She was once a beauty, the grand dame of Downtown department stores. But the grandeur of the former Macy’s/Kaufmann’s building has given way to grime. Few probably want to meet under its famous clock these days.

The exterior of the historic old store at Fifth Avenue and Smithfield Street has fallen into neglect. Large plate glass windows that once heralded the latest fashions are still filled with leftover Christmas displays.

Christmas bulbs, bags and boxes are scattered about some windows. Clumps of soot-covered fake snow sit piled in one, while exposed wires or lights dangle from others. Sheets of weathered plywood cover part of the spaces once used to attract the eye of shoppers.

Debris clutters the floor and steps just inside an entrance on Fifth. Private property and no trespassing signs are posted on the main entrances on Smithfield. Stains mar the concrete.

Advertise with us

People are starting to notice the sorry state of the Downtown landmark, two years after Philadelphia-based Core Realty purchased the 13-story building with big plans to redevelop it. Macy’s closed in September 2015.

“It looks like a dump,” said Trevor Miller of Evans City as he walked by the building the other day.

After the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette made inquiries about the former store’s condition, the city is pressing Core Realty to clean up, and the owner is vowing to do so.

“They can clearly do a better job,” said Kevin Acklin, chief of staff to Mayor Bill Peduto. “They acknowledged that. In terms of the management in Philadelphia, they expressed a commitment to act immediately to make sure the site is cleaned up.”

The city, Mr. Acklin said, has received complaints about the state of the structure’s exterior. There also have been reports of homeless people sleeping in the nooks around the revolving doors.

Advertise with us

“We intend to hold them accountable, not only to the schedule for development, but for the condition of the building,” he said.

For more than a century, the store, opened in 1877, was one of the city’s top shopping destinations, expanding over the years to meet its growing customer base. During the holidays, crowds gathered outside to drink in the enchanting window displays. And the big ornate clock at Fifth and Smithfield became a favorite meeting spot.

After buying the iconic property for $15 million in July 2015, Core talked of devoting the first two floors to retail, restaurants and entertainment, supplemented by 312 luxury apartments, a 160-room Even Hotel and 600 parking spaces.

Core originally planned to keep the Macy’s department store on floors 1-4, but that changed dramatically when the chain decided to close the store altogether.

Some two years later, Core has yet to announce any deals with retailers or restaurants, and there’s little tangible evidence of progress, at least from the outside.

Advertise with us

Michael Samschick, Core’s CEO, said that is misleading. The firm has been hard at work on the inside, he stressed, creating atriums and skylights as part of the building plans.

Core, he explained, typically works from the inside out, which is why it has not devoted much attention to the building’s exterior.

That, he said, will be changing “because we love Pittsburgh and want to do the right thing.”

The big ornate clock outside the former Macy's/Kaufmann's building at Fifth Avenue and Smithfield Street Downtown was a popular meeting spot. (Bob Donaldson / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

The developer plans to put “some lipstick” on the old dame, covering the windows with renderings of what the former department store will look like when the redevelopment is done, as well as with ads relating to the project. It also is open to showing the work of local artists in the windows, he said.

“One thing we don’t want to be is an eyesore. It’s important to us to give respect to the city and the streetscape,” he said.

Advertise with us

Inside, Core has been working at “a pace we are comfortable with.” Mr. Samschick acknowledged that an electrical vault fire in the building last July “was way more impactful than people realized.”

As a result of the blaze, which also created havoc for the adjoining Allegheny Building, Core has had to replace transformers, switch gear and various systems. While that has slowed progress, it will benefit the redevelopment in the long run, he said.

“There’s nothing that will be in that building that won’t be brand new, from top to bottom,” he said.

Eager to show off that it has not been loafing, Core will give Mr. Acklin a tour of the building Thursday.

Kaufmann's Department store downtown Pittsburgh corner of Smithfield and Diamond Street Circa: April 9, 1912 (HANDOUT/PG ARCHIVE)

Kaufmann's Department store, Downtown, at the corner of Smithfield and Diamond Streets circa April 1912. (Post-Gazette archives)

Advertise with us

As for retail, Core has “players lined up,” although it does not appear that any deals have been finalized. At one time, it was considering fashion retailers, restaurants and entertainment, including a movie theater and a bowling alley.

Recently, the focus has been more on restaurants than dry goods, though Mr. Samschick said there will be a “nice blend.”

“It’s a wonderful merchandising mix. At the end of the day, it will blend well with the hotel, the amenity packages, the apartments,” he said.

Work on the Even Hotel, meanwhile, is expected to start within days after the developer, Reception Hotels and Resorts, closed on construction financing, said Matthew Shollar, a Reception representative.

The hotel, scheduled to be completed in March 2018, will occupy the building’s fifth and sixth floors. It has taken awhile to get work started because of the complicated nature of the mixed-use project and the historic tax credit process, Mr. Shollar said. A lot of the prep work has been done by Core, he added.

Advertise with us

For some passersby who walked by the once bustling Downtown destination the other day, progress, in any form, is long overdue.

“Something needs to happen. Hopefully, something will happen sooner rather than later,” architect Jeff Davis said. “It would be nice to see more activity soon.”

Mark Belko: mbelko@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1262.