Candidates offer opinions on reforming Pittsburgh government at mayoral debate
April 4, 2013 10:00 AM
Jack Wagner, left, and Bill Peduto listen as Jake Wheatley answers a question during the Democratic mayoral debate at the University of Pittsburgh's O'Hara student center in Oakland. A.J. Richardson made brief opening statement and left, leaving Wheatley, Wagner and Peduto to answer questions by Pitt students in the 90 minute debate.
By Timothy McNulty Pittsburgh Post-Gazette
With few policy differences emerging yet among the three candidates to be Pittsburgh's next mayor, each is jockeying for position as lead reformer.
The Democratic trio of city Councilman Bill Peduto, former state Auditor General Jack Wagner and state Rep. Jake Wheatley all agreed changes need to be made to the leadership of Pittsburgh government, especially as shown in the way it handled the embattled Pittsburgh Police Bureau.
Mr. Wheatley said the indictment of former Chief Nate Harper on charges he used private police detail money for personal use has "extremely damaged" police morale, especially among fellow black members of the force.
"Officers in that department feel like they're under attack for something that happened with one individual," the Hill District man said.
Mr. Wagner criticized how the police chief currently reports to the city public safety director rather than directly to the mayor.
"We've heard nothing about that in this controversy. That needs to change," he said. "That begins first and foremost with the mayor."
Each also criticized the related issue of a private account -- established by the Murphy administration in 1994 -- that the mayor can use for his expenses.
"Why the mayor has his own set of rules, I have no idea, but it's wrong," said Mr. Peduto, who seemed to have much of the 150 in the crowd at the mayoral debate at the University of Pittsburgh on his side.
On his first day in office, he said "I'll take a pair of scissors and cut that card up."
Mr. Wheatley -- a towering man and former active duty Marine -- joked he wouldn't need a police bodyguard like Mr. Ravenstahl, which Mr. Wagner, another former Marine, seconded.
Getting back to the federal probe of police spending, Mr. Wagner said if he is elected mayor "the police should never be handling that money. That's been going on for years in the city of Pittsburgh. That will change day one."
The three men and Sheraden activist A.J. Richardson are running for the Democratic nomination for mayor in the May 21 primary. Mr. Richardson made a brief apology at the beginning of the debate for an early morning arrest for drunk driving then left the event.
The men had few policy differences, agreeing on providing prevailing wages for workers on city contracts (though Mr. Wheatley stressed the requirement should not overly burden minority or women-owned businesses); that the city should provide benefits to same-sex couples; on providing bike lanes; improving oversight of public transit; and strengthening city building inspection efforts.
While Mr. Peduto and Mr. Wagner said they largely supported the city challenging UPMC's charitable status, Mr. Wheatley was discordant. The Ravenstahl administration should have negotiated with the health provider instead of taking it to court, he said, as "without UPMC and the University of Pittsburgh, we would not have weathered the recession as we have."
The candidates tried to make their reformer messages clear early on.
"The transformation of Pittsburgh has begun. There's one part of it that hasn't caught up: that's city government," Mr. Peduto said.
Mr. Wagner -- as he did early in the day in a court battle over a campaign finance law Mr. Peduto championed -- tacitly painted the councilman as part of the problem.
"Yes, Bill Peduto is right in saying the city of Pittsburgh has problems. ... There are many issues in this city that have not been addressed by city government."
Mr. Wheatley, a 10-year state legislator, pitched himself as the outsider.
"Unlike the other gentlemen on this stage, I'm not a historic and institutional politician," he said.
The debate was hosted by WPTS-FM and the Pitt Political Review.
It was latest in a string of debates among mayoral hopefuls but the first with a field tightened by city Council President Darlene Harris dropping out last week and city Controller Michael Lamb bowing out Monday. The next is scheduled for 8:30 a.m. Saturday at the Pittsburgh Obama school in East Liberty, hosted by the NAACP and other groups.