Pittsburgh officials are taking another crack at an anti-gang violence strategy that failed when the city first tried it — but they say this time the effort is boosted by police cooperation and federal support.

National criminologist David Kennedy pioneered the approach, which aims to reduce gang-related gun violence by levying heavy enforcement against the most violent gang members while offering help to people who agree to put down their guns.

It’s the same philosophy that was behind the Pittsburgh Initiative to Reduce Crime, or PIRC, which was launched by then-Mayor Luke Ravenstahl in 2008 but didn’t get underway until 2010.

The program sputtered out by 2014, and Mr. Kennedy put the blame squarely on the Bureau of Police, calling it “the most condescending and aggressively uncooperative agency” he had ever encountered.

Advertise with us

But things have changed, he said.

“This really feels to me like a different police bureau than I experienced the last time,” Mr. Kennedy said Thursday. “Given what I saw the last time, I would not have predicted the level of openness and energy that we’re seeing now.”

The bureau has created an 11-person Group Violence Intervention unit that will be the heart of the effort, designed to involve the entire bureau as well as a cadre of outside partners, including probation and parole officers, community organizations and federal prosecutors.

Investigators are tracking 39 groups in the city, said Sgt. Jim Glick, who heads GVI. Police prefer the term “group” because they feel it better reflects the loose organization and shifting allegiances they see here than the word “gang.”

“What is a group today may not be tomorrow,” said violent crimes Cmdr. Victor Joseph. “Group names and associations change. Things are different than they were 15 or 20 years ago when things were neighborhood-based. These days it is very fluid. Guys from two different neighborhoods that historically would never be associated are associated now.”

Advertise with us

Of the 39 groups in the city, police have determined which members are the most violent through intelligence, informants and old-fashioned police work, Cmdr. Joseph said.

Working under the premise that a small group of people causes a disproportionate amount of the violence in the city, GVI specifically targets the individuals whom police determine to be the most violent.

Officers give those particular people a message: If they don’t stop shooting, police will crack down not only on them, but on their entire group, Sgt. Glick said.

“The approach is to punish the group for the actions of one,” he said.

When a group member commits a violent act, he said, police will use every possible avenue to disrupt the entire group — through arrests when possible but also through less traditional avenues like calling in building inspectors to condemn an unsafe structure that has been at the center of violence. The targeted response is called a Violent Crime Response Team.

Advertise with us

Sgt. Glick has been been a part of four such efforts since August 2016.

“Every lever that we can pull on a VCRT we do,” he said. “But a VCRT is only initiated for group violence. We’re not going to do it because someone is selling drugs on the corner.”

Police let the targets know what’s coming, he said, adding, “We tell them, ‘If you weren’t shooting each other, we wouldn’t be here.’”

Police aren’t focused on a neighborhood or geographic area as whole, Cmdr. Joseph said, just on the group members themselves.

“The whole neighborhood will not feel negative repercussions, and in fact if done correctly there will be positive repercussions for the neighborhood because we will remove those violent members from the community that the community does not want there any more than we do,” he said.

Advertise with us

On the flip side of the Violent Crime Response Team are outreach and social services. If group members agree to stop shooting and want to get away from their violent lifestyles, police connect them to social services, job training and other resources like tattoo removal.

In April, the police bureau used $120,000 in grant money from the U.S. Department of Justice to hire Cornell Jones, a minister who previously worked at State Correctional Institution Pittsburgh, to coordinate the outreach side of Group Violence Intervention for two years.

Mr. Jones works with five people from the nonprofit Family Life Empowerment, which is nearing the end of a one-year, $150,000 contract with the city to provide GVI services. The bureau plans to ask Pittsburgh City Council to renew that contract when it expires in November, public safety spokeswoman Sonya Toler said.

Both Mr. Jones and his team help group members who are ready to get out and try to smother simmering disputes before they explode into violence.

“If we know someone might be the next shooter, we go and do a ‘custom notification’ and let them know ‘we want to help you, we want you to stay alive and stay out of prison,’” he said. “They tell me people they’re worried about who might get shot in the future. My goal is to take that and find every resource and connection to find anything we can do to help that person stay alive.”

Advertise with us

The “custom notifications” are also attended by police, who warn group members about enforcement, and are one of two main ways police plan to get the message of GVI to the city’s most violent people.

The other way is through a “call-in,” a formal meeting attended by 20 to 40 of the city’s most influential group members in which authorities lay out the philosophy of GVI. The hope is that the attendees take the message back to their groups.

The city first held a “call-in” in 2010 when PIRC began. Now, as the police bureau turns back to that strategy, officials are planning to hold a call-in before the end of the year, Cmdr. Joseph said.

Both Sgt. Glick and Cmdr. Joseph declined to discuss the bureau’s past history with PIRC — “That’s ancient history,” Cmdr. Joseph said — but Mr. Kennedy acknowledged that some people may have reservations about returning to a strategy that flopped on its first attempt.

“It’s understandable and also heartbreaking,” Mr. Kennedy, the criminologist, said. “Because it was infuriating that all of the energy that the city and some really, really committed community partners put into this the last time was just blocked by other opposition.”

Advertise with us

The strategy never had a chance to work the first time, he said. The approach has been used in cities across the country with varying degrees of success — some places saw significant decreases in homicides.

“You had to be pretty close to what happened to know, but PIRC didn’t exist,” Mr. Kennedy said. “It was supposed to happen, but PIRC never happened. So it could not have worked because it wasn’t done.”

This time, he said, Group Violence Intervention is just one part of what his organization, the National Network of Safe Communities, is doing in Pittsburgh. His organization is also here because Pittsburgh was selected by the U.S. Justice Department as one of six pilot cities to participate in the National Initiative for Building Community Trust and Justice.

The federal initiative aims to improve relationships between police departments and communities by focusing on racial reconciliation, procedural justice and implicit bias.

“As far as we’re concerned, the violence prevention work is not separate from the other work we’re doing with the city, which is doing a better job of keeping communities safe and doing it in ways that do not cause unintended harm in the community by using enforcement powers unnecessarily,” Mr. Kennedy said.

Advertise with us

Ms. Toler said GVI is part of a bureau-wide shift toward holistic policing, and that the federal support provided by the national initiative has made a significant impact.

The reconstitution and redevelopment of GVI has been underway for several months, said Kevin Acklin, Mayor Bill Peduto’s chief of staff. And while the Gang Violence Intervention unit has existed since mid-2015, it’s only now beginning to fulfill all the aspects of Mr. Kennedy’s strategy, Sgt. Glick said.

Mr. Acklin said Mr. Peduto hopes to attend the upcoming call-in and is “very supportive” of the current effort.

“When you’re brought up and crime is the best way to make ends meet and pay the bills, you’re provided with very few options and alternatives,” Mr. Acklin said. “[GVI] is a continuation of the underlying policy that the mayor ran on — which is to have a police force more embedded in and connected to the community it serves."

Some city council members and community leaders are prepared to give the Group Violence Intervention strategy another shot.

Advertise with us

Councilwoman Natalia Rudiak said Thursday she pushed for officials to provide quarterly reports about PIRC when it began and would like to see such evidence this time as well.

“We can’t just throw money at a problem. We need to show reductions in violence,” she said. “If the data shows it’s not working, we need to try a different approach, because lives are at stake.”

Police recorded 78 shootings during the first six months of 2015, compared with 98 during the first half of 2016 and 86 through the end of June this year.

Tim Stevens, chairman and CEO of the Black Political Empowerment Project, said he is cautiously optimistic about the strategy’s return and wants to give city officials plenty of time to work out the details before he criticizes or analyzes their efforts.

“This is an opportunity to solve a huge piece of the puzzle, and that is dealing with those who are primarily most at fault with causing the actual violence, shootings and murders,” he said. “We need to give those who are putting this renewed program in place — which has some tests across the country — we need to give them a chance to succeed.”

Shelly Bradbury: 412-263-1999, sbradbury@post-gazette.com or follow @ShellyBradbury on Twitter. Reporter Adam Smeltz contributed.