When Karl Joseph sustained a season-ending ligament tear in his left knee earlier this month playing safety for the West Virginia University football team, the Mountaineers had to figure out how they would replace a team leader and an all-Big 12 Conference performer.

Mr. Joseph had to figure out a lot more. What happens to a college athlete when he or she is taken away from the bright lights of a stadium and put under the light of an operating room? Who pays for the medical bills that accrue when student-athletes are injured representing their school?

The answers vary from school to school, and for some who follow college sports, that’s a problem.

“You’re talking about the health of players, you’re talking about their finances related to medical injuries and even the possibility they lose their educational opportunity because of an injury,” said Ramogi Huma, president of the National College Players Association, a California-based advocacy group for college athletes.

Advertise with us

“It’s a serious problem. What we’ve been advocating for are legal guarantees that require schools to pay for current and former players’ sports-related medical expenses. There’s more than enough money to do that.”

Though there is no uniform policy, the National Collegiate Athletic Association requires that all its athletes must have insurance for athletic-related injuries. But it does not spell out who pays for that insurance.

Most Division I, II and III programs have health insurance policies covering its athletes for sport-related injuries. While athletes at certain schools receive all the care they need, the system makes it possible for others at schools with less-comprehensive policies to either shoulder the financial burden or avoid important procedures altogether.

For injuries at West Virginia that result from team activities (such as games, practices and strength training), the athletic department’s insurance acts as a secondary insurance policy, covering deductibles and procedures not covered by an athlete’s personal insurance.

“There’s no out of pocket cost to the athletes,” said Dave Kerns, West Virginia’s football athletic trainer. “Our athletic insurance will pay deductibles, our insurance will pay for prescriptions and our insurance will pay for just about everything that we need covered.”

Advertise with us

A similar policy exists at the University of Pittsburgh. Penn State University did not respond to requests for an interview.

The NCAA does have a catastrophic injury program that covers all medical costs beyond a $90,000 deductible for any athlete, so there is some consistency in college sports. The program, according to the NCAA’s director of travel and insurance, Juanita Sheely, provides $20 million in lifetime benefits to athletes who become totally disabled while playing or practicing.

But even at schools where athletes are insured, cautionary tales prevail, such as the one of Kyle Hardrick, a former Oklahoma University basketball player whose scholarship wasn’t renewed in 2009 after he sustained a knee injury and whose family had to pay about $10,000 in medical bills.

For someone like Mr. Joseph, a WVU senior projected as a second- or first-round pick in the upcoming National Football League draft, such concerns don’t exist. But other athletes, especially those without multiyear scholarships, find themselves in a more vulnerable position.

“The whole system is so dysfunctional,” said Ellen Staurowsky, a sports management professor at Drexel University in Philadelphia. “These issues would be remedied if there were a players’ association that negotiated these issues up front with the association. It’s unfortunate we don’t have a system like that because we wouldn’t be coming at it from the worst-case scenario and then tracing back what actually happened.”

Advertise with us

Efforts to form a union for college athletes at Northwestern University — a cause that Mr. Huma and United Steelworkers brought to the National Labor Relations Board — failed earlier this year.

Short of a workers’ compensation program that would exist if athletes were recognized as employees, Mr. Huma and the NCPA are pushing for all schools to give written guarantees to recruits and parents about what kinds of coverage they have and how much of it they provide.

There’s also the issue of long-term care and how schools treat their athletes once they leave campus or their eligibility expires. At West Virginia, an injury is covered by the school for 52 weeks, regardless of whether that player is a freshman or senior. In the past year, the Big Ten and Pac-12 conferences announced plans to cover medical costs after players leave.

But for many who shoulder the effects and complications later in life, there is uncertainty.

“I haven’t heard really any anecdotal evidence of players getting treatment six, seven, eight years down the line from a school without any problems,” Mr. Huma said. “I don’t think that exists.”