Every case of organ transplantation is miraculous. It’s “the gift of life,” as the tagline often goes, highlighting the preciousness of additional time.

But work behind the scenes is its own kind of wonder, especially when personal preferences or rare biological mismatches remove tools from a surgeon’s toolbox.

About one year ago, two UPMC surgeons — along with collaborators from myriad departments — performed a first-ever dual heart-kidney transplant on a patient who, for religious reasons, opted not to receive any blood products.

Heart transplants where a patient, by chance, didn’t require blood transfusion have occurred, likely even at UPMC. That’s a feat of its own, given a 2024 study looking specifically at blood transfusion in heart transplants, which found that 89.5% of the study population required donated blood.

Advertise with us

Kidney transplants don’t require transfusion nearly as often, but the nature of a dual transplant is more complex, making the availability of blood products — even if they aren’t used — a vital tool to produce good outcomes in most cases.

This patient, 56, who declined an interview, is a Jehovah’s Witness. That sect of Christianity points to Scripture throughout the Bible that “clearly command us to abstain from blood,” per the group’s website. And there are no exceptions.

So, when the patient’s longstanding heart failure worsened, causing poor functioning of other organs, particularly his kidneys, a dual transplant was the last option to save his life.

The physicians at his York County hospital contacted numerous high-level transplant centers around the country, hoping someone would be willing to take on this complicated case.

They all said no except for UPMC.

Advertise with us

“This was an otherwise fairly healthy person who seemed fairly robust,” said David Kaczorowski, surgical director of the UPMC Heart Transplant Program and co-lead surgeon on this case. “We felt this was someone we could help, and we wanted to give him every chance to get a transplant and successfully get through it.”

A discussion between the patient and UPMC’s Center for Bloodless Medicine and Surgery helped to determine which components of blood, if any, the patient was willing to accept.

“Some [Jehovah’s Witnesses] won’t even accept having their own blood returned to them, which would make a heart transplant impossible, because a cardiopulmonary bypass machine is used,” Kaczorowski said. “For many of them, it’s important that the blood stays in continuity with the body.”

“We felt this was someone we could help, and we wanted to give him every chance to get a transplant and successfully get through it,” says David Kaczorowski, surgical director of the Center for Advanced Heart Failure at the UPMC Heart and Vascular Institute. (Courtesy of UPMC)

UPMC transplant surgeons prepared for a theoretical case such as this one for about a year before this particular patient sought care. To further tailor the protocol, Kaczorowski collaborated with Vikraman Gunabushanam, UPMC abdominal transplant surgeon and assistant professor of surgery, and a few other specialists.

The protocol focuses on optimizing the patient’s red blood cells — the blood they already have — before surgery, meticulously monitoring and limiting blood loss during surgery and conserving as much blood as possible after surgery by strategically timing blood draws and using pediatric-sized, lower-volume tubes when blood is taken.

Advertise with us

Knowing that protocol relies on those who would care for the patient moment to moment in the post-operative period, the transplant team met with nursing leadership, then with nurses in the cardiothoracic intensive care unit in a town hall format.

“We really explained the rationale for doing this, explained the protocol for doing this, and then we moved forward with the transplant,” Kaczorowski said. “It’s hard to know which nurse is going to be on that day, or which nurse is going to get the assignment, so we had to broadly prepare for it.”

As the pre-heart transplant coordinator, Katelyn O’Connell helped guide this patient through all facets of his initial transplant-related care. She was qualified to do that because she spent several years as a nurse in the cardiac ICU, which allowed her to mentally put herself in the shoes of the nurses charged with his care.

“When you’re a bedside nurse, especially in the ICU, how often are you drawing blood on your patient? [A lot.] For these patients, you have to be a lot more cognizant of that and a lot more limiting,” she said.

Using her nursing skills as the pre-heart transplant coordinator, as she’s done for over four years, O’Connell has an appreciation for the courage it takes to think differently.

Advertise with us

“It’s just so wonderful to work at a transplant center that is willing to offer these opportunities to patients who previously would not have them,” she said. “I think it’s easy to have pretty strict guidelines, like if [patients] say no to blood products, we aren’t going to transplant them. But being able to think, ‘OK, they aren’t going to accept blood products, but how can we still make this happen?’ I think our program here does a really good job of meeting patients where they are.”

And this protocol promises to help far many more patients than just this one man.

Details of the protocol were published in the Journal for Heart and Lung Transplantation in March, making that information available to any medical professional hoping to help someone in a similar predicament.

Since the successful completion of the surgery — resulting in a patient who is still doing well, one year post-op — Kaczorowski and O’Connell have both noticed an uptick in bloodless heart transplant referrals.

And per Kaczorowski, the extreme emphasis on conserving blood — both the patient’s own and for transfusion — can positively influence best practices for all patients at all levels of care.

Advertise with us

“We believe that every heart is truly a gift. It’s priceless really. We don’t want to use them without discretion,” Kaczorowski said. “If we did a transplant on someone and that person passes, that’s really unfortunate and that heart could have been used for someone else. By the same token, it’s really important for us to help every patient as best as we can and also honor their religious preferences. In my view, I want to help everyone we can and respect their beliefs.”

Abby Mackey (abbyrose.mackey@gmail.com), a registered nurse, is a freelance writer based in the South Hills.