ERIE, Pa. -- Marjorie Diehl Armstrong doesn't have to be the mastermind.

The federal jury doesn't have to believe that she planned the robbery of an Erie PNC Bank branch; that she participated in the construction of a collar bomb; or that she took part in the events Aug. 28, 2003, when the bank was robbed and the bomb detonated, instantly killing a pizza delivery man who was part of the operation.

All the panel of seven men and five women has to believe is that Ms. Armstrong assisted the other members of the conspiracy in any fashion, said Assistant U.S. Attorney Marshall J. Piccinini, and that's enough to convict her.

But throughout his opening statement, the prosecutor made it clear he planned to prove all those things.

Advertise with us

They were a group of "twisted, intellectually bright, dysfunctional individuals, [who] outsmarted themselves," Mr. Piccinini said. "Their plan failed miserably."

Even so, it took until 2007 when a federal grand jury returned an indictment, charging Ms. Armstrong and another man, Kenneth Barnes, with criminal conspiracy, bank robbery and using a firearm in relation to a violent crime. Another man, William Rothstein was also named in the conspiracy, though he died of cancer before charges were filed.

Mr. Barnes pleaded guilty in December 2008 and was sentenced to 45 years in prison. He is expected to testify next week against Ms. Armstrong.

According to investigators, on Aug. 28, 2003, Brian Wells, a pizza delivery man who had been in on the planning of the robbery, entered the Summit Towne Center branch of PNC Bank about 2:30 p.m. He presented a teller with a four-page demand note, lifted his oversized white T-shirt, revealing a bomb strapped around his neck and chest.

Carrying a one-shot shotgun that was disguised as a walking cane, Mr. Wells demanded $250,000. The teller, Barbara Eisert, told the man she couldn't get him that much money. Instead, she collected $8,702 from three different teller drawers and placed it in a canvas bag.

Advertise with us

Mr. Wells walked calmly out of the bank, sucking on a lollipop. He left in his green Geo Metro, but a customer followed him. A state trooper was on-scene almost immediately and stopped Mr. Wells' vehicle.

He was handcuffed and placed on the ground in front of the trooper's police car. Mr. Wells said he had been attacked by a man with a gun who strapped the bomb on him.

Less than 30 minutes later, while officers awaited the Erie City bomb squad, the bomb around Mr. Wells' neck exploded. Camera crews from local television stations recorded Mr. Wells pleading for help just before the bomb detonated.

Even though it took more than four years before charges were filed in the case, Mr. Piccinini told the jury that investigators started putting the pieces together almost immediately.

"These people went into panic mode," he said. "It started from the moment Brian Wells exploded."

Advertise with us

After Mr. Wells was stopped by police, the prosecutor said, Mr. Barnes and Ms. Armstrong, who had been watching from a nearby Eat 'n Park fled. Mr. Piccinini said they went to try to recover a number of notes that had been hidden like a scavenger hunt providing instructions to Mr. Wells on how to get the bomb removed.

But by Sept. 21, 2003, Mr. Rothstein, who police believe constructed the collar bomb, called state police and told them about another, unknown part of the case.

Inside a freezer in his home, he told investigators, was the body of James Roden -- Ms. Armstrong's former boyfriend. He had been shot twice in the chest.

Ms. Armstrong pleaded guilty but mentally ill to the slaying in 2005. Police believe she killed Mr. Roden in August 2003 to prevent him from revealing information about the planned bank robbery. Afterward the shooting, Ms. Armstrong called Mr. Rothstein to help her get rid of the body.

Throughout the prosecution's opening statement, Ms. Armstrong whispered to defense attorney Douglas Sughrue her disagreement with allegations by the prosectuor in his opening statement.

Advertise with us

Repeatedly, when Mr. Piccinini referred to the shooting death of Mr. Roden, Ms. Armstrong got louder and louder.

At one point when he referred to the allegation that Ms. Armstrong wanted the bank to be robbed to get money to pay to have her father killed, she said loud enough for the gallery to hear: "That's a lie. That's a damn lie."

During the planning of the bank robbery, the group had agreed the device Mr. Wells would wear would look like a destructive device, but it wouldn't be activated.

But that eventually changed, Mr. Piccinini said. Instead, what was placed around Mr. Wells was two 6-inch pipe bombs, loaded with powder from shotgun shells. It had two Sunbeam egg timers inside and was constructed out of hunter green angle iron.

"It never could have been disarmed by anyone but its creator," he said. "It had trip wires and fake trip wires."

Advertise with us

Before the device was affixed to Mr. Wells that day, Mr. Piccinini continued, Mr. Wells had second thoughts.

"Something about the device caused him to back off," he said.

Mr. Piccinini said that Mr. Barnes will testify that after Mr. Wells grew wary of the plan, Ms. Armstrong and Mr. Rothstein forced Mr. Wells to wear the bomb around his neck. The prosecutor said the pair fired a gunshot as a warning to Mr. Wells during that confrontation.

For his part, Mr. Sughrue focused much of his opening statement urging the jury not to jump to conclusions and he reminded jurors that Ms. Armstrong is presumed to be innocent.

After his client was convicted in the Roden homicide, Ms. Armstrong met with investigators on multiple occasions to discuss the collar bomb case. Though she provided some information, at one point she said she wouldn't say more without immunity.

Advertise with us

Mr. Sughrue admitted his client didn't talk to investigators for the good of society.

"She was around this cast of characters," Mr. Sughrue said. "She wanted to help the FBI for her own good. She wanted to be [moved to a prison] closer to Erie."

The prosecution called four witnesses late Friday afternoon, including the teller who was robbed, as well as two state troopers who responded to the bank robbery.

The trial, before U.S. District Judge Sean J. McLaughlin, is expected to last at least two weeks.