MORGANTOWN, W.Va. – West Virginia clawed its way back from a listless first half and a multi-possession hole to get even with Oklahoma State late in the fourth quarter of a game it seemingly had to win to avoid a potential tailspin. With its back firmly against a wall, it had responded, and done so resoundingly.
It just came up a few plays short.
The Mountaineers (3-2, 0-2 Big 12), trailing by two touchdowns in the third quarter, fought back but were unable to get past the No. 21 Cowboys, who notched a 33-26 overtime victory Saturday night at Milan Puskar Stadium.
The loss is West Virginia’s second in a row, putting it in a dire position as it prepares for two top-five opponents, No. 3 Baylor (Oct. 17) and No. 2 TCU (Oct. 29), in the next three weeks.
“We challenged them, and we came out in the second half and played a lot better,” Mountaineers coach Dana Holgorsen said. “We were at a point where we could win. At the end of the day, it was not good enough.”
Without star safety Karl Joseph, who will miss the rest of the reason after injuring his knee in practice last Tuesday, the Mountaineers’ defense performed admirably, holding a Cowboys (6-0, 3-0) team averaging 483 yards and 42 points per game to 362 yards and 33 points. Oklahoma State quarterback Mason Rudolph, who entered the night sixth among Football Bowl Subdivision players in passing yards, was flustered for a good portion of the game, completing only 50 percent of his passes and throwing three interceptions.
But its offense was too inconsistent and dug West Virginia too deep of a hole to recover. Wendell Smallwood was impressive once again, rushing for 147 yards and a touchdown while playing through an ankle injury that kept him out of practice this week. But a lack of a run game beyond him, with only 108 yards from four other players, and an erratic showing from quarterback Skyler Howard largely stifled coach Dana Holgorsen’s attack.
Much of that could be tied to carelessness, as a team that breezed through its first three games with a lack of turnovers – two in all – has unraveled in the past two games, with a combined nine giveaways in losses to Oklahoma and Oklahoma State.
The errors against the Cowboys, just as they were against the Sooners, were costly.
Pinned inside his team’s own 10 in the first quarter, Howard, lined up in the shotgun formation, received a snap, but just as he was about to tuck the ball in and step back, he collided with Smallwood and the ball popped loose. Oklahoma State’s Emmanuel Ogbah fell on top of it in the end zone to give the Cowboys a 7-0 lead.
That would only mark the beginning of West Virginia’s woes.
At the very end of their first quarter, and on the first play of its drive, Ogbah stripped Rushel Shell on what would have been a five or six yard gain and Oklahoma State again recovered, this time on the West Virginia 28. A one-yard touchdown run from Rennie Childs barely one minute later doubled the Cowboys’ lead.
And that wouldn’t be the last of the self-inflicted wounds. On the Mountaineers’ next drive, Smallwood, their most reliable offensive threat for much of the night, fumbled at the Oklahoma State 7, denying West Virginia of points on its most promising drive of the night up to that point (though it would record a safety minutes later).
“If I could put one person on the bench because of it, I would,” Holgorsen said. “It was three different people. We work it every day, twice a day. We preach it. We talk about it. We just have to do a better job.”
The sloppy play didn’t completely disappear, but as the third quarter began, the Mountaineers’ once-anemic offense suddenly found some life.
Facing a fourth and seven on the Oklahoma State 40, Howard connected with freshman Jovon Durante for an 11-yard gain. Seconds after Durante went to the ground, West Virginia snapped the ball and handed it off to Smallwood, who scampered 29 yards through a rattled defense for its first offensive points of the game with 12:44 remaining in the quarter.
Though Oklahoma State tacked on another touchdown three minutes later, the Mountaineers quickly answered, getting a 48-yard touchdown pass from Howard to Shelton Gibson. After mustering only 147 total yards in the first half, West Virginia logged 144 on its first three drives of the quarter.
The Cowboys pushed their lead to 26-19 in the fourth quarter, but from there, the Mountaineers cobbled together what, at the time, seemed like their most important drive of the season. Behind Howard’s arm, West Virginia marched 68 yards in 2:45, punctuated by a three-yard run from Howard that ultimately forced the game into overtime.
On Oklahoma State’s first drive, with a fourth and one at the 2, backup quarterback J.W. Walsh ran up the middle for a score to put the Cowboys up seven. The Mountaineers drove to the Oklahoma State 4, but a seven-yard loss from Shell forced a fourth-and-goal from the 11.
“They had nine people in the box,” Holgorsen said. “That is one more than us. They had one extra guy. I could have thrown one-on-one on the outside, but I did that on the previous play, and they have corners that can cover pretty good. I decided to try to give the run.
“It was our game plan to run the ball on third down, and we didn’t really want it to be third and six on the six-yard line in overtime against a stacked box, that’s typically when we do something with the pass option that we have off of it. We did it twice in overtime, and we weren’t successful either time. I had to give the run game another chance. That’s kind of why we were in the position that we were in.”
After evading a pass rusher, Howard was unable to connect with Daikiel Shorts in the back left corner of the end zone.
Craig Meyer: cmeyer@post-gazette.com and Twitter @CraigMeyerPG.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.