Among those who've added to the gaiety of nations and increased the public stock of harmless pleasure (thanks, Dr. Johnson), few rank higher than the team of W.S. Gilbert (words) and Arthur Sullivan (music), who together created 14 comic operettas, 1871-96, most of which have pretty continuously held the stage since.
"The Pirates of Penzance," "H.M.S. Pinafore" and "The Mikado" are the most popular, but five or six more are just as good, including my favorites, "Trial by Jury" and "Iolanthe." It is "Iolanthe" with which the Pittsburgh Savoyards, in their 70th season, have just returned to the Andrew Carnegie Free Library Music Hall in Carnegie, after several years of exile in the North Hills.
Indeed, in the 40 years I've been going to Savoyards' shows, they've had many homes, from the Ellis School to the HazÂlett to Antonian Hall. I think the Music Hall, on a hill above downtown Carnegie, suits them best, even though it lacks a proper orchestra pit, because it has a period grace that echoes G&S's own.
Not that the G&S operettas are just pretty. Their chief pleasure lies in the contrast between prettiness and melody on the one hand, and satire and surrealism on the other, heartily mocking the self-satisfaction of high Victorian institutions.
'Iolanthe, or, the Peer and the Peri'
- Where:Pittsburgh Savoyards at Andrew Carnegie Free Library Music Hall, Carnegie.
- When: Fri.-Sat. 8 p.m., Sun. 2:30 p.m.
- Tickets: $8-$17
- More information: pittsburghsavoyards.org or 412-734-8476.
In "Iolanthe," mockery aims chiefly at the House of Lords and the Law, especially the Court of Chancery, presided over by a Lord Chancellor who is all snarled up in his affections for a pretty ward. But there is also aesthetic parody of fairyland escapism, as variously found in formal 18th century pastoral, Shakespeare, Wagner and Mendelssohn.
The specific absurdity is that the Chancellor and the entire House of Lords (or at least the dozen the Savoyards put on stage) are in pursuit of Phyllis, a Dresden china shepherdess who is committed to Strephon, a generic Arcadian shepherd who turns out to be half fairy, half mortal.
Iolanthe, his mother, has been banished to a nearby stream to live among the frogs (a joke about the French) because she got involved with a mortal, but the Brunnhilde-like Fairy Queen pardons her, and the fairies conspire to help Strephon's pursuit of Phyllis by sending him into Parliament to torment the feckless Lords.
The plot gets even more convoluted, the better to lavish ridicule on every side. But the power of Sullivan's music is such that even as it bristles with Gilbert's verbal wit it sings with both joy and pathos.
The Savoyards are a kind of community theater writ large, with more than the usual resources, including a volunteer orchestra of two dozen under the experienced leadership of Guy Russo. Apparently there were a few strings missing at the matinee I saw, but my forgiving ear was generally happy, and I already love the score, one of Sullivan's most effervescent and inventive.
Another resource is first-time (with the Savoyards) director Sally Denmead, who has assembled a stronger than usual ensemble of Lords (the men) and Fairies (the women). She is also responsible for the most ambitious and generally successful choreography I can remember in recent Savoyards years.
Rachel Myers is outstanding as Phyllis, with a full measure of calculating innocence and a handsome soprano. Justin Thomas Zeno is a more-than-usually comical Strephon, and Corey Nile Wingard and Jeffrey Gross are delightfully obtuse as the lead Lords.
Chief comic duties fall to Jonah Winter's Lord Chancellor, well-characterized but lacking something in vocal volume, and Janette Patterson-Schafer's Queen of the Fairies, faint of character but vocally impressive.
Denmead plays the text straight, without the tinkering you sometimes find, providing a program glossary for intriguing obscurities. But at the performance I saw, she did substitute a verse in recognition of a visiting group from West Virginia for the address to Capt. Shaw. She also provides a choreographed backstory during the overture, and I saw a number of new physical jokes.
I'd call it a successful blend of the traditional and the new, with the G&S appeal intact. Long may they wave!
Post-Gazette senior theater critic Christopher Rawson can be reached at crawson@post-gazette.com.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.