Freddie Steinmark’s story has been called a “Brian’s Song” for college football.

But “My All American,” the movie based on his triumph on the University of Texas football team and battle with grave illness, spends too much time on the gridiron. That means too little time exploring the source of Freddie’s grit, courage and selflessness, not to mention attitudes about racial injustice and the Vietnam War in the late 1960s and early ’70s.

'My All American'

Ratings explained

Advertise with us

Starring: Finn Wittrock, Aaron Eckhart.

Rating: PG for thematic elements, language and brief partial nudity.

It also ignores less inspirational and more dolorous developments, spelled out in the source book, Jim Dent’s “Courage Beyond the Game: The Freddie Steinmark Story.” They don’t diminish how heroic or beloved he was, but they do humanize him.

“My All American” stars Finn Wittrock as Freddie, a Colorado high school athlete whose accomplishments outstripped his size of 5 feet 9 and 150 pounds. His speed, fearlessness and determination persuade coach Darrell Royal (Aaron Eckhart) to give him a shot at the University of Texas.

As the movie builds to the “Big Shootout” between the Longhorns and the Arkansas Razorbacks in December 1969, the leg pain plaguing the star safety can no longer be ignored. Anyone familiar or even unfamiliar with the real story knows this will not turn out well, and all those plans with girlfriend Linda Wheeler (Sarah Bolger) may turn to ashes.

Advertise with us

With “Rudy” and “Hoosiers” to his writing credit, Angelo Pizzo knows how to dramatize underdogs with heart, but this story doesn’t have the same sort of traditionally triumphant ending. That means jump-cutting to the conclusion, relying on an overpowering score reminiscent of Michel Legrand’s for “Brian’s Song” and painting Freddie as too much of a saint.

“My All American,” blessed with Mr. Wittrock, who personifies Freddie’s fighting spirit, crosses the goal line, but you wish for more grace, finesse and insight along the way.

Movie editor Barbara Vancheri: bvancheri@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1632. Read her blog: www.post-gazette.com/madaboutmovies.