
Ken Caine wasn’t sure if he’d be able to return to playing hockey after his knee replacement.
“I knew people that still struggled after a knee replacement — and I kind of resigned myself to that — but then I said, ‘I’m going to work as hard as I can,’” said Caine, 66, of Crafton. “If I couldn’t get back to it, I told myself that would be OK, too. I just had to accept whatever the outcome was.”
To Caine’s surprise, he found himself back on the ice three months later, participating in the Friday evening pickup hockey league he runs at Robert Morris University.
With every glide, he gained confidence.
“I remember the puck went in the corner, and I was skating down with a guy behind me. Either I’m going to wipe out horribly, or I’m going to be able to make this sharp turn and get around behind the net,” he said. “I made the turn. The knee felt perfect, strength was no issue, and I was like, ‘I’m back.’”
For the more than 700,000 total knee replacements performed annually in the U.S., according to the American Academy of Orthopaedic Surgeons, not all patients have the same experience as Caine, who received his knee replacement in January 2024 at UPMC Shadyside. At UPMC, ongoing research projects and advanced surgical approaches to knee replacements, including minimally invasive techniques, cementless replacements and robotic-assisted technology, are helping patients recover more quickly, leave the hospital sooner and return to their daily lives.
A new knee
For Caine, the right knee pain started around 2021.
He saw Melissa McLane, an assistant professor in UPMC’s orthopaedic surgery department, who first prescribed cortisone shots followed by platelet-rich plasma injections, common treatments used before resorting to joint replacement.
That surgery involves removing parts of an arthritic or damaged joint and replacing them with a metal, plastic or ceramic device designed to replicate the movement of a healthy joint, according to the American Academy of Orthopaedic Surgeons. While hips and knees are the most commonly performed joint replacements, other joints can also be replaced such as the ankle, wrist, shoulder and elbow.
Osteoarthritis — caused by the gradual breakdown of cartilage in a joint — is the most common reason for knee replacement. Rheumatoid arthritis and post-traumatic arthritis stemming from an injury can also damage the joint enough to require replacement.
Brian Klatt, who performed Caine’s surgery and serves as chief of the Division of Orthopaedic Surgery at UPMC East, said that while a replacement is designed to mimic a knee joint, a functioning natural knee is still better. However, when knee pain begins preventing patients from doing the things they want to do, it may be time to consider surgery.
Caine received injections every six months, but, eventually, his knee gave out.
“One day I was playing, and kind of the knee just gave out and said, ‘That’s it, you’re done,’” he recalled. “I couldn’t put any pressure on it, and then it hurt, so I knew then. I said, ‘OK, I’ve taken this as far as I possibly could.’”

McLane referred Caine to Klatt. X-rays showed that the cartilage in Caine’s knee had worn down to the point that the joint was bone on bone.
“If the [patient] has end-stage arthritis, where they’re bone on bone, or they’ve got changes in their knee, and they’ve tried to manage it with nonoperative measures — anti-inflammatories, physical therapy, injections or bracing — and it’s not giving them the relief they want and they can’t do the things they want to do in life, then it comes time to start talking about a replacement-type procedure,” Klatt said.
Caine said at that point, the decision ultimately became clear.
“[Klatt] said, ‘You’re bone on bone, perfect candidate. Let’s have the knee surgery,’” Caine said. “So I did.”
Out with the old, in with the new
When Caine scheduled his surgery, he learned he would be receiving a cementless knee replacement, a type of implant designed with a porous surface that allows the patient’s bone to grow into it over time rather than relying on bone cement to secure it in place.
Caine, who was 64 at the time, did not smoke and had good bone strength, factors that made him a candidate for the cementless approach, Klatt said. His desire to return to an active lifestyle also played a role.
“There’s several different implants that are a little more — I call it congruent — but they allow for the person to feel more natural when they’re doing sports, and then it’s grown to the bone, so it won’t fail from the cement breaking down with them doing these types of activities,” Klatt said. “That’s one of the reasons why I’m comfortable letting Ken be very active on that knee.”
Caine’s surgery only took 57 minutes.
Then, he remembers waking up in the recovery room.
“When I woke up, I was still on whatever pain medicine, and I could move that knee all around, and it didn’t hurt,” he said. “I said, ‘This is pretty sweet here. This is nice.’”
Caine was able to return home the same day.
“They said, ‘Well, you could stay the extra night if you want,’ and I said, ‘No. There’s a Penguins game on TV tonight. I’m going to go home.’”

Patients in good health with fewer medical comorbidities — like Caine — are often candidates for same-day discharge, Klatt said. Before leaving, patients typically complete a physical therapy session, demonstrate they can safely move around, eat a meal and successfully urinate.
Same-day discharge after joint replacement was far less common 15 years ago, Klatt said. Advances in medication and anesthesia have helped change that.
One is tranexamic acid, a medication used to reduce bleeding during surgery, which Klatt said has helped reduce blood loss and swelling. Local anesthetic nerve blocks and spinal anesthesia have also improved pain control after surgery.
Caine was pleasantly surprised by his mobility following the procedure.
“It hurt, but I could go up and down the steps,” he said. “I could sit and watch TV. I could have dinner. I was mobile, and not fast, but I was able to get around.”
The road back to the ice
While the surgery itself was over in less than an hour, Klatt said recovery requires a much longer commitment from the patient.
“The work that you do is more important sometimes than the work we do,” Klatt said. “If we do our job right, we’re really just about an hour. But their job can take months to fully recover, regain their function, regain their muscles and be back to normal.”
For Caine, that work began almost immediately. He had in-home physical therapy for the first two weeks before working with Juliane Russell, a physical therapist at UPMC Rehabilitation Institute in Green Tree, who he had previously seen for other injuries.
“She worked me hard,” Caine said. “I said, ‘Come on, Julie, let’s go.’ So I had a good relationship already with her.” Joking, he added: “And she put me in a lot of pain.”
Caine committed to physical therapy six days a week. Two months after surgery, Caine asked Klatt if he could return to the ice. Klatt wasn’t ready to clear him yet, so Caine waited another month.
During that final month, his physical therapy became increasingly tailored to hockey.
“I brought a hockey stick into the physical therapy clinic,” Caine said. “We actually worked on some skating techniques and some skating things to strengthen those muscles to be able to get back on the ice. Skating backwards, forwards, different exercises like that.”
Three months after surgery, Klatt cleared him to skate. Regaining confidence in his new knee happened gradually.
“It was step by step,” Canie said. “OK, you can do this, then you can start to do this a little more in the knee, then you can do this. And now I do everything I want to do.”
Some of his teammates now tell him he is skating better than he had in the years leading up to surgery.
Recovery and monitoring continue well beyond the first few months. Klatt said he typically sees knee replacement patients at two and six weeks, to monitor their function and progress with physical therapy. He then follows them at one year, two years and every five years afterward to watch for wear or other problems.
Changing joint replacements
Joint replacement technology continues to evolve, with robotics and improvements in cementless implants among the biggest changes, Klatt said.
“It is much more common for a knee to be done robotically, but it doesn’t need to be,” Klatt said. “I do about half and half, but we’re doing more and more [revision] knee [replacements] with robotics, which gives us an advanced ability to cut the bone when there’s deficient bone. I think that’s a really big advancement.”
Robotic-assisted surgery gives surgeons another tool to plan bone cuts and balance the knee based on a patient’s individual anatomy. UPMC researchers are studying how robotic procedures compare with traditional surgery, as well as how the way a knee is balanced during surgery affects its function afterward.
Klatt said infection is another major focus of ongoing research within the health system.
UPMC participated in a study of a rapid, two-stage approach to treating joint replacement infections, in which an infected implant is removed, a patient receives high-dose antibiotics for about a week and a new implant is placed.
Researchers are also participating in a study with Peptilogics, a biotech company based on the South Side, examining a solution designed to disrupt biofilms — communities of bacteria that can make infections difficult to treat.
“A biofilm is what causes infections to become chronic,” Klatt said. “The bacteria are able to build a membrane to protect themselves. This company has a product they believe disrupts that biofilm and can be used safely in humans.”
UPMC is among the early centers participating in the study and has treated the second-highest number of patients in the country so far, according to Klatt.
Back to what matters
Now, more than two years after surgery, Caine is back to doing the things he loves — and hockey is only one of them.
“I’m doing a bunch of other stuff, too,” he said. “I go kayaking. I’m a lifeguard, so I go swimming all the time.”
His left knee is now approaching bone on bone, and Caine continues receiving injections in hopes of delaying another replacement. He hopes he won’t need another surgery, but after his experience with the first, he knows he would do it again if necessary.
“My recommendation is: Listen to exactly what your doctors tell you, and your physical therapy people, and work hard,” Caine said. “Don’t go out searching the internet for some get-healed-quick fix or something, because there’s no quick fix. It’s just you got to work and do it hard.”
Perhaps the biggest measure of success for Caine comes during summertime at his family’s house on Lake Erie, where he can once again keep up with his grandchildren.
“Before, I couldn’t even take a walk on the beach with them, and now I’m like, ‘Let’s go for a walk,’” Caine said. “We’ll walk a mile or two.”
Ava Dzurenda (ava.dzurenda@gmail.com) is a science writer and exercise physiologist based in Squirrel Hill.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.