Shinseki resigns from Veterans Affairs

Departure comes amid scandal

Share with others:

Print Email Read Later

WASHINGTON -- Eric Shinseki resigned as Veterans Affairs secretary Friday, apologizing for a scandal in which employees throughout the VA's massive hospital system conspired to hide months-long wait times that veterans faced when seeking care.

The size and scope of the coverups in an agency that he had presided over for more than five years left Mr. Shinseki dumbfounded and President Barack Obama searching for a replacement for one of his longest-serving and most trusted Cabinet officials. Mr. Obama said Sloan Gibson, the VA deputy secretary, will take over until a new secretary is named.

In announcing Mr. Shinseki's resignation, Mr. Obama went out of his way to describe the former Army general as a person of integrity who presided over a bureaucracy that was overwhelmed by two long wars and an aging veteran population, and which ultimately succumbed to widespread cheating to hide its shortcomings.

"I want to reiterate, he is a very good man," the president said at the White House. "I don't just mean that he's an accomplished man. I don't just mean that he's been an outstanding soldier. He's a good person, who's done exemplary work on our behalf."

Mr. Obama concluded, however, that the growing calls for Mr. Shinseki's firing had become too much of a distraction from the complicated work of fixing the troubled department.

The problems surrounding long wait times for care -- and VA employees' attempts to cover them up -- have been around for years, detailed in more than 18 watchdog reports dating back to 2000. The latest, and most damning, review was released earlier this week by the VA inspector general and immediately spurred the wave of bipartisan calls for Mr. Shinseki's ouster. Mr. Shinseki himself seemed stunned by the report's conclusion that he had, for the last five years, been presiding over a deeply flawed and dishonest bureaucracy.

"I can't explain the lack of integrity among some of the leaders of our health care facilities," Mr. Shinseki said shortly before he quit his post. "This is something I rarely encountered during my 38 years in uniform. I cannot defend it because it is indefensible. But I can take responsibility for it, and I do."

Mr. Shinseki's fall at the VA was triggered by a confluence of problems, including poor leadership at VA hospitals, woefully dated technology and a health care system that couldn't handle the strain caused by almost 13 years of war and Vietnam veterans using the system in greater numbers, according to his former top aides.

Mr. Shinseki's forced resignation amid dwindling political support raises a difficult question for the Obama administration: Can anyone reform an agency that, as the president acknowledged Friday, had been dogged by management and funding problems for a "very long" time?

Soon after he took over the VA in 2009, Mr. Shinseki tried to improve the leadership culture by meeting quarterly with every hospital director in the agency's giant network, sometimes for hours. "It was months and months and months, ... every single day getting a personal read," said Rep. Tammy Duckworth, D-Ill., who worked for Mr. Shinseki at the VA. "No other secretary had ever done that."

Mr. Shinseki, who lost half of his right foot to a mine in Vietnam, also pushed for more education and training, similar to the kind the Army had instituted in the 1970s when it wrestled with widespread discipline problems, mistrust and dissent in its ranks. Neither of those efforts was enough to ensure that managers -- seeking performance bonuses and promotions -- were willing to acknowledge the problems inside VA's healthcare system, which grew worse over the last five years as more than 2 million patients were added to the rolls.

"As Ric Shinseki himself indicated, there is a need for a change in culture within the [Veterans Health Administration], and perhaps the VA as a whole, to make sure that bad news gets surfaced quickly so things can be fixed," Mr. Obama said.

John Gingrich, Mr. Shinseki's chief of staff until 2012, stated the problem more starkly: "When people don't have integrity, it is hard to transform them."

Mr. Shinseki also struggled to update the VA's electronic scheduling systems, some of which had been in place since the 1980s. The aging system made it difficult for low-level employees to track patients and made it almost impossible for top VA officials in Washington to get reliable data on how long veterans were waiting for care. The president on Friday described these technology problems as "eminently fixable."

But plans to build a new scheduling system have been discussed for more than 14 years and have languished because of a lack of funding and the need to address more pressing needs within the overburdened VA system. "It's a simple question of bandwidth and priorities," said Peter Levin, a former senior technology adviser to Mr. Shinseki at the VA.

As the strain on the system and mid-level VA managers mounted, a culture of cheating and lying took hold within the department, former officials said. "It is like the Army at the end of the Vietnam War," said a top VA official, who requested anonymity to speak frankly about the VA woes. "You can only press so hard before even people with the highest values start to succumb to the lowest common denominator."

Until recently, Mr. Shinseki was best known in Washington as the four-star Army general who had drawn the ire of the George W. Bush administration by predicting that several hundred thousand troops would be needed to stabilize Iraq in the wake of a U.S. invasion.

Mr. Shinseki's reputation as a straight shooter who had fought for his country won him widespread admiration in Washington. One admirer was Ms. Duckworth, a first-term lawmaker who lost both her legs after a helicopter accident in Iraq in 2004. She became an outspoken war critic as she recovered and befriended then-Illinois Sen. Barack Obama, who backed her unsuccessful 2006 congressional bid. Later, she joined the Obama administration as a VA assistant secretary for public affairs -- the public face of the department -- and reported to Mr. Shinseki.

"I'd mop floors for Ric Shinseki," she said in a 2009 interview shortly after she took the job. She reaffirmed those sentiments last week. "He cares about veterans as deeply as anyone," she said. "His entire life has been spent taking care of soldiers. "

By Friday morning -- after reading the VA inspector general report, speaking with fellow veterans and hearing from constituents -- Ms. Duckworth delivered a significant psychological and political blow to Mr. Obama, her political patron, and Mr. Shinseki, her former boss. "Our first priority should be the veterans, and at this point whether Secretary Shinseki will stay or go is too much of a distraction," she said in an interview before Mr. Shinseki submitted his resignation. "I think he has to go."

Many of Mr. Shinseki's closest aides and Capitol Hill backers pointed to his achievements running the VA, especially his effort to reduce veteran homelessness by 25 percent during his tenure.

Join the conversation:

Commenting policy | How to report abuse
To report inappropriate comments, abuse and/or repeat offenders, please send an email to and include a link to the article and a copy of the comment. Your report will be reviewed in a timely manner. Thank you.
Commenting policy | How to report abuse


You have 2 remaining free articles this month

Try unlimited digital access

If you are an existing subscriber,
link your account for free access. Start here

You’ve reached the limit of free articles this month.

To continue unlimited reading

If you are an existing subscriber,
link your account for free access. Start here