What do horse racing, venture capitalists and Overstock.com have in common? They all involve placing bets that could return exactly $0.
Putting crisp dollar bills down on the horse expected to win the Kentucky Derby is one thing, but familiar online retailer Overstock.com has upped the ante — accepting bitcoin as a legitimate form of payment for that discounted kettle or kitchen set of your dreams.
On Dec. 17 last year, bitcoin — a digital currency that exists outside of the traditional banking system — topped out at a value of $19,783.06 per coin. For context, the first bitcoin transaction in 2010 required 10,000 coins to order two pizzas.
Now everyone wants in on what seems like free money.
Therein lies the danger. If something seems too good to be true, it probably is. Or, as University of Pittsburgh mathematics professor Gunduz Caginalp puts it, “It looks like we’re in a later phase of bubble.”
Bubbling over
Read More
In February, Mr. Caginalp published a research paper, “Validation, Liquidity Price, and Stability of Cryptocurrencies,” with his son Carey Caginalp, a former Carnegie Mellon University instructor and visiting scholar at Pitt.
The younger Mr. Caginalp had been following bitcoin for some time, and the two began thinking about bitcoin as an asset, or rather the lack thereof. Their research indicates that cryptocurrency prices will likely never stabilize.
On Tuesday, for example, a single bitcoin traded for less than $11,000, a significant drop from last December’s high.
While bitcoin is speculative, with a winner-takes-all ethos, the currency has no real intrinsic value, explained Mr. Caginalp.
In other investments, terms like equity at least imply partial ownership of a company, voting rights and perhaps a dividend. Bonds accumulate interest and are repaid upon maturity.
“I think for the average person, by the time that you hear about [bitcoin], it seems like it’s going to go up forever and it’s often actually the peak,” Mr. Caginalp said. “Any type of speculative asset becomes somewhat dangerous to buy, especially with relatively little knowledge.”
Bitcoin prices are solely based on how many people want to buy and sell the cryptocurrency at a given time, he said. It’s difficult to know at what price bitcoin should be trading at on a given day.
Even art dealers have carved out a more exact science to valuation.
“Artwork goes for high prices, but there’s an established history of people determining how much a painting is worth and what it can do for a gallery or a museum,” Mr. Caginalp said.
‘Dangerous investment’
Daniel Robison, co-founder and lead organizer of the Pittsburgh Bitcoin Users Meetup group, agrees that the price of bitcoin will likely never stabilize. His events typically draw 30 to 60 enthusiasts each month, though the online community has grown to nearly 800.
He doesn’t find issue with bitcoin’s irregular prices, which shake up irregularly as if placed on the San Andreas fault line. “While bitcoin isn’t a security, much of its speculative value parallels the shares of a startup technology company,” said Mr. Robison, 35, of Highland Park.
To him, any stake is risky — whether it’s buying bitcoin, shares of a company on the public market or throwing venture capital at a new startup.
Using venture capital firms as an example, Mr. Robison said they stand to make huge gains by taking calculated risks on a young company. That also means room for substantial losses.
“It’s basically a difference of approach,” he said, “which is why for every institutional investor and investment manager in New York you hear decry bitcoin as a dangerous investment, you’ll have another VC in Silicon Valley extolling the coming age of cryptocurrencies.”
Some investors value bitcoin not as a currency but as a technology.
Hundreds of millions of dollars have been invested in hardware and software securing the technology underpinning bitcoin, called blockchain. At its core, blockchain is a continuously growing list of records, fully encrypted by central computers. It’s what makes it so difficult to steal another person’s bitcoin.
That technology could be a “platform for any application we can dream of,” said Mr. Robison.
Luxury auto brand Porsche, for example, announced that it was experimenting with blockchain technology to potentially lock and unlock vehicles through a secure app.
“To think that bitcoin is a static thing and that its utility today determines its utility tomorrow is to underestimate things pretty extremely,” Mr. Robison said, noting he’s cautiously optimistic. “Bitcoin is a software technology, and like any software it can be changed.”
Buyer beware
There is a basic assumption in finance that people know what the value of something is and they buy with that knowledge. Mr. Caginalp advises not to invest in crypto without fully understanding the price at which you’re buying.
Two different multimillionaires, for example, might be willing to purchase a luxury car at two different prices, he said. They could be relatively modest price points, but the manufacturer can take advantage of those who are instead willing to pay a premium.
“Their opinion doesn’t really count because if there’s a small supply, [the manufacturer] can sell cars for 1 million each because there are enough people at the fringe who will pay that much for the car.”
It’s the fringe that sometimes dictates the price, Mr. Caginalp said.
In the case of bitcoin, if someone is willing to buy at $20,000, then someone is willing to sell at that price even if the majority value bitcoin at, say, $10,000. You don’t want to be the one that buys in at that high price.
And as for businesses like Overstock.com and Expedia that accept bitcoin as a payment, Mr. Caginalp finds it risky and plain unnecessary.
“I would be worried if I’m buying in bitcoin,” he said. “If I’m buying it in dollars, I have a good idea what I paid for it, but if I’m paying in bitcoins, I have to be concerned at what price I got the bitcoins.”
You’re holding some risk as you hold onto bitcoin, he said.
Mr. Robison thinks clutching those pesky bitcoins has made him savvier in his own finances.
“I like to think my relationship with money has, if anything, become more conservative and deliberate. I was not quite 30 when I got involved with bitcoin for the first time and was financially still pretty immature,” he said.
“I think that today I’m a better investor and better curator of my personal finances than I might otherwise have been without a little trial by fire.”
Courtney Linder: clinder@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1707. Twitter: @LinderPG.
Join the Tech.pgh Community!



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.