Hours after a woman arrested at PrideFest pleaded guilty to reduced charges, the Allegheny County district attorney criticized the way the June event was planned and staffed.

Ariel Lawther, 19, of Harmony pleaded guilty Wednesday morning to two summary counts of harassment. She was arrested June 15 and charged with aggravated assault, simple assault and other crimes after Pittsburgh police said she hit a protester and then struck an officer who tried to intervene in the chest and groin.

Video of the arrest — in which Officer Souroth Chatterji pushed and struck Ms. Lawther — circulated on the Internet and angered some.

Ms. Lawther spent 16 hours in jail before she was released, her defense attorney, Komron Maknoon, said in court Wednesday.

Advertise with us

Allegheny County District Attorney Stephen A. Zappala Jr. said in a statement that he agreed to reduce the charges because, “This was an appropriate resolution in light of the evidence, and all parties involved were in agreement.”

Mr. Zappala also said he thought that Officer Chatterji “acted reasonably and within his duties as a police officer in taking action to defuse a confrontation, especially given the inadequate number of police officers assigned to the event and the apparent failure to plan for the physical separation of the festival attendees from the protesters.”

PrideFest was organized by the Delta Foundation. President Gary Van Horn told the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette this summer that, for the first time in the gay pride event’s history, it was short of the number of officers needed to work nine shifts, in part because fewer officers volunteered than were needed.

Mr. Van Horn said Wednesday that he thinks part of that shortage occurred because of new bureau regulations that made it harder to schedule the same officers, some of whom had worked it every previous year.

He said he has met with local and federal officials since PrideFest and hopes that scheduling will run more smoothly next year and also that officers will have more First Amendment training.

Advertise with us

Pittsburgh public safety spokeswoman Sonya Toler said acting police Chief Cameron McLay plans to review all bureau policies, including those for scheduling officers to work large-scale events such as PrideFest.

Ms. Lawther’s jail time counted as her sentence for one of her counts of harassment. District Judge Anthony Ceoffe gave her the opportunity to perform 40 hours of community service in Pittsburgh on the second count or to pay $440 in court fees and fines.

She opted to pay the fines, noting that she does not live in the city.

Mr. Maknoon said he was pleased by the “significant reduction” in the charges against Ms. Lawther.

Officer Chatterji was cleared of excessive-force allegations by the city’s Office of Municipal Investigations last month.

Ms. Lawther’s civil attorney, Steve Barth, said he is still trying to obtain video that he thinks was used in that review. “There's something there to investigate,” he said.