HARRISBURG — Parents and school districts claimed in a lawsuit Monday that Pennsylvania is violating its Constitution by failing to pay for education in such a way that provides all public school students — including those in poor communities — the opportunity for an adequate education.

The suit (explore below), filed in Commonwealth Court, is based in part on a provision of the state Constitution that states the “General Assembly shall provide for the maintenance and support of a thorough and efficient system of public education to serve the needs of the Commonwealth.”

The six school districts, parents of schoolchildren, the Pennsylvania Association of Rural and Small Schools, and the Pennsylvania state conference of the NAACP argue that the state has violated its constitutional obligations by sending too little money to schools, and allowing schools in poor communities to operate with less funding for each student than do schools in wealthy areas.

“It turns the caliber of public education into an accident of geography,” the complaint states. “Children in property- and income-poor districts are denied the opportunity to receive even an adequate education, while their peers in property- and income-rich districts enjoy a high-quality education.”

Advertise with us

The lawsuit names as respondents Republicans Gov. Tom Corbett, Senate President Pro Tem Joe Scarnati, and House Speaker Sam Smith, as well as acting Education Secretary Carolyn Dumaresq.

Tim Eller, a spokesman for the state Department of Education, said that in 1997, when a prior lawsuit from the Pennsylvania Association for Rural and Small Schools was in the courts, total spending in public schools was $13.7 billion. By the 2012-13 fiscal year, that number had grown to $27.6 billion.

“The commonwealth’s authority rests on the amount of state dollars allocated in the annual state budget for support of public schools, and as of 2014-15, Pennsylvania invests a record $10 billion in public schools — the highest level ever,” Mr. Eller said in an email.

Steve Miskin, a spokesman for House Republicans, defended how the state appropriates money for schools.

“We use a fair funding distribution formula, which helps districts with a declining or small tax base as it drives the vast bulk of tax dollars to what are considered the least wealthy districts,” he said. This year, the poorest quarter of Pennsylvania school districts received 46 percent of the main K-12 funding line in the state budget, according to House Republicans.

Advertise with us

In 1999, the state Supreme Court rejected two lawsuits challenging state funding of public schools. The court found the two suits, one from the rural schools association and the other by Philadelphia and its school district, could not be decided by the courts, saying in the Philadelphia case that the judicial branch could not overturn legislative decisions on education.

But attorneys for the new lawsuit say the adoption of state academic standards mean the courts now are able to measure if students are meeting their educational objectives.

Education funding is a major point of contention at the Capitol, where Democrats for years have argued that Mr. Corbett should have replaced the federal stimulus money that had been used for schools; those stimulus funds expired at the beginning of his term. Mr. Corbett lost his bid for re-election last week to Tom Wolf, a Democratic businessman from York County who says he will increase education funding in part by instituting a severance tax on natural gas.

Legislators, too, have acknowledged a need to examine school funding. They charged a state commission of administration officials and legislators with recommending a school funding formula by June.

Michael Churchill, an attorney with the Public Interest Law Center of Philadelphia, said that in only three U.S. states does a smaller percentage of K-12 public school funding come from state sources. (According to U.S. Census data, those three states are Connecticut, Nebraska and South Dakota.)

Advertise with us

Last month, the American Institutes for Research, a non-partisan behavioral and social science research organization, published a study finding Pennsylvania is above average among U.S. states in its average level of funding, but that the money is inequitably distributed. The study was commissioned by the William Penn Foundation of Philadelphia.

The six school districts bringing the suit are the William Penn School District in southeastern Pennsylvania, the School District of Lancaster, Panther Valley School District in Carbon County, Greater Johnstown School District, Shenandoah Valley School District in Schuylkill County and Wilkes-Barre Area School District.

Attorneys from the Public Interest Law Center of Philadelphia and the Education Law Center are representing the petitioners.

At a news conference at the Capitol, Joseph Bruni, superintendent of the William Penn schools, in Delaware County, called the district’s situation “an American tragedy.” Located just a few miles from wealthy communities, his district cannot provide full-time guidance counselors in elementary schools and has had to cut back on Advanced Placement classes, he said.

“We’re struggling to meet a bare minimum of services,” he said.