Don Lindich’s Sound Advice: To amplify, or not to amplify?

Share with others:


Print Email Read Later

Question: A year or so ago you rec­om­mended Polk LSi25 speak­ers as a great value on close­out for $1,299 a pair. I man­aged to find a like-new set on eBay for $750 and they were lo­cal, so I picked them up.

I think I need a new re­ceiver to power them. I have a vin­tage Pioneer SX-828 that drove my vin­tage EPI HE21’s beau­ti­fully. When I hooked up the Polks, they sound fine up to about ¼ vol­ume. Higher than that, the amp clips on and off. I am think­ing this is not good for my re­ceiver. I be­lieve the EPI’s are 8 ohm and the LSi25’s are 4 ohms. Should I get a new re­ceiver or am­pli­fier for my new speak­ers?

TOM K.,

Fremont, Calif.

Answer: What­ever you do, don't use the SX-828 with your Polk LSi25 speak­ers any­more! It is true that driv­ing the re­ceiver un­til it clips and shuts off is not good for the re­ceiver, but it is even worse for those beau­ti­ful new speak­ers. Clip­ping cre­ates dis­tor­tion that dam­ages speak­ers, es­pe­cially tweet­ers. The Vifa Ring Radi­a­tor tweet­ers used in your Polk LSi speak­ers are pretty spe­cial, and you want to keep them per­form­ing their best.

In the past I would have rec­om­mended the Har­man/​Kar­don HK3490 re­ceiver. Selling for un­der $400, it had tons of clean power and could drive your 4-ohm speak­ers ef­fort­lessly. Sadly, it has been dis­con­tin­ued and re­placed with a much in­fe­rior model.

Your best bet is to get an in­te­grated am­pli­fier, or a sep­a­rate am­pli­fier and pre­am­pli­fier. Here are three op­tions to con­sider.

The first is the Emo­tiva mini-X A100. It pro­vides 80 watts per chan­nel into 4-ohms and sells for 219 at www.emo­tiva.com.

A mid­priced op­tion is the NAD C 326 BEE for $549. See it at www.nade­lec­tron­ics.com.

The third choice is a bit off the beaten path. The Neu­haus Lab­o­ra­to­ries T-2 in­te­grated am­pli­fier uses vac­uum tubes, and though it is only 20 watts per chan­nel, it will drive your LSi25 speak­ers very well. In fact, I used the T-2 to drive the Polk LSi9 speak­ers and they worked won­der­fully to­gether. The T-2 has three ste­reo con­nec­tions. a dig­i­tal op­ti­cal con­nec­tion and a USB con­nec­tion. It is per­fect for use play­ing back dig­i­tal files and makes them sound nice and warm. I highly rec­om­mend it — www.neu­haus­labs.com.

Home TV re­cord­ing

After my re­cent col­umn about home tele­vi­sion re­cord­ing and the Chan­n­el­mas­ter DVR+, I re­ceived quite a few emails from read­ers with sug­ges­tions for al­ter­na­tives. One of them, the Me­dia­s­onic HW-150, looks to be a stand­out value and does most of what the DVR+ does, but for $35 in­stead of $249. It only has one tuner and lacks the fancy pro­gram guide, but given the price of $35 vs. $249, I doubt peo­ple will com­plain too much.

Need­less to say I am ex­cited about this pros­pect and or­dered one from Am­a­zon im­me­di­ately. It re­cently ar­rived, and I have com­menced test­ing. I will have more about it next week, so if you are in­ter­ested in home re­cord­ing, stay tuned … and don’t buy any­thing un­til you see next week’s col­umn!


Read prod­uct re­views by Don Lindich at soundad­vice­blog.com.

Join the conversation:

Commenting policy | How to report abuse
To report inappropriate comments, abuse and/or repeat offenders, please send an email to socialmedia@post-gazette.com and include a link to the article and a copy of the comment. Your report will be reviewed in a timely manner. Thank you.
Commenting policy | How to report abuse

Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement

You have 2 remaining free articles this month

Try unlimited digital access

If you are an existing subscriber,
link your account for free access. Start here

You’ve reached the limit of free articles this month.

To continue unlimited reading

If you are an existing subscriber,
link your account for free access. Start here