Home >  Local News >  Neighborhoods

Wednesday, July 02, 2003

By A.J. Caliendo

When a reviewer has seen and reviewed a show multiple times, there is a danger of taking a cynical view toward the overexposed work.

So, before reviewing South Park Theatre's new incarnation of Neil Simon's "The Odd Couple," I read the original 1965 New York review, hoping to gain a fresh perspective.

In South Park's production, which runs through July 13, there are many moments to enjoy, starting with Lynn DeBree's set depicting the living room of prototype slob Oscar Madison. DeBree has added feminine touches to reflect Madison's apathy toward changing the decor after his wife's exodus.

Director Mary Beth Gray knows that timing is essential in any comedy, especially Simon. Gray makes sure her cast does not rush past the double takes and pauses.

The actors prove equal to the task, milking much of that classic comedy for maximum effect. Madison's poker buddies, played by Jake Perry, John Palucka, Matt Weinstock and John W. Ewart, run the gamut from competent to better-than, each at some point taking advantage of a spotlight comic moment or two. Lauren Cooper and Erin McAuley coo along nicely as the none-to-bright Pigeon sisters.

But no "Odd Couple" can work without a funny odd couple, and here, too, this production succeeds.

David W. Dietz III as legendary neat-freak Felix Unger proves that whining, if done properly, can still be funny. Dietz remembers that Felix's peculiarities are supposed to annoy Oscar, not the audience. A special mention must be given to his mastery of Unger's sinus-clearing "moose calls."

As Oscar, Michael Shahen more than holds his own. Shahen, whom Gray has appearing bare-chested often enough to shame those of us who don't work out as seriously as he seems to, rants and raves his way through tirades aimed at his anal-retentive roommate without ever losing track of the underlying affection that prompted him to invite Felix to stay in the first place.

After a bit of an attitude adjustment, South Park's "The Odd Couple" is capable of proving that not only can you teach an old dog new tricks, you can make him enjoy some of the old ones.

"The Odd Couple" at South Park Theatre, Brownsville Road at Corrigan Drive, South Park. Remaining performances are at 8 p.m. July 3, 5, 6, 10, 11, 12 and 13; 4 p.m. July 5 and 12. Ticket prices $8-$9; call 412-831-8552 for reservations and information.

A.J. Caliendo is a freelance writer.