Three candidates will vie for two open seats on the Allegheny County Common Pleas Court next week.

Allegheny County has 43 judges who sit in four different divisions: civil, criminal, family and orphan’s. In Pennsylvania, Common Pleas Court judges serve 10-year terms and earn $178,868 annually.

Out of six candidates in May’s primary, Patrick Connelly, Mary McGinley and David Spurgeon emerged as winners to move on to the general election.

Mr. Connelly, 49, who lives with his wife in Lawrenceville, ran for a seat on the bench in 2013, and dropped out in 2015 after he failed to get the Democratic endorsement.

Advertise with us

He believes that it is essential for a judge to have worked in the past as a trial attorney. Mr Connelly, who earned his law degree from West Virginia University, was a civil litigator for 23 years, trying cases all over Western and Central Pennsylvania.

He most recently was appointed to serve as a mediator and arbitrator in federal court.

“A judicial seat is the next natural step in my career progression,” Mr. Connelly said.

The same skills that he uses as an arbitrator would serve him well as a judge, Mr. Connelly said: a good temperament and the ability to be impartial and fair.

As an attorney, he said, the job is to help clients solve problems. As a judge, he continued, it will be the same, just without the advocacy.

Advertise with us

Mr. Connelly, who serves as a mentor in the Pittsburgh Public Schools, was rated as highly recommended for this election by the Allegheny County Bar Association.

Because of his breadth of experience trying cases in courtrooms across the commonwealth, Mr. Connelly believes he has seen both good and bad practices, which would allow him to help guide the development of the courts.

“I don’t want to be someone to pound my chest and say, ‘If I get in there, I’m going to change the world,’” he said.

But that doesn’t mean Mr. Connelly would not want to help the court run more smoothly.

He notes that his background is not much different than Judge Spurgeon’s — outside of the fact that Mr. Connelly has practiced civil law, while Judge Spurgeon spent his career in the criminal courts.

Advertise with us

Of the seven judges elected in the last two elections, none of them came from private, civil litigation backgrounds, he said.

“I think there’s something to be said for having a diverse background of experience for Common Pleas judges.”

Ms. McGinley, 40, of Squirrel Hill, has been a practicing attorney for 15 years.

She graduated from Duquesne law school and has focused her career in private practice doing civil litigation, primarily business disputes, and in orphan’s court handling wills, trusts and non-profit matters.

Ms. McGinley prides herself on being able to resolve clients’ problems before they have to get to court. She also notes that she is able to facilitate dialogue among the parties to a case and calm what, otherwise, could be a heated, emotional process.

Advertise with us

Ms. McGinley, who earned a recommended rating from the bar association, grew up in Mt. Lebanon in a family that is a minority owner of the Pittsburgh Steelers. She is the first woman to serve on the board of directors for the team and believes her family’s legacy has given her opportunities to earn trust in the community.

“This is my way of giving back, stepping into a leadership role that I think can be impactful,” she said. “I think a judge’s role is to sit back and listen, and I think that’s one of the strengths I have.”

Ms. McGinley, who has chaired the bar foundation’s Attorneys Against Hunger Campaign for more than 10 years, said she was inspired by the career of her uncle, Bernard McGinley, who served for many years on the state’s Commonwealth Court.

Were she to be elected, Ms. McGinley said, she would like to eventually have a visionary role on the court, identifying areas that need to be improved and facilitating dialogue with her colleagues to ultimately implement change.

Ms. McGinley, who is married and has two children, ages 5 and 7, lives with her family in Squirrel Hill.

Advertise with us

David Spurgeon, 45, of McKeesport, was appointed to fill a vacant seat on the Common Pleas court in June 2016 by Gov. Tom Wolf.

He was assigned to the Family Division, where he hears delinquency and dependency cases, as well as Protection From Abuse cases two or three times each week.

Judge Spurgeon, who is rated highly recommended by the county bar association, spent 20 years as a trial lawyer and joined the Allegheny County District Attorney’s office in 1998. In 2001, he was promoted to the domestic violence unit, and in 2009, he was promoted to deputy DA overseeing it.

He put together a group of people to form the first intimate-partner violence review team to help identify and address problems in the system, and he also was the first prosecutor to go to family court to prosecute a defendant for violating a PFA.

“The courts need to be adaptive, reactive, proactive and able to address our community issues as they happen,” he said. “Here, you feel like you have the ability to make and affect change.”

Advertise with us

Judge Spurgeon, who previously served on the board for the Center for Victims, sought the Democratic endorsement in 2015 but dropped out when he did not receive it.

“It’s another step in my public service career,” Judge Spurgeon said. “I think it’s an admirable place to practice law.”

Judge Spurgeon, who earned his law degree from Duquesne University where he now teaches, said that since joining the family division, he feels that he’s making a difference in children’s lives every day.

Typically, newly elected judges are assigned to the family division, which hears dependency, divorce, juvenile delinquency and PFA cases.

Judge Spurgeon, who grew up in McKeesport and remains in the Mon Valley, said there are no judges from that area currently sitting on the Allegheny County bench. With a quarter of the county’s population from there, he said, that community ought to have representation in the courts.

Advertise with us

“Sometimes you need people who are reflective of those communities,” he said. “Sometimes, you need real people to be real judges to judge real people.”

There are also four judges up for retention this year. The Allegheny County Bar Association has recommended all four.

They are: Judge Kelly E. Bigley, Criminal Division; Judge Cathleen Bubash, Family Division. Judge Michael McCarthy, Orphans’ Court; Judge John “Jack” McVay, Civil Division

Paula Reed Ward: pward@post-gazette.com, 412-263-2620 or on Twitter: @PaulaReedWard.