser was the lead­ing vote-get­ter, and Ms. Huber edged Mr. Stairs by one vote. The ag­ri­cul­tural so­ci­et­ies have a dif­fer­ent vot­ing struc­ture than the alumni elec­tions. Rather than hav­ing alumni vote in a di­rect elec­tion, ag­ri­cul­tural so­ci­et­ies from each county se­lect as many as three del­egates to vote for can­di­dates.

Mr. Pier­mat­tei said the re­sults from Ven­ango County were com­pro­mised. He said three del­egates from Ven­ango reg­is­tered to vote for Mr. Stairs, and later three del­egates also from Ven­ango reg­is­tered to vote for Mr. Huber. When more than three del­egates are rep­re­sent­ing a county, they are re­quired to form a cau­cus and de­cide which three del­egates will rep­resent that county, ac­cord­ing to Penn State’s trustee vot­ing rules. Mr. Pier­mat­tei said there was no cau­cus, and the del­egates cho­sen were the three who voted for Ms. Huber.

On Tues­day, Ms. Huber and Mr. Stairs could not be reached for com­ment. Mr. Pier­mat­tei said Penn State had un­der­taken an in­ves­ti­ga­tion of the re­sults with the con­clu­sion that the re­sults should stand. He said this law­suit was Mr. Stairs’ last re­sort to get a “fair elec­tion pro­cess” af­ter hav­ing run up “against the wall.”

Penn State re­leased a state­ment say­ing, “The Univer­sity be­lieves that Mr. Stairs’ al­le­ga­tions are with­out merit. The Univer­sity is very dis­ap­pointed that Mr. Stairs has cho­sen this course of ac­tion and that it will be re­quired to de­vote Univer­sity re­sources to de­fend­ing this lit­i­ga­tion. Be­cause this mat­ter now is the sub­ject of pend­ing lit­i­ga­tion, the Univer­sity will have no fur­ther pub­lic com­ment.”

One of the other law­suits Penn State is fac­ing also has been de­vel­op­ing in re­cent days. In the case of Paterno et. al. v. the NCAA and Penn State, the op­pos­ing sides dis­pute a com­po­nent of a pro­tec­tive or­der.

The plain­tiffs don’t want a blan­ket pro­tec­tive or­der, which would seal pre­trial dis­cov­ery ma­teri­als in any fo­rum other than trial prep­a­ra­tion, and filed a mo­tion last week. The Paterno law­yers wrote the pub­lic has “a keen in­ter­est in what hap­pened in the in­ves­ti­ga­tions at Penn State and a right to ac­cess to the pub­lic pro­cess of court pro­ceed­ings.”

The NCAA is seek­ing a pro­tec­tive or­der to seal the doc­u­ments.

On Mon­day, Penn State filed a mo­tion ex­press­ing the same. The uni­ver­sity’s law­yers ar­gued that the plain­tiffs would oth­er­wise at­tempt to con­duct a “pub­lic re­la­tions cam­paign.”

Mark Dent: mdent@post-ga­, 412-439-3791 and Twit­ter @mdent05.

Join the conversation:

Commenting policy | How to report abuse
To report inappropriate comments, abuse and/or repeat offenders, please send an email to and include a link to the article and a copy of the comment. Your report will be reviewed in a timely manner. Thank you.
Commenting policy | How to report abuse

Create a free PG account.
Already have an account?

You have 2 remaining free articles this month

Try unlimited digital access

If you are an existing subscriber,
link your account for free access. Start here

You’ve reached the limit of free articles this month.

To continue unlimited reading

If you are an existing subscriber,
link your account for free access. Start here