Separate campaigns seeking union representation for thousands of graduate assistants at Penn State University and the University of Pittsburgh face new potential hurdles, one of them surfacing two weeks before an expected campus election.
The Fairness Center, a legal advocacy group that opposes public employee unions, announced Monday that a Penn State doctoral student has filed a motion to intervene before the Pennsylvania Labor Relations Board. The student, Michael Cronin, seeks to halt a campus election that tentatively is set to take place early next month.
The labor board, turning aside a challenge by Penn State, ruled in February that some 3,800 individuals at University Park and other Penn State locations are workers, and as such, have a legal right to organize. Ballots are tentatively set to be cast as soon as April 10, officials have said.
But Mr. Cronin, a doctoral student and graduate assistant who studies energy and mineral engineering, doesn’t see himself as a public employee. He contends that the duties he performs 20 hours a week in return for a stipend, benefits and tuition waivers are primarily educational, preparing him for a career.
"I accepted my appointment to further my education," he wrote in a affidavit attached to the motion, dated Friday. "Had I merely sought to earn money as an employee during my time as a doctoral student, I could have done something other than being a graduate assistant."
"I do not consent to the Coalition of Graduate Employees representation or to association with the Coalition of Graduate Employees," he wrote.
The coalition, in turn, filed its own brief in response. It called the motion "a meritless attack" and said Mr.Cronin's motion was filed "on behalf of one eligible voter out of 3,799."
"The Fairness Center exists solely to attack unions, to harm and disenfranchise working Pennsylvanians and to ensure that the only Americans with a voice are the wealthy," the coalition asserted in a statement.
The center, with offices in Harrisburg and King of Prussia, provides free legal services and is representing Mr. Cronin in his opposition to the organizing effort, which the Fairness Center said is backed by the Pennsylvania State Education Association.
At Pitt, where some 2,000 graduate assistants could potentially affiliate with the United Steelworkers, campus organizers petitioned the labor board in December seeking an election. A hearing is tentatively set for June 4 through June 8, the union says.
But Pitt, which previously declined to say how it would respond to the petition, signaled this month its intent to oppose it. The school “has formally told the [labor board] that it’s fighting our petition for an election," stated the Pitt Graduate Student Organizing Committee on its Facebook page March 15.
Pitt and its spokesman Kevin Zwick have since confirmed the planned challenge. It appears to involve an argument similar to one used unsuccessfully by Penn State.
“The university believes that graduate students are students — not workers — and we are following the process set by the Pennsylvania Labor Relations Board to establish this case,” Pitt said in a statement.
“The University of Pittsburgh remains committed to the success of all students, and we will continue doing what we do best: partnering with graduate students — individually and collectively — to support their growth and success,’’ it added.
“We are disappointed but probably not surprised, given what happened at Penn State,” said Brad Manzolillo, organizing counsel with the Steelworkers.
Regarding the Penn State case, the Fairness Center says that Mr. Cronin faces the prospect of “losing the ability to determine his own educational future.” If a simple majority of the 3,800 vote for a union, all would become part of the bargaining unit.
“I desire an unmediated relationship with my supervisors and the power to negotiate my own terms and conditions of my appointment as a graduate assistant,” Mr. Cronin wrote. “I should be free to speak for myself.”
Temple University in Philadelphia has had a recognized graduate assistant union since 2001.
The Fairness Center said a 1977 state Supreme Court decision, Philadelphia Association of Interns and Residents v. Albert Einstein Mecial Center, Temple University, established that those paid to work mainly for educational or training cannot be unionized. It said the labor board ignored that case, and it has not been tested legally since.
Those supporting graduate unions say the case does not apply, noting that educational benefits aside, the graduate students are paid to do needed campus work. They have cited issues from pay and transparency in workplace decision-making to harassment concerns as reasons students want representation.
“As graduate student employees, we do a large portion of the teaching and research work at the University,” said the Pitt Graduate Student Organizing Committee. “In fact, the University would cease to function without our labor. We pay taxes and receive a W-2 IRS form from the University.”
Bill Schackner: bschackner@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1977 and on Twitter: @Bschackner.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.