The blowback — and the accolades — came fast and furious after Congress completed its overturning of the nation’s strongest internet privacy protections for individuals.

The House vote Tuesday allowing telecommunications companies to track and sell a customer’s online information with greater ease, after earlier Senate approval, is either freeing up the market or allowing internet highway robbery, making the rules more clear or doing away with them, depending on who is talking.

The House voted 215-to-205, largely along party lines, in favor of dismantling rules created by the Federal Communications Commission in October. Those rules, which had been slated to go into effect later this year, had required broadband providers to get permission before collecting data on a user’s online activities.

President Donald Trump is expected to sign the bill into law.

Advertise with us

U.S. Rep. Mike Doyle of Forest Hills has been one of the leading Democrats on the issue.

“Broadband providers see literally everything you do online. Without these rules, these companies don’t have to ask before selling all that information. They don’t have to take reasonable measures to protect that information when they collect it,” Mr. Doyle said Tuesday in a speech on the House floor. He said Internet service providers have an obligation to protect the privacy of their customers.

Read More

Mr. Doyle elaborated during an interview Wednesday, saying the vote blocks three simple rules. Those rules would have required broadband companies to ask customers before sharing web browsing histories, to have reasonable safeguards to protect their data, and notify them in case of a breach.

“This is a net loss for consumers,” Mr. Doyle said.

Republicans say they are correcting a problem caused by a power grab by the Federal Trade Commission which, they say, stripped power from the Federal Communications Commission when it reclassified Internet service providers as common carriers.

Advertise with us

The result was two different sets of rules for providers and search engines.

U.S. Rep. Tim Murphy, R-Upper St. Clair, said the FTC rules are ineffective because they applied only to service providers and not search engines or social media sites.

The measure Mr. Murphy supported “requires all segments of the Internet to be on equal footing with a consistent set of privacy rules, ensuring the smaller ISPs play by the same rules as the bigger players like Facebook and Google,” said his spokeswoman Carly Atchison.

Interest in internet privacy tools spiked in recent weeks with focus on the congressional action, according to a Colorado company that sells internet encryption services.

“We do not log anything,” said Caleb Chen, digital currency advocate at Denver-based software company Private Internet Access. “Privacy and trust is our reputation.”

Advertise with us

Mr. Chen said the spike in inquiries to his company began around March 7 when repeal discussions got underway and the surge in interest was continuing. Despite the potential to increase revenue from the repeal, PIA has been lobbying against rule change, including taking out three full-page ads in the New York Times, he said.

“In the short term, we might benefit, but it’s really the beginning of a long, slippery slope” to shrinking privacy, he said. “We don’t want to go there.”

Virtual private networks, like the one marketed by PIA, keep secret the sites consumers visit and other information, making them an option to prevent internet service providers from selling personal information to advertisers and others. The vote in Congress repealed rules preventing the use of private data by outside agencies.

Advocates for the rule change say the repeal will provide revenue for big broadband infrastructure improvements. But David Farber, an adjunct professor of computer science at Carnegie Mellon University, said that may not happen without written agreements with internet service providers.

“Consumers need protection,” Mr. Farber said. “Unless there’s something in writing, sworn on a stack of FCC regulations, don’t hold your breath.”

Advertise with us

With the rules, consumer social security numbers, location, internet browsing history and other private information could be delivered to advertisers for marketing purposes. Even the collection of such data poses risks, according to Evan Greer, campaign director for Fight for the Future, a nonprofit internet freedom group based in Worcester, Mass.

“Once that data is collected and stored, it’s incredibly vulnerable to hackers and thieves,” she said. “It’s putting people at risk.”

“Your Internet service provider is the portal that everything goes through. It literally sees everything you do. They know every website you visited and how many times,” Mr. Doyle said.

People who buy that information from them “can see patterns develop. They’d be able to know where a person is when they’re online. They’d know your financial information, your personal data and have information about when your children are on the web and when they’re not.”

A spokesman for U.S. Rep. Bill Shuster, R-Everett, said the legislation allows both the FCC and FTC to retain their authorities to protect consumer privacy.

Advertise with us

The congressman “supported the resolution because the original rule by the Obama administration was poorly drafted. It unfairly punished one segment of this critical and growing industry,” Casey Contres said. “When it comes to the Internet, we need more innovation, not misguided government regulation.”

Others are counting on the market to regulate itself.

“Individuals and businesses operating within the context of the free market have a shared interest in protecting consumers’ privacy,” U.S. Rep. Keith Rothfus, R-Sewickley, said in a written statement. “This is demonstrated by the many Internet service providers that voluntarily include an opt-in option in their privacy clauses, which requires affirmative consent from the consumer regarding the use of consumer data and thereby empowers consumers to decide if and when their data is shared.”

Mr. Doyle said that can’t work when 82 percent of American households are serviced by only one provider.

“If you don’t like Google you can use Bing, and if you don’t like Bing you can use DuckDuckGo, but with ISPs” most people have no choice, he said.

Advertise with us

Having lost the battle on the House floor, Mr. Doyle is now seeking a presidential veto.

He and U.S. Rep. Mike Capuano, D-Mass., started an online petition at WhiteHouse.gov.

A spokeswoman for the White House did not respond to a request for comment.

The New York Times contributed. Tracie Mauriello: tmauriello@post-gazette.com. Kris Mamula: kmamula@post-gazette.com.