Wednesday, May 21, 2025, 12:07PM |  56°
MENU
Advertisement
Anthony Hamlet addresses the media last week at the Pittsburgh Public Schools administration building in Oakland.
2
MORE

Pressure building for renewing superintendent search

Nate Guidry/Post-Gazette

Pressure building for renewing superintendent search

After four civic organizations Tuesday jointly called for the Pittsburgh Public Schools board to start anew in its search for a superintendent, a second school board member said publicly that she couldn’t support Anthony Hamlet.

In interviews, leaders of the Urban League of Greater Pittsburgh, the Hill District Education Council, the Black Political Empowerment Project and A+ Schools agreed that the new schools chief should not, as one of them put it, “begin with a pretty serious cloud over his head.”

“I am not happy that we’re in this situation, but we would be remiss if we did not say honestly what we felt. We thought that our opinions need to be on the record for all to see,” said Tim Stevens, BPEP chairman and CEO.

Advertisement

The Pittsburgh Post-Gazette reported last week that Mr. Hamlet’s “educational philosophy” in his resume included a sentence almost identical to one in a Washington Post editorial from February 2015 — minus one word. He repeated the phrasing, again without attribution, during an introductory news conference last month. That report followed earlier stories that the document included claims about his record that were at odds with data filed by the Palm Beach County school district.

Thomas Sumpter, center, speaks Wednesday with attorney Ira Weiss, right, as Ronald Joseph listens to the agenda at a Pittsburgh school board meeting in Oakland.
Molly Born and Chris Potter
As superintendent debate continues, new board's agenda is stalled

“We just don’t see how further investigation will undo what’s already been done with a search process that was gravely flawed,” said A+ Schools spokesman James Fogarty. “I think it’s time to start over and do it right.”

“I think it is best, in my estimation, for him as well as for Pittsburgh Public Schools, if this is not belabored, if this is not something that is hanging there for people to pick up on every time there’s a question mark,” said Esther L. Bush, president & CEO of the Urban League of Greater Pittsburgh.

She questioned whether Mr. Hamlet would “really be given the benefit of the doubt” in day-to-day operations if he remains with the district.

Advertisement

“There’s too much second-guessing. There’s too much, ‘I wonder if,’” Ms. Bush said.

​Also Tuesday, Terry Kennedy became the second Pittsburgh school board member to say publicly that she can no longer support Mr. Hamlet, 46. District 4 school director Lynda Wrenn took a similar position Thursday.

“I think he’s a good guy,” said Ms. Kennedy, who represents District 5. “While he has a lot of good qualities, my support of him ... was based on the information we had at the time. At this point, it’s been proven to me that my opinion was based on incorrect information, and I can’t support him at this point as our superintendent.”

Other board members declined to comment or couldn’t be reached Tuesday. Mr. Hamlet didn’t return a call. He is being paid this month as a consultant to work with Linda Lane, who is stepping down as superintendent June 30, when her contract expires.

Anthony Hamlet addresses the media about his resume last week during a press conference at the Pittsburgh Public Schools administration building in Oakland.
Molly Born and Adam Smeltz
Former state prosecutor to look into Hamlet's credentials

The school district had no comment beyond a statement reiterating that the personnel committee of the board met with Mr. Hamlet Monday and that the results of an independent inquiry “will guide recommendations related to Dr. Hamlet’s status.” District solicitor Ira Weiss on Monday retained former state prosecutor Laurel Brandstetter to conduct an official review of the resume.

Asked Tuesday about what the district might be obligated to pay Mr. Hamlet if it were to break his contract, Mr. Weiss said such a discussion would be premature. “I don’t want to get beyond our headlights here. We’re in the middle of an inquiry. Those sorts of analyses and discussions will be held, if at all, when appropriate. I think it would be inappropriate for me to get into that right now.”

According to Mr. Hamlet’s contract, if he and the board mutually agreed to part ways, he could receive a year’s compensation. He would not be entitled to pay or benefits if he resigned, however.

Steve Robinson, spokesman for the Pennsylvania School Boards Association, said if the board decides to end its pact with Mr. Hamlet and can’t reach a mutual agreement with him on how to do that, it would be up to Mr. Weiss to advise the board on how to proceed. Costs would “be based on how each side pursues things and reacts to the whole process” and whether the superintendent would “quietly [back] away or [fight] the whole issue.”

For its part, A+ Schools said it had verified inconsistencies in Mr. Hamlet’s resume before the four groups released the statement.

“The board should have vetted this before this was presented to the community,” Mr. Fogarty said. “We feel badly for [Mr. Hamlet], but there are many discrepancies that are here, that we have questions about.”

Beyond the questions over resume claims and possible plagiarism, Sala Udin, co-chair of the Hill District Education Council, aired concerns over what he called the lack of experience of both Mr. Hamlet and Brian K. Perkins, the consultant the board hired to guide the search.

“More important to me is the fact that [Mr. Hamlet] lacks the experience of an urban superintendent. And I think [the school board] ought to build that into the criteria, so that they only search for superintendents who have the requisite experience. ...

“I think although Dr. Perkins has exemplary credentials, he also lacks experience in searching for a school superintendent. So I think that was where the mistake began.”

In the joint statement, the groups called on the board to issue a request for proposals for executive search organizations “with successful track records of placing urban superintendents (including supporting the board in vetting the final candidates)” and “use a community committee to screen applicants and build consensus for selecting the district’s next leader.”

The board meets tonight for a regularly scheduled closed-door personnel meeting before a public agenda review meeting.

Molly Born: mborn@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1944. Adam Smeltz: asmeltz@post-gazette.com or 412-263-2625. Chris Potter contributed.

First Published: June 14, 2016, 3:29 p.m.
Updated: June 14, 2016, 7:13 p.m.

RELATED
Anthony Hamlet and Superintendent Linda Lane exchange contact information on  May 18 when Mr. Hamlet was announced as the next superintendent for Pittsburgh Public Schools.
Lexi Belculfine
Public schools advocacy group issues statement of support for city school board
The Pittsburgh Public Schools board met for three hours Friday to discuss the controversy surrounding Anthony Hamlet, shown May 18 at his introductory news conference, and will meet again Monday.
Molly Born and Chris Potter
Questions raised over Hamlet's hiring process
SHOW COMMENTS (0)  
Join the Conversation
Commenting policy | How to Report Abuse
If you would like your comment to be considered for a published letter to the editor, please send it to letters@post-gazette.com. Letters must be under 250 words and may be edited for length and clarity.
Partners
Advertisement
Mayor Ed Gainey lost his reelection bid Tuesday in the first major defeat for a progressive movement that has reshaped Western Pennsylvania politics.
1
news
Analysis: Pittsburgh Mayor Gainey’s stunning primary defeat highlights era of political upheaval
Corey O’Connor is congratulated as he arrives at his celebration party at Nova Place on the North Side on Tuesday, May 20, 2025.
2
news
Corey O’Connor wins Pittsburgh’s Democratic mayoral primary, unseating incumbent Ed Gainey
View of the Grove Entrance at the Brighton Rehabilitation and Wellness Center on Tuesday, Aug. 9, 2022, in Beaver, Pa. (Ariana Shchuka/Post-Gazette) #buildingmug
3
news
Two Pittsburgh-area nursing homes ordered to pay more than $15 million for health care fraud
Corey O’Connor speaks at his celebration party for Democratic Mayor Candidate at Nova place on North Side on Tuesday, May 20, 2025.
4
news
Corey O’Connor wins Democratic primary for Pittsburgh mayor, unseating Ed Gainey
Pittsburgh Penguins General Manager Kyle Dubas announced during a press conference on Monday, April 28, 2025 at UPMC Lemieux Sports Complex in Cranberry that management and head coach Mike Sullivan have agreed to part ways.
5
sports
Jason Mackey: Why Capitals assistant coach Mitch Love makes a ton of sense for the Penguins
Anthony Hamlet addresses the media last week at the Pittsburgh Public Schools administration building in Oakland.  (Nate Guidry/Post-Gazette)
Anthony Hamlet addresses the media during a recent press conference at the Pittsburgh Public Schools administration building in Oakland.  (Nate Guidry/Post-Gazette)
Nate Guidry/Post-Gazette
Advertisement
LATEST news
Advertisement
TOP
Email a Story