Two decades later, suspect arrested in killing of 2 women

For the family of the victims, the news brings a sense of relief but painful memories as well

Share with others:

Print Email Read Later

Her body was found in a wooded area south of the Long Island Ex­press­way in North Shir­ley, N.Y., about 17 miles east of where she had last been seen, en­ter­ing a small blue car out­side the Blue Dawn Diner in Islan­dia. She was Col­leen McNamee, 20, and she had been stran­gled and bru­tally beaten.

Two months ear­lier, in No­vem­ber 1993, an­other young woman, Rita Tan­gredi, 31, who, like Ms. McNamee, was be­lieved to have been a pros­ti­tute, had been killed nearby, her nude body posed the same way as Ms. McNamee’s.

Twenty years be­fore sec­tions of Long Island beach­front brush be­came a dump­ing ground for pros­ti­tutes’ bod­ies, these two un­solved mur­ders stag­gered the vic­tims’ fam­ily and friends, leav­ing a trail of dev­as­ta­tion that friends say in­cluded the sui­cide of Ms. McNamee’s boy­friend.

Now, fo­ren­sic work by the Suf­folk County Po­lice Depart­ment, com­bined with changes to DNA col­lec­tion pro­ce­dures, has brought some long-de­layed re­lief to fam­ily and friends: John Bit­trolff, 48, a car­pen­ter and mar­ried father of two from nearby Manor­ville, was ar­rested last month on charges of mur­der­ing Ms. McNamee and Ms. Tan­gredi.

He is be­ing held with­out bail af­ter plead­ing not guilty last week. In­ves­ti­ga­tors are also ex­am­in­ing whether Mr. Bit­trolff could have been in­volved in the death of a third woman on Long Island, 28-year-old San­dra Cos­tilla, whose body was found in North Sea in No­vem­ber 1993.

“It was the mir­a­cle of DNA which al­lowed us to ar­rest him and then pros­e­cute him,” Suf­folk County Dis­trict At­tor­ney Tho­mas J. Spota said.

At both mur­der scenes, the killer had left clues. The same item of cloth­ing was miss­ing from both ar­eas, and their nude bod­ies were posed iden­ti­cally. Near the bod­ies were wood shav­ings. And both Ms. McNamee and Ms. Tan­gredi had been beaten so badly that brain tis­sue was ex­posed.

Mr. Bit­trolff’s ar­rest, pros­e­cu­tors say, could be traced to his brother Tim­o­thy’s con­vic­tion last year on crim­i­nal con­tempt charges for vi­o­lat­ing an or­der of pro­tec­tion.

Act­ing on a 2012 New York state law that al­lows law en­force­ment to take DNA sam­ples from any­one con­victed of a crime, au­thor­i­ties col­lected Tim­o­thy’s Bit­trolff’s ge­netic ma­terial, which proved a par­tial match to the DNA in se­men found on Ms. McNamee’s and Ms. Tan­gredi’s bod­ies.

De­tec­tives be­gan ex­am­in­ing rel­a­tives of Tim­o­thy Bit­trolff. They ex­tracted DNA from a cig­a­rette butt thrown out a win­dow by a third Bit­trolff brother, but the re­sults did not match, Mr. Spota said. Then, when John Bit­trolff was be­ing ques­tioned by au­thor­i­ties, he took a sip of wa­ter. Bits of sa­liva taken from the glass, Mr. Spota said, linked him to the de­cades-old mur­ders.

Mr. Bit­trolff’s law­yer, Wil­liam Kea­hon, de­fended his cli­ent in court last week, say­ing “the in­dict­ment is proof of noth­ing.” Mr. Keaton added, “He’s kind, gen­er­ous, the best neigh­bor you could have.”

The ar­rest briefly al­layed the pain of peo­ple who had qui­etly mourned the two women for de­cades, even as res­i­dents be­came trans­fixed by a new string of mur­ders of women, some of them pros­ti­tutes, in and around Gilgo Beach. (Mr. Spota has made clear that there is no known con­nec­tion be­tween the two sets of kill­ings.)

For some, though, re­lief gave way to a fa­mil­iar kind of heart­ache, as state­ments by pros­e­cu­tors about the vic­tims’ work as pros­ti­tutes dredged up mem­o­ries of the way the women were over­looked at the time of their death.

“We’ve been wait­ing a long time for this case to break, and I’m just thank­ful now that it has,” said Law­rence McNamee, Col­leen McNamee’s father. “But in its break­ing, it’s opened up a lot of mem­o­ries that took a long time to put aside.”

Be­fore her death, Ms. McNamee had been re­ceiv­ing out­pa­tient treat­ment for drug ad­dic­tion in an ef­fort to es­cape the fate that had claimed so many young peo­ple in her neigh­bor­hood, friends say. She was known as a bub­bly peace­maker in Sa­chem High School on Long Island, dress­ing im­pec­ca­bly. She could be heard in hall­ways im­plor­ing friends in a squeaky voice to stop fight­ing or sleep­ing in class.

But Ms. McNamee fell into the wrong crowd, said a friend, Sta­cey Ann, 36, and her name was pulled through the muck by po­lice and news­pa­pers when her body was found in Jan­u­ary 1994. Ms. Ann said her friend’s death was dis­re­garded be­cause of as­sump­tions po­lice made about her line of work.

“They la­beled her as a pros­ti­tute,” Ms. Ann said. “They’re gone, both her and Rita. Stop call­ing her that.”

Rita Tan­gredi’s son, An­thony Tan­gredi, who told re­port­ers af­ter Mr. Bit­trolff’s ar­raign­ment that he felt re­lieved, did not re­spond to emails and phone calls seek­ing ad­di­tional com­ment.

Ms. McNamee’s friends gath­ered Sun­day night with a few of Rita Tan­gredi’s rel­a­tives for a can­dle­light vigil to re­mem­ber the two women on the wind­swept Smith Point Park in Mas­tic Beach.

On her way home from the vigil, Jeni­fer Kauff, 41, a friend of Ms. McNamee, had no choice but to drive by the exit off the Wil­liam Floyd Park­way where her friend’s body had been found. She had avoided the site for the last 20 years.

“It felt like a scab be­ing ripped off all the time,” Ms. Kauff said, “a wound that never com­pletely healed for all of us.”

United States - North America - New York


You have 2 remaining free articles this month

Try unlimited digital access

If you are an existing subscriber,
link your account for free access. Start here

You’ve reached the limit of free articles this month.

To continue unlimited reading

If you are an existing subscriber,
link your account for free access. Start here