The digital clocks struck 2:18 p.m. and a mini symphony of loud whines began to erupt from their cell phones.
At Commonplace Coffee in the Mexican War Streets, a handful of people both inside and outside the tiny shop — baristas included — looked down at their phones.
On Wednesday afternoon, the Federal Emergency Management Agency sent millions of text messages to cell phones in the U.S. as part of the first nationwide test of its Wireless Emergency Alert system.
The message read: “THIS IS A TEST of the National Wireless Emergency Alert System. No action is needed,” beneath a header that said, “Presidential Alert.”
These types of texts are already used to warn the public about dangerous weather through tornado or flash flood warnings, and in cases of missing children when Amber Alert messages are sent. So the tone of the warning sound may be familiar.
Designed as the highest level of warning transmission, the presidential alert — which is not really President Donald Trump sending a giant group text to the whole country — is reserved for the most dire national emergencies.
Read More
To date, this class of alert has not yet been used, according to FEMA.
The presidential alert system will not replace existing radio and broadcast alerts, explained Gregory Touhill, an adjunct faculty member at Carnegie Mellon University’s Heinz College of Information Systems and Public Policy. It will augment them.
“A lot of folks don’t watch TV anymore. They’re doing Netflix and they’re on their cell phone,” said Mr. Touhill, who served as deputy assistant secretary of cybersecurity and communications at the Department of Homeland Security when the presidential alert system was first being coordinated.
“We thought, we have to have the ability to reach folks and what do they have? They have wireless phones.”
As her iPhone went off in the coffee shop, 35-year-old Lindsey Moore took out her earbuds and peered around the room with a blank face.
“I was dreading [the test] happening since it was first announced,” said Ms. Moore, a personal stylist who lives in the Mexican War Streets. “I know there are parameters around it, which is good, but I feel like [President Trump] could still abuse it,” she said.
Rahul Telang, a professor of information systems at CMU’s Heinz College, said most privacy and security concerns are internalized by the individual.
“I think a lot of people might feel psychologically bad. They might question and think about all of these possibilities. Did somebody share their number?” he said. “I wouldn’t be shocked if people contacted their wireless providers to ask about it.”
Per FEMA, users cannot opt out of the presidential alert (unlike weather or Amber alerts), which will be sent to all handheld devices that are connected by a wireless service provider that’s opted in.
Most customers of 100 participating companies — including all of the big providers like Verizon and Sprint and most small ones — should have received the alert. FEMA estimated that 75 percent of the population with a smartphone would get the text alert.
Part of the reason for the test was to see if most people did get the text and to determine if the infrastructure for sending the alerts requires improvement.
Prior to Wednesday, a nationwide test has never been conducted, although the Wireless Emergency Alert system has been around since 2012.
The system traces its orgins to the Warning, Alert and Response Network Act of 2006, wherein the George W. Bush administration pushed for a new emergency alert system. That came after steep criticism of the way the government handled emergency response during Hurricane Katrina in 2005.
The testing itself should prevent false warnings from being sent out in the future — something that’s already happened.
In January, a false alarm in Hawaii sent residents a text about a ballistic missile threat but there was no missile inbound to the island.
Communicating that the presidential alert was just a test well in advance of the actual message was “a good lesson” from the Hawaii mix-up, Mr. Touhill said.
“That helps dampen down the folks with the ‘War of the Worlds’ syndrome,” he said, referring to the 1930s radio broadcast of H.G. Wells’ science fiction story. “What would happen today if something like that occurred on social media?”
He said to expect more tests like this in the future — so don’t fret if you did not receive the message. FEMA is required to test the alert at least once every three years.
Hi there, there are a number of reasons why you may not have received the alert. We test so when the system is needed things will go smoothly. We’ll be working with mobile providers and @FCC to determine what improvements need to be made.
— FEMA (@fema) October 3, 2018
“After each test, an after-action report and improvement plan is created and incorporated into future testing to ensure continual advancement of alert and warning capabilities,” reads a FEMA description of the alert.
On Wednesday, the agency replied to tweets from people who did not receive the message.
“We’ll be working with mobile providers and [the] FCC to determine what improvements need to be made.”
A tragedy like the missile threat, if it had actually happened, is the kind of event that Charlotta Dragenflo, 34, said would be appropriate for a presidential alert.
“There’s not much that impacts the whole country at once,” said the development officer from Brighton Heights. “If it’s used for propaganda and you can’t turn it off, you can’t do that. It’s gotta be a safety thing.”
She and her friend, Emma Kieran, 40, agreed that unless it was a national crisis — like a terrorist threat or all airports being shut down at once — there’s no need for a presidential alert.
“My thought is mostly confusion,” said Ms. Kieran, a nonprofit consultant from the Mexican War Streets, “because I want to know what it’s actually going to be used for.”
Both of the friends shared a concern that although the president, himself, is not sending the text messages, he may be able to influence how frequently they’re sent and the contents.
Mr. Touhill said drills like the presidential alert are executed at a level below that of the president.
“This is not a political issue,” he said. “This is a public safety issue.”
Courtney Linder: clinder@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1707. Twitter: @LinderPG.
Updated Oct. 3, 2018 at 5:30 p.m.
Join the Tech.pgh Community!




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.