 Share
the risk, share the pain
Thursday, January 21, 1999
The concept was a novel one to Western Pennsylvania hospitals nearly two years ago when
AHERF entered a "risk-sharing" contract with HealthAmerica, the region's
second-largest managed care insurer.
Insurers, of course, have always been in the business of taking financial risk. Not so
for hospitals. Under the new agreement, however, AHERF's hospitals, in effect, took on
some of the insurer's function.
Hospitals engaged in "risk-sharing" give up the traditional promise of fees
for every service they provide and every treatment they perform. Instead, they accept a
fixed price, usually a percentage of the premiums a health plan charges its members, for
all of the treatments and services that those members will need.
By doing so, the hospitals expose themselves to the same risk the insurer takes: that
the health care may cost more money than they receive.
There is, of course, an upside, or hospitals would never sign these pacts. Just as
insurers may take in more premium dollars than they expend on claims, the hospitals may
get more money from the insurers than they have to spend on treatments and services. That
is especially true if they have lean overhead and treat patients in the most
cost-effective ways.
That was not the case for AHERF. The foundation has acknowledged that the risk-sharing
contracts it signed here, with HealthAmerica, and in Philadelphia, with U.S. Healthcare
and Independence Blue Cross, incurred steep losses.
|