A judge has ordered that four city charter schools be allowed to operate through mid-2021 as a result of a lawsuit they filed against Pittsburgh Public Schools, claiming the school board erred in issuing them a one-year renewal.

Arguing that they would have trouble recruiting students and staff, getting financing and planning long-term, Urban Pathways K-5 College Charter School, Manchester Academic Charter School, Urban Academy of Greater Pittsburgh and Urban Pathways 6-12 Charter School alleged that the school district “misread” a part of state law that allows certain school systems to issue a one-year charter.

At issue was the interpretation of a part of the state school code, which says a “first class” district may renew a charter for one year if members find “insufficient data concerning the charter school’s academic performance to adequately assess the performance.” Philadelphia is the only “first class” district in the state; Pittsburgh Public is a “first class A” district because it serves a city whose population does not exceed 1 million.

The order Friday from Allegheny County Common Pleas Judge Michael F. Marmo granted the four schools a five-year charter effective July 1, 2016.

Advertise with us

Ira Weiss, solicitor for the Pittsburgh Public Schools, said the school board approved the one-year charters in June because the four schools, plus Propel Northside, had submitted incomplete “achievement data” by the time the item came up for a vote. The school system has operated as a first-class district in other ways, he said, including when students can start school and the term for superintendent.

“We don’t agree that we misread it,” he said, noting the order doesn’t address that overall legal issue. “ ... The school district has an obligation to its students that the charter schools are doing what the law requires them to do.”

Mr. Weiss said the Pittsburgh school board has approved the “vast majority” of the charters in the city. He said the district won’t appeal the ruling. Propel Northside did not join the suit, and a representative couldn’t immediately be reached.

The four schools enroll a total of more than 1,100 students, most of whom receive free or reduced lunch, said Kevin M. McKeena, an attorney representing them.

“While the schools believe the district had enough data at the time of renewal, the consent order allows the charter schools and the district to move forward collaboratively,” he said.

Advertise with us

Charter school leaders expressed relief at the decision.

“One year puts everything on a very tilted schedule,” said Gail D. Edwards, CEO of Urban Academy of Greater Pittsburgh Charter School, the oldest of its kind in the city. “It also doesn’t allow parents to feel confident in their decision to choose our school.”

Rachel Amankulor, deputy director of policy at PennCAN — the Pennsylvania Campaign for Achievement Now — which is part of a national network that advocates for high-performing charter and other public schools, called the board’s decision an “irresponsible” one that “resulted in needless litigation and diverted precious time and taxpayer resources away from its core mission of improving the quality of education in Pittsburgh Public Schools.”

“The board’s actions reflect its hostility toward charter schools and its willingness to ignore the law,” she said. “This issue is not about charters versus district, but about good governance versus bad governance.”

Regina Holley, president of the city school board, couldn’t be reached for comment, but Mr. Weiss said, “I don’t think the record supports any effort to get rid of charters.”

Molly Born: mborn@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1944.