Federal investigators have launched what is believed to be a broad and unprecedented investigation into sexual abuse by Catholic clergy, issuing subpoenas to dioceses across Pennsylvania and bringing a potent set of law-enforcement tools to follow up on a scathing state grand jury report in August.

Seven dioceses, including Pittsburgh and Greensburg, have confirmed receiving subpoenas.

All Roman Catholic dioceses in Pennsylvania have already undergone state- or county-level grand jury investigations, but longtime advocates for victims say they’ve never seen a federal effort on this scale.

“It’s something we always we wished for but thought it would never happen,” said Judy Jones, Midwest leader for the Survivors Network of those Abused by Priests. “Now it’s happening, and it’s all because of the Pennsylvania grand jury. Hopefully this is going to spread and go into other states.”

Advertise with us

She said victims are “very excited about this,” especially after their disappointment Wednesday when a measure they favored, enabling lawsuits over long-ago abuse, died in the Pennsylvania Senate on the final voting day of the legislative session.

The Associated Press, which first reported the subpoenas, said federal authorities sought documents stored in the church’s so-called “secret archives,” and records related to the dioceses’ organizational charts, finances, insurance coverage, clergy assignments, treatment and other documents.

The subpoenas were issued by U.S. Attorney William McSwain of the Eastern District of Pennsylvania Philadelphia, according to the AP, and demanded the bishops turn over any evidence that anyone in their ranks took children across state lines for illicit purposes; sent sexual images or messages via phone or computer; instructed anyone not to contact police; reassigned suspected predators; or used money or other assets as part of the scandal.

A representative for Mr. McSwain declined to comment to the AP, as did a Justice Department spokeswoman.

An Aug. 14 report of a statewide grand jury into six Catholic dioceses reported that more than 300 priests had abused more than 1,000 children across seven decades. Other than priests previously convicted in past years, this grand jury investigation yielded only two new indictments of priests, both of whom have pleaded guilty.

Advertise with us

Because nearly all the allegations happened too long ago to prosecute, the report fueled furious debate over whether to allow a two-year reprieve in the civil statute of limitations so that older victims of child sexual abuse can sue their attackers and the institutions that covered it up.

That proposal was endorsed by state Attorney General Josh Shapiro, the investigative grand jury, the House of Representatives, Senate Democrats as well as victims and their advocates. But Senate Republicans, who control the chamber, until recently opposed any retroactive change in the law.

Late Wednesday, a compromise plan was floated that would have created a state-run compensation fund and opened a window for older victims to sue their attackers, but not the institutions that may have shielded their abusers. But the plan, put forth by Senate President Pro Tempore Joe Scarnati, R-Jefferson, was swiftly denounced as protecting the Catholic Church, and the bill died on the last scheduled voting day of the legislative session.

The federal inquiry could be different from the state investigation. Former federal law-enforcement officials said U.S. law provides an array of tools. If they are targeting cases of coverup by bishops or other church officials, the feds could bring either criminal or civil cases under the Racketeer Influenced and Corrupt Organizations (RICO) Act, originally designed to fight organized-crime syndicates.

Also, federal authorities have jurisdiction over cases involving the Internet or interstate travel — such as cases described by the state grand jury in which Pennsylvania priests brought minors to neighboring states to facilitate acts of sexual abuse.

Advertise with us

Federal investigators also can look into financial transactions, such where money came from or whether settlements with victims were used to silence them and keep abusers in ministry.

“I think this is really good news, and it’s a long time coming,” said David Hickton, former U.S. Attorney for the Western District of Pennsylvania and now a professor of law at the University of Pittsburgh.

In 2005 and 2011, the Archdiocese of Philadelphia underwent investigations by grand juries in that city.

In 2016, a statewide grand jury issued a scathing report on its investigation into the Diocese of Altoona-Johnstown, prompting a successor grand jury that issued the August report into six more dioceses.

After the 2016 Altoona-Johnstown report, then-U.S. Attorney Hickton said publicly his office was looking into whether RICO law could be applied to that diocese.

Advertise with us

That led to a 2017 memorandum of understanding between Mr. Hickton’s successor and Altoona-Johnstown Bishop Mark Bartchak, leading to such changes as a new oversight board and a reconstituted board that reviews allegations of abuse.

“It basically required accountability, it required outside involvement with the review, and it’s the type of thing I think we need, because I believe at this point the Catholic Church has lost credibility to investigate itself,” said Mr. Hickton.

The Western District’s involvement in the Altoona-Johnstown case also stemmed from its prosecution of a priest from that diocese, Joseph Maurizio Jr., involving his sexual abuse of orphans in Honduras. He received a 16½-year sentence in 2016 on charges of engaging in illicit sex in foreign places, possession of child pornography and international money laundering.

Seven of the state’s eight Roman Catholic dioceses on Thursday confirmed receiving subpoenas and pledged cooperation with the federal investigation, including Pittsburgh, Greensburg, Erie, Harrisburg, Philadelphia, Scranton and Allentown. The Altoona-Johnstown diocese did not reply by evening.

The Diocese of Pittsburgh said in a statement it “will cooperate fully with any and all investigations of the sexual abuse of minors by clergy in Pennsylvania.”

Advertise with us

Two Eastern Catholic jurisdictions, the Byzantine Catholic Archeparchy of Pittsburgh and the Ukrainian Catholic Archeparchy of Philadelphia, have acknowledged recently receiving law-enforcement inquiries but have not specified which entity was investigating.

Jerry Zufelt, spokesman for the Diocese of Greensburg, said the “subpoena is no surprise considering the horrific misconduct detailed in the statewide Grand Jury Report. Survivors, parishioners and the public want to see proof that every diocese has taken sweeping, decisive and impactful action to make children safer.”

He added in a statement: “The diocese will fully cooperate with this federal subpoena and will provide all the information requested, including details about the 15,000 people in the last 15 years who the diocese has background checked and trained to recognize the signs of abuse — along with our zero tolerance policy for any violation of the Code of Pastoral Conduct.”

Kenneth Lanning, a retired FBI agent who worked in its behavioral science unit, focusing on the sexual victimization of children, said that under ideal circumstances, state and federal investigators would cooperate and determine which type of charges would be more effective.

One advantage to federal investigations, he said, is that they can uncover types of evidence so that charges can be brought without requiring often-reluctant victims to take the stand.

Advertise with us

The investigation is “groundbreaking if we’re going to see one of the U.S. attorneys pursuing the Catholic cases,” said Marci Hamilton, a University of Pennsylvania professor and chief executive of Child USA, a nonprofit think tank focused on preventing child abuse. “The federal government has so far been utterly silent on the Catholic cases.”

A law professor warned it is premature to assume a Justice Department investigation will necessarily reach higher up the church hierarchy than earlier probes or end with more serious charges.

“Because federal law enforcement is investigating something doesn’t always mean it is more serious or a bigger crime,” said Mary Graw Leary, who teaches at Catholic University’s law school. “Sometimes it just means there’s a federal question.”

Staff writer Liz Navratil, Inquirer reporters Angela Couloumbis and Jeremy Roebuck and The Associated Press contributed to this report.