In his latest novel, “The Fifth Gospel,” (Simon & Schuster, $25.99), Ian Caldwell weaves a mystery tale centered around the murky history of the Shroud of Turin.
The Shroud is purported by some biblical scholars to have been the garment used to wrap the body of Jesus Christ after his crucifixion. The history and varied ownership of the garment could rival Hammett's Maltese Falcon as an object so desired that foul play can easily be a by-product of eventual ownership.
The year is 2004 and Mr. Caldwell opens his tale with the death of a museum curator in Rome. The curator, Ugo Nogara, was killed by a single gunshot wound to the head. He had been scheduled to open a new exhibit which was rumored to have new information about the Shroud.
When police arrive at the scene of Nogara's death, a priest named Father Simon Andreou is next to the corpse. He gives the investigators a description of his discovery of the body.
Both Father Simon and his priest brother, Father Alex Andreou, were acquaintances of Nogara. Both men had some idea of what Nogara's exhibit was supposed to unveil. Father Simon is a Roman Catholic prelate, and Father Alex is a Greek Orthodox priest.
Nogara's exhibit concerns something called the Diatessaron, otherwise called the Fifth Gospel. In the way that Mr. Caldwell presents it, the Fifth Gospel is a a compilation or summary of the four gospels of Matthew, Mark, Luke and John.
Meanwhile, only a short time after Nogara's death, Father Simon is arrested and charged with Nogara's murder. During Simon's incarceration, it becomes increasingly clear to Father Alex that his brother is being framed as part of a larger scheme. He thinks the entire episode revolves around the upcoming opening of the dead man's exhibit.
In addition to providing a multi-layered mystery, Mr. Caldwell has also provided a good dose of biblical history, especially of the four books which begin the New Testament. As Father Alex goes about his investigation aimed at exonerating his brother, there are frequent references and quotes from the four gospels.
Mr. Caldwell takes the reader along on a tutorial of what he feels are key passages from the gospels needed to understand the history of the Shroud of Turin. It isn't such an involved tutorial that one has to be a biblical scholar or even a Christian in order to follow the information the author provides as a backdrop to the mystery.
The history of the Shroud of Turin goes back many centuries, and there has been much debate over the years regarding where it first appeared after the death of Christ and who took ownership.
It is widely accepted that one of the early possessors of the shroud were officials of the Eastern Orthodox Catholic Church. This is a branch of Catholicism which is separate from Roman Catholicism. According to Mr. Caldwell, the shroud was taken from Orthodox ownership when Roman soldiers pillaged Turin during the 13th century Crusades and took the garment. Its proper ownership has been in question ever since.
The provenance and history of an historical artifact is not something new to Mr. Caldwell. In the best-seller “The Rule of Four,” Mr. Caldwell and co-author Dustin Thomason built their novel around an obscure 15th century text called Hypnerotomachia Poliphili. The document in question is one of the factors in the solution to a murder mystery.
As the answer to the mystery in “The Fifth Gospel” draws closer to a solution, Mr. Caldwell juxtaposes the history of the priest brothers and the history of the two branches of the Catholic Church. The author here is trying to show how differences in the two sects don't negate the underlying fact that there is still some shared belief among the two sides.The two brothers respect each other's fundamental beliefs. The resolution of the case demonstrates how much they care for each other.
Steve Novak is a freelance writer living in Cleveland.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.