
Just three games into her junior season at Upper St. Clair High School, Rylee Kalocay had already reached a major basketball milestone: The 17-year-old became the youngest player in school history to score 1,000 points.
Then, on Jan. 2, 2024 — the first game back from winter break — Kalocay planted her left leg while driving toward the baseline, and her knee gave out.
An MRI the next day confirmed she had torn her anterior cruciate ligament, or ACL, and meniscus.
“I thought the world was gonna end,” Kalocay, now 19, said. “I was so angry. I wasn’t even as upset as I was just mad at the fact that I didn’t know what I was gonna do.”
Kalocay underwent ACL reconstruction and meniscus repair at UPMC Shadyside later that month, performed by Dharmesh Vyas, a UPMC orthopaedic sports medicine surgeon. Seven and a half months later, she was back on the basketball court.
Now, the Upper St. Clair native is a sophomore combo guard at Eastern Kentucky University in Richmond, Ky.
Her recovery reflects an individualized approach to ACL reconstruction, shaped in part by decades of research and innovation at UPMC.
The late Freddie Fu’s work on double-bundle ACL reconstruction marked a turning point, helping shift the field toward restoring each patient’s unique anatomy. Today, UPMC researchers continue to study ways to improve reconstruction and reduce reinjury, including different grafts and procedures designed to better protect the reconstructed ligament.
That work is particularly relevant for young female athletes like Kalocay, who face a higher risk of ACL tears than their male counterparts.
A more individualized approach
When an athlete has a torn ACL, determining the best reconstruction depends on a variety of factors, said Bryson Lesniak, associate professor of orthopaedic surgery at UPMC.
“It is actually really important to take the whole picture into consideration, meaning the athlete, gender, the imaging — between X-ray radiographs, MRI — what sport they play, what position within the sport they play, what their expectations are and what their level of return to sport is,” he said.

In ACL reconstruction, a graft is typically taken from the patellar, quadriceps or hamstring tendon, and small tunnels are drilled into the femur and tibia to anchor the new ligament.
Which graft is used depends on the patient.
“There’s not one that’s the perfect graft, and that’s because there’s always going to be some donor-site morbidity when you take something from the knee and put it in as your ACL,” Lesniak said in a video interview.
Patellar tendon grafts have a long history of research and are commonly used in high-level athletes.
“The patellar tendon graft tends to be used in elite athletes, professional sports, especially in the United States, the NFL, the NBA, Major League Baseball, and then comparable women’s leagues like the WNBA, women’s soccer, etc.,” Lesniak said. “There’s a lot of history and scientific evidence that allows physicians to lean on that graft as a workhorse in our kind of performance athletes.”

Kalocay received a patellar tendon graft, though she admitted she was hesitant at first.
“I was terrified to do the [patellar tendon],” Kalocay said in a video interview. “I really thought it was best to do a muscle, because that’s what I heard everybody doing.”
But after discussing the options with Vyas, Kalocay trusted his recommendation.
“He was just so personable and really wanted me to understand why every option he had in mind was the best option,” she said.
Graft preferences have shifted over time. Lesniak said hamstring tendon grafts have become less common in his practice and among many of his colleagues, while quadriceps tendon grafts have gained popularity.
Recent research has documented a similar shift among ACL specialists. A 25-year survey of members of the ACL Study Group, published in February in the Journal of ISAKOS, found hamstring graft preference peaked at 62% in 2014 before declining to 48% in 2023, while quadriceps tendon graft preference rose to 20%.
Age can also play a role in graft selection. Lesniak said surgeons have moved away from using donor tissue — known as an allograft — in young, active patients because of a higher risk of failure.
Research also supports that concern. A 2020 systematic review and meta-analysis of patients 19 and younger found allografts were nearly four times as likely to fail as autografts, or tissue taken from the patient’s own body.
For older athletes, however, Lesniak said donor tissue may still be an option — another example of why there is no single ACL reconstruction that works best for every patient.
Searching for fewer retears
At UPMC, Lesniak said ACL research is “always going on.”
Much of that work builds on the legacy of Fu, former chair of the orthopaedic surgery department at the University of Pittsburgh School of Medicine and UPMC, whose research into double-bundle ACL reconstruction — which sought to re-create both bundles of the ACL individually to stabilize the knee — marked a turning point in how surgeons approached the injury.
While the technique itself is not commonly performed today, Lesniak said the research helped shift the field toward a greater focus on restoring a patient’s individual anatomy — and helped shape much of the ACL research that followed.
“Dr. Fu’s legacy, and thereby UPMC’s ACL legacy as it pertains to double bundle, is that it really forced orthopaedic surgeons that did ACL surgery at that time to really refocus on how we do ACLs in general,” Lesniak said.
Today, one focus is finding ways to reduce the risk that a reconstructed ACL will tear again.
One area of research involves adding extra support to the outside of the knee during ACL reconstruction. Known as a lateral extra-articular procedure, or LEAP, the technique uses additional tissue to help reduce rotational stress on the reconstructed ACL.
Research published in 2025 in the Journal of Clinical Medicine found that adding a LEAP to ACL reconstruction can reduce graft failure and rotational instability, particularly in high-risk patients.
An international trial enrolled more than 1,200 patients, who received either a patellar or quadriceps tendon ACL reconstruction. Half also received the additional lateral procedure. Researchers will compare outcomes and failure rates between the groups after follow-up is completed.
“We expect that to be a future landmark paper over the next several years,” Lesniak said.
Researchers are also studying how a patient’s anatomy may increase the likelihood that a reconstructed ACL will fail.
One factor is the posterior tibial slope, or the angle of the top of the shin bone. A steeper slope has been associated with a higher risk of ACL reconstruction failure, Lesniak said.
For patients who tear a reconstructed ACL and have a particularly steep tibial slope, surgeons may alter the alignment of the bone during revision surgery to reduce the risk of another failure. While it’s a larger procedure than an ACL reconstruction alone, Lesniak said it has been demonstrated to improve outcomes in high-risk patients.
“We’re always trying to go as close as we can get to zero failure,” he said. “Obviously, in our world, zero percent failure rate doesn’t really exist. But it’s that golden ring out there we’re trying to get to.”

Why female athletes are at greater risk
Kalocay’s injury happened without another player crashing into her, a common mechanism for an injury that disproportionately affects young female athletes.
Female athletes have a significantly higher risk of ACL injury than males participating in comparable sports, Lesniak said, with teenage athletes among those at greatest risk.
But there isn’t one clear explanation for the disparity.
“There’s a lot of theories, and there’s some evidence for a lot of them, but there’s not one overarching reason,” Lesniak said.
Researchers have studied a combination of anatomical, hormonal and biomechanical factors, including differences in knee alignment, joint laxity and Q angle — a measurement of the alignment between the thigh, knee and lower leg.
How athletes move may matter, too. Studies have found differences in how male and female athletes jump and land, Lesniak said, which can place different forces on the knee.
Erica B. Coffey, a physical therapist at UPMC Rooney Sports Complex, said strength and sports participation may also play a role.
“I don’t think that we necessarily know all of the reasons,” Coffey said in a video interview. “There’s certainly discussions about hormones, there’s discussions about Q angle, and there’s discussions about strength and sports specialization.”
Athletes who specialize in one sport at younger ages may be more susceptible to injury, she said. At the same time, participating in high-level sports more frequently creates more opportunities for injury.
Some of those risks can be addressed.
A 2025 meta-analysis published in Annals of Medicine of randomized trials found neuromuscular training programs reduced ACL injury risk by about 50% among female team-sport athletes. Lesniak said those strategies are incorporated into strength and conditioning programs for female athletes at UPMC medicine-led universities.
“You can affect ACL rupture rate in high-risk athletes with preventative programs,” he said.
The long road back
A successful ACL reconstruction doesn’t end in the operating room. Rehabilitation can begin before surgery and continue for months afterward.
Before her surgery, Kalocay began “prehab,” working to strengthen the muscles surrounding her injured knee. A 2022 review, published in Arthroscopy, Sports Medicine, and Rehabilitation, found four to six weeks of prehabilitation can improve strength and range of motion after surgery and may improve the timing and likelihood of returning to sport.
Coffey said the goal of prehab is to reduce swelling, restore range of motion and regain control of the quadriceps.
Rehabilitation for Kalocay resumed the day after surgery. Five days later, she still couldn’t lift her leg straight.
“I can’t lift up my leg. What do I do?” she remembered asking Vyas.
“Yes, you can,” he told her. “You’re in your head. You need to lock in.”
With Vyas’ hand on her quadriceps, Kalocay tried again. Her leg lifted.
From there, she progressed quickly. By seven months, she began playing with contact, and, about two weeks later, she returned to competition.
Before athletes return to sport, Coffey said physical therapists assess strength, jumping, sprinting and agility, gradually progressing them from individual skills to full contact.
For Kalocay, strength testing eventually showed her reconstructed left leg was stronger than her right.
“She’s good to go 110%,” Kalocay recalled her physical therapist writing when he cleared her.
“I thought I was gonna be scared at first,” she said, referring to returning to basketball. “But as soon as I was in the game, it just went back to normal.”
Now playing Division I basketball at Eastern Kentucky, Kalocay said she feels stronger and more confident in her knee than ever.
“I’ve never felt better in my body in my life,” she said.
Ava Dzurenda (ava.dzurenda@gmail.com) is a science writer and exercise physiologist based in Squirrel Hill.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.